Best Auto Locksmiths near Brookhaven, NY
None of these locksmiths is based in Brookhaven; they work from Mastic (5 mi), Islandia (12 mi) and Kalamazoo, MI (660 mi).
10 locksmiths listed · 3 open 24/7 · all 10 open weekends · 7 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license
Data verified October 16, 2026
Hendrickson Towing and Recovery
Locksmith Men South Shore
East Island Locksmiths
Anytime Locksmith
Locksmith Men
Listed for drivers in and around Brookhaven, NY, these 10 shops are auto locksmiths. What each one says about lockouts, key cutting, programming and hours comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Brookhaven, NY
The 10 locksmiths on this page are rated from 3.0 to 5.0 across 2,416 reviews; 6 have 50 or more reviews and 7 are rated 4.5 or higher. 3 are open around the clock; 9 are open on Saturdays and 5 on Sundays. 2 show a license on their websites. 6 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 22 years. 4 offer emergency or roadside call-outs; 3 give free estimates and 3 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 8 of the locksmiths on this page; 7 publish a contact page and 4 list a public email. We count these figures across the locksmiths on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the locksmith before you book.
Which locksmiths listed for Brookhaven answer at night?
3 of the 10 shops list round-the-clock hours every day of the week. Lockouts are the classic 3 a.m. call and they are handled at the roadside. A lost key that needs programming usually waits for morning, when the paperwork can be checked and the right equipment is on board.
Mobile Key & Lock Locksmith
Long Island Auto Locksmith
American Lock and Garage
The Strutt
Why these companies made our list
What customers say about locksmiths near Brookhaven
- “Highly recommend Locksmith Men. Very prompt response time, they came to me and very professional.” — customer of Locksmith Men
- “Excellent and prompt service, knowledgeable, and professional. I would definitely use Anytime Locksmith again.” — customer of Anytime Locksmith
- “Professional, friendly, great price and completed our KIA 2 key fobs in record time.” — customer of East Island Locksmiths
- “Locked my car keys in my car. Calvin said 20 min and showed up on time.” — customer of Mobile Key & Lock Locksmith
- “I would definitely recommend Anytime Locksmith. They were able to come on the same day, solve our safe problem, and did more than they were paid to do.” — customer of Anytime Locksmith
Excerpts from public reviews of the locksmiths listed on this page.