Best Auto Repair in Bay Shore, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Repair companies out of 187 vetted & reviewed in the Bay Shore area.

M B Automotive

M B Automotive

(49)
  • Engine
  • Island
  • Reviews
“We do moving in the summer plowing in the winter so we have a lot of vehicles and equipment I first brought my personal car there which is a BMW and mike and his team did a great job on it at a fraction of what the dealer would've charged me.”
ASE, ASE Certified
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 2017
1460 N Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY
i
Brightside Automotive Repair

Brightside Automotive Repair

(48)
Oil Changes, Transmissions, NYS Inspections
“When driving in from out of state to try and catch a ferry to Fire Island, my break calipers on the front ends blew and the breaks began to heat up quick and stick.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2017
15 Ackerson St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

(50)
“You can't put a price on honesty with auto mechanics, and not only are they honest about what repairs you may need and a very reasonable cost, but they are very skilled and knowledgeable and the job gets done right the first time.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2016
1926 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
True Street Performance

True Street Performance

(47)
  • Knowledge
  • Questions
  • Review
“When I got the call it was done Jim explained the night before he just wasn't happy with something and had driven it along the day before and diagnosed a cracked oil cooler which he fixed at no additional cost because we had agreed to x amount "all i...”
In Business Since 2012
101 Cleveland Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
Great Neck Auto Tech

Great Neck Auto Tech

(47)
  • Mechanic
  • Book
  • Tire
“It is so comforting to have an auto repair facility that you never have to second guess and always know that you are getting the correct work done at a fair price.”
ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1996
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
Don Joe Auto Body

Don Joe Auto Body

(50)
  • Brand
  • Insurance Company
  • Pickup
“Don Joe was a real plasure to do business with on our car repair - we are greatly pleased with the work, their communications throughout and would highly recommend them to anyone in need of auto body repair.”
In Business Since 2021
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
Sagamore Collision

Sagamore Collision

(45)
“Oyster Bay BMW recommended I go to Sagamore where It was determined that there was no damage to exhaust and they buffed out the scratches for me immediately for no charge.”
In Business Since 2012
91 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY
i
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

(47)
  • Honest
  • Pickup
  • Communication
“They have deals on services frequently enough that getting work done on your car makes you feel responsible, rather than feeling like youre wasting a penny and trying to keep up.”
ASE Certified
Coupons & Offers
Family Business
In Business Since 2007
291 Bay Shore Rd, Deer Park, NY 11729
i
Jmr Garage

Jmr Garage

(21)
  • Price
“Let me tell you about this place the owners are really sincere and hard-working people so my story is I went in today with a malfunction on my car because something was stuck inside one of my driveshafts, and they were able to find the problem right ...”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2015
214 N Fehr Way, Bay Shore, NY
i
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

(29)
Scheduled Maintenance, Systems, Transmission
“I brought my 2003 Honda minivan in thinking the transmission needed to be rebuilt but Mark was so honest telling me all it needed was an electronic sensor component.”
ASE Certified
Coupons & Offers
Family Business
In Business Since 2015
1926 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
D&G Auto Repair and Services

D&G Auto Repair and Services

(38)
  • Labor
  • Honest
  • Quality
“Fair prices, they repair what your car needs, not like in other workshops that sell you expensive repairs that you do not need at that time, 100% recommended!”
In Business Since 2023
1924 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
i
John A Carucci Motors Inc

John A Carucci Motors Inc

(42)
  • Photo
  • Inspection
  • Job
“Been using John for years - he and Michael are great along with Oscar the mechanic - but, I guess they have decided it's time to relax - now we have Ricky who we already like - very nice guy good pricing and great work.”
1782 Union Blvd #1, Bay Shore, NY
i
Sunrise Collision and Towing

Sunrise Collision and Towing

(42)
  • Work
  • Morning
  • Brand
“They ended up declared it a total loss,, they then help us out about going about getting paid for the car so another 5 stars now its 2016 and there helping me a with a custom paint job on a trex if your reading all this look on there business page...”
Accepts Debit, Check, Cash, All Major Credit Cards, Insurance
In Business Since 1986
224 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
North Shore Auto & Towing Inc

North Shore Auto & Towing Inc

(26)
  • Audi
  • Door
  • Job
“So whether you are in a major accident or slight fender bender, knowing you have a trustworthy and professionally family run mechanic in the rolodex, is worth its weight in gold.”
In Business Since 1993
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
Pro Tech Benz

Pro Tech Benz

(29)
Repair and Full Servicing All Mercedes, Computer Diagnostics
“The other places tried to rip me off and fix what I even didn't need to fix in my Mercedes CLS 500, 2006 and Quintin was really honest and didn't give me any BS, and I am so happy I found him, it is so rare these days.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2014
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
All Island Auto Co

All Island Auto Co

(17)
“Honest staff came out to my car to make sure she had found the right part.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2004
4 Sweeneydale Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.

Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.

(15)
  • Prices
“I knew I needed tires replaced which they also did without a problem in only a few hours while I was at work!”
In Business Since 2012
2304 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
L & D Services Station Inc

L & D Services Station Inc

(21)
“It's very busy, the best part is they are honest not a lot of places like this left, I should be selfish and tell people to go elsewhere so the wait isn't so long but I can't they are to nice”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1969
Serving Bay Shore Area
i
Rev's Auto Services

Rev's Auto Services

(20)
  • Money
  • Vehicle
“Positive Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Carburetor cleaning, Electrical repair, Air & cabin filter replacement, Tires, Steering & suspension repair, General repairs & maintenance, Auto engine diagnostic, Auto engine tuning, Eng...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1998
91 Moffitt Blvd # A, Bay Shore, NY
i
Tom's Vette Shop Inc

Tom's Vette Shop Inc

(5)
  • Prices
“I have known Tom for many many years , he knows his stuff and his prices are better then catalog prices , very nice person and he will give you great advice .”
In Business Since 1995
81 Cleveland Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

(15)
  • Price
  • Mechanics
“They are fairly priced knowledgeable and very accommodating I used a mechanic for over 25 years till he retired so was quite nervous about trying someone new.”
14 Garfield Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
i
Gomez Auto Repair

Gomez Auto Repair

(13)
“This place is excellent, ask for Tony he is the best in all of bay shore and Brentwood”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
102 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY
i
Park Service At Sagamore

Park Service At Sagamore

(3)
“After looking for a new auto mechanic to replace a long trusted mechanic that closed shop, we were so very happy to find Eddie at Park Service at Sagamore........”
91 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY
i
I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC

I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC

(3)
“Good service”
98-2 Wisconsin Ct, Bay Shore, NY
i

Auto Repair Services in Bay Shore, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$300
Maximum cost
$2500
National Average
$460
Avg Per Hour Rates
$80
$370
$650
Average price range is based on 461 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $460
Minimum cost $300
Maximum cost $2500
Avg Per Hour Rates $80

Average range $370 to $650 is based on 461 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top