Best Engine Repair and Replacement in Rochester, NY

The highest-rated Engine Overhaul & Replacement companies out of 133 vetted & reviewed in the Rochester area.

Browncroft Garage

Browncroft Garage

(47)
Service & Repairs, BG Products & Services, Fleet Services
“I am new to the Rochester area and didn't have a recommended mechanic so I just chose one (wasn't Browncroft) and it was a horrible experience, so I looked for a new mechanic and was told to check out Browncroft… BEST recommendation ever!”
In Business Since 1987
Offers Financing Options
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A
762 Atlantic Ave, Rochester, NY
i
Ferrel's Garage

Ferrel's Garage

(46)
We Provide ac Service, Oil Changes, Brake Repairs
“Ferrell's was able to find and fix an issue that I've had for years, when multiple other shops and chains wasted my time and money while accomplishing nothing.”
In Business Since 1984
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
365 University Ave, Rochester, NY
i
Schoen Auto

Schoen Auto

(49)
Engine Repair
“As a New Customer with a 33 Year Young Car, They Took the Time to Make Sure Absolutely No Aspect was Overlooked - in an Effort to Get it Up to Snuff - While myself on the Receiving End Never Felt Like i was Being Coerced Into Any Decision of What i w...”
In Business Since 1989
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
319 E Chestnut St, East Rochester, NY 14445
i
Blaesi's Automotive

Blaesi's Automotive

(49)
  • Prices
  • Upsell
  • Vehicles
“Great shop - fair, honest, they don't try and up-sell you on every little thing like other shops I've been to - it's the only place I go now, great experience every time!”
In Business Since 2010
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
981 Hudson Ave #3747, Rochester, NY
i
Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care

Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care

(49)
Air Conditioning Services, Air Filter Replacement
“This is owned and ran by the same people as the one off of lexington by far hand down my favorite shop to take my car when things aren't going right they are extremely professional and extremely understanding to ones situation and they are without a ...”
In Business Since 2012
Locally Owned & Operated
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
1521 Mt Read Blvd, Rochester, NY
i
Fetzner Collision

Fetzner Collision

(47)
“I also had a complex situation where I was rear ended a second time while waiting for the parts to come in for my first repair, and the guys here helped me navigate two insurance claims without any headache.”
In Business Since 2019
Family Business
Free Initial Consultation
2485 Dewey Ave, Rochester, NY
i
Redi Imports Downtown

Redi Imports Downtown

(34)
Auto Mufflers, Transmission, Auto Welding
“He even reference another shop where I have a good relationship with the owner but didn't know he did that sort of work and he told me he was a great guy and he said no offense taken if you'd rather have him do it even after spending over 30 minutes ...”
In Business Since 2013
Accepts Check, Cash, All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
144 Railroad St, Rochester, NY
i
Moriarty Diesel

Moriarty Diesel

(46)
  • Truck
  • Needs
  • Call
“Tyler – highly recommended by a marine surveyor who had previously worked with him – provided us with extensive details on the maintenance and repair work that the engine required, information that we needed to negotiate the boat purchase.”
In Business Since 2014
Transparent Fees & Pricing
1005 Mt Read Blvd, Rochester, NY
i
Gearhead Automotive

Gearhead Automotive

(49)
  • Vehicle
  • Work
  • Mechanic
“Just moved into the area and me and my girlfriend both had are tires pop unfortunately I had to get a whole new tire but I got the new one and he replaced it for a very reasonable price and was done within a hour and my girlfriend just popped her tir...”
In Business Since 2024
763 Linden Ave, Rochester, NY 14625
i
Emerson Collision

Emerson Collision

(48)
Collision Repair, Frame Repair and Straightening, Automobile Painting
“Once we got the car in and left it there, we got updates from the business on where they were in the process, they even included pictures with the updates so we could see how things were coming along!”
In Business Since 1988
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
2589 Ridgeway Ave, Rochester, NY
i
My-Tee Automotive Service

My-Tee Automotive Service

(48)
  • Honest
  • Fashion
  • Crew
“I as a women is very fearful when enter a car shop to get work done as most mechanics see Women and they see $$ as alot of us don't know what to look for and what the estimated cost(s) should be.”
In Business Since 1962
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
1 Rockwood St, Rochester, NY
i
Armour Automotive

Armour Automotive

(33)
  • Prices
  • Honest
  • Vehicle
“Services Transmission, Air & cabin filter replacement, Exhaust, Tires, Steering & suspension repair, Electrical, Auto engine diagnostic, Body & Trim, Wheel alignment, Brakes, Air conditioning, Brake service & repair, Battery, Oil change”
In Business Since 2017
259 Lee Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Elmers Brighton Garage

Elmers Brighton Garage

(42)
“He was able to recommend what he felt was the best tire and best price but encouraged me to look around (which I did and found similar) and then was able to get the tires quickly and complete the service quickly.”
In Business Since 1937
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
1848 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY
i
Avery's Garage

Avery's Garage

(15)
Fleet Services, Heavy Truck Repair, Napa Peace of Mind Warranty
“Great family business ,exceptional service They were fast with our needs got us back up and rolling Thank you SEALWAY FAMILY”
In Business Since 2020
Family Business
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
137 Syke St, Rochester, NY
i
Phil's Auto Clinic

Phil's Auto Clinic

(37)
  • Mechanic
  • Prices
“) They are practicing safety precautions during covid19, showing they care about customers, and he was able to complete the extensive service list before the eta he set for completion.”
In Business Since 2006
4199 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Vanthof's Automotive Repair

Vanthof's Automotive Repair

(22)
Auto Repair and Service, Tire Dealers, Wheel Alignment
“Jim and his staff have been taking care of our cars for years, and we always feel we are very well taken care, charged appropritately and the work is well done.”
In Business Since 1984
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
929 W Linden Ave, East Rochester, NY 14445
i
Stan's Auto Service

Stan's Auto Service

(37)
  • Prices
  • Fair
  • Mechanic
“They answered all calls, got me in their schedule which I know was tight (every other garage was booked weeks out), figured out the problem quick, and had it fixed in faster than expected time.”
In Business Since 1970
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
307 S Washington St, East Rochester, NY 14445
i
Roosevelt Service Station

Roosevelt Service Station

(45)
“I have always had the fastest most professional and courteous service at the Roosevelt service station year after year after and have heard their name thrown around as an excellent place since 1984”
In Business Since 1997
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
305 Roosevelt Rd, East Rochester, NY 14445
i
Diesel Haus

Diesel Haus

(23)
“I was so happy and impressed with the quality of service i received from this company, i bought a reefer box truck from Diesel Haus, and the crew went above and beyond to make sure my truck was ready, by replacing all the brake shoes and drums for...”
In Business Since 2007
Family Business
80 Saginaw Dr, Rochester, NY
i
Tri County Repair LLC

Tri County Repair LLC

(3)
“Chad and Brett are both very knowledgeable people and very helpful, anytime i need repairs for my truck they always get me in and out in a very timely fashion, highly recommended and will be going back Services Steering & suspension repair, Auto engi...”
In Business Since 2023
Transparent Fees & Pricing
3680 Buffalo Rd BLDG 10, Rochester, NY
i
Pryme Motorsports

Pryme Motorsports

(9)
  • Quality
“I've seen this shop go above and beyond all expectations to provide professional and quality services to not only me but my friends and family as well.”
1517 Mt Read Blvd, Rochester, NY
i
Culver Best Auto Care

Culver Best Auto Care

Auto Repair, Brake Service, Oil Change
“We strive to provide a hassle-free experience by offering exceptional customer service with competitive prices on all our products and services. Whether you need a full-service oil change or a complete engine tune up, we will do everything we can to ...”
In Business Since 2023
1387 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Buck's Auto Parts

Buck's Auto Parts

(8)
“John took the time to teach me a few things and re-timed the distributor and only charged $50!”
1551 Brighton Henrietta Town Line Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Lawless Diesel LLC

Lawless Diesel LLC

(6)
“Good the guys are the best in the business very professional and respectful you could not ask for a better bunch of guys to work on your equipment.”
174 Colvin St, Rochester, NY
i

Engine Repair Services in Rochester, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$732
Maximum cost
$5485
National Average
$2194
Avg Per Hour Rates
$108
$1890
$3047
Fair price range is based on 507 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $2194
Minimum cost $732
Maximum cost $5485
Avg Per Hour Rates $108

Fair range $1890 to $3047 is based on 507 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top