Best Engine Repair and Replacement in Amherst, NY

The highest-rated Engine Overhaul & Replacement companies out of 102 vetted & reviewed in the Amherst area.

Waye Motors Inc

Waye Motors Inc

(15)
Brakes, Preventative Maintenance, Engine Repair
“Highly recommend.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
In Business Since 1962
Serving Amherst Area
i
Martin's Auto Repair

Martin's Auto Repair

(16)
Propane Refill, Napa Autocare Center, Emissions Repair
“Martin has never steered me wrong and I have been taking my vehicles to them for several years and will continue to have my vehicles serviced only by them.”
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2018
Serving Amherst Area
i
Shamrock Service Center

Shamrock Service Center

(20)
  • Quality
  • Job
  • Professional
“Wait it gets better, when I arrived for my appointment, they took my car right in and I was on my way home less than a half hour from the time I got there.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
Family Business
Serving Amherst Area
i
Moriarty Diesel

Moriarty Diesel

(18)
  • Price
  • Work
  • Job
“Cole the service manager and Tyler the foreman were great to work with and made sure to answer all my questions and go above and beyond to explain repairs.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
In Business Since 2014
1005 Mt Read Blvd, Rochester, NY
i
Stan's Auto Service

Stan's Auto Service

(17)
  • Mechanic
  • Price
“They do a great job at fair price.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
In Business Since 1967
Serving Amherst Area
i
Main Stream Motors

Main Stream Motors

(11)
“I thought I would never find a place to fix my car for a reasonable price.”
In Business Since 2021
961 Lyell Ave Bldg 1, Suite 4, Rochester, NY
i
Impact Motors

Impact Motors

(12)
  • Mechanic
  • Price
  • Honest
“Took my car in for an inspection (had already failed at a dealership) and they inspected and repaired it for $100's less then every other place I had checked.”
751 Linden Ave, Rochester, NY
i
Meade Automotive Machine Co

Meade Automotive Machine Co

(2)
“Great place”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2004
Serving Amherst Area
i
Hometown Auto Service

Hometown Auto Service

(19)
  • Honest
  • Vehicles
  • Job
“What else do you need to know?”
Serving Amherst Area
i
Buck's Auto Parts

Buck's Auto Parts

(7)
“They helped me rebuild a Porsche 911SC engine about 10 years ago and it runs like new.”
1551 Brighton Henrietta Town Line Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Dynamic Diesel Repair

Dynamic Diesel Repair

(1)
“We completed several projects together and they were very professional and organized.”
Serving Amherst Area
i
Park Avenue Garage

Park Avenue Garage

Brakes, Engine & Transmission, Car & Truck Care
“We know your time is important. That's why we are conveniently located near you in Rochester, NY. Most truck or car maintenance services can be performed while you wait. Many repairs can be completed the same day. Difficult or easy, our mechanics wil...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2018
1415 Scottsville Rd, Rochester, NY
i
Red's Auto Center

Red's Auto Center

(29)
Red's Auto Center is Now a Penske Truck Rental Center
“Took my car to Reds, explained the issue & Chris pulled it in the shop right away , turns out the oil filter had a small pinch from improper installation (pin hole from improper tool )”
In Business Since 2017
Serving Amherst Area
i
Young's Tire & Auto

Young's Tire & Auto

(18)
  • Vehicle
  • Job
  • Inspection
“My 80 year old mother stopped in today needing air in 3 of 4 tires… they came right out and checked all the pressures, added air and sent her on her way!!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2012
Serving Amherst Area
i
T & F Tire Service & Supply Co. Inc

T & F Tire Service & Supply Co. Inc

(19)
  • Tires
  • Work
  • Business
“I thought I had originally paid someone a couple hundred $$ to fix my brakes and rotors just to get ripped off bc they were still grinding and I had to push them to the floor to stop..”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1968
Serving Amherst Area
i
Cotton's Custom Diesel

Cotton's Custom Diesel

(8)
  • Price
  • Truck
“7 Cummins turbo failed I was In Denver ,Co at the time called these guys and gave me a price that was far better than other quotes for a setup they recommended, gave the truck to the guys and let them go at.”
In Business Since 2018
Serving Amherst Area
i
Next Level Auto Center

Next Level Auto Center

(20)
  • Professional
  • Vehicle
  • Job
“After calling about a dozen other repair shops in the area, which were all booked full for a week or more, Next Level got me in immediately, and my vehicle was serviced and out the door in a little more than an hour, which was more than perfect becau...”
Coupons & Offers
Locally Owned & Operated
In Business Since 2020
Serving Amherst Area
i
Matta Motors

Matta Motors

(20)
Timing Belts, Exhaust Labor, Tune Up Labor
“I can't think of any dealer service center or other independent garage that I would give a 5-star rating to, but with Matta Motors, it is well deserved.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1984
Serving Amherst Area
i
E2 Automotive LLC

E2 Automotive LLC

(19)
Car Service, Mechanic Shop, Auto Service
“I was always contacted about what was going on, even if it was just to say, hey we're still waiting on the part but we're working on getting everything else together so we can get your car back to you as fast as we can.”
ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
Locally Owned & Operated
Serving Amherst Area
i
Ambridge Wholesale Tire

Ambridge Wholesale Tire

(19)
  • Professional
  • Job
  • Quick Service
“Great guys & super good prices !!!!”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
Locally Owned & Operated
Serving Amherst Area
i
Mike's Auto Service Center

Mike's Auto Service Center

(19)
Tire Rotation, Preventive Maintenance, Radiator Service
“After they were done, Brianna, a very upbeat personality, took time to tell me some issues they found with my vehicle that I should keep an eye on because they felt within a year I would have to address them.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Family Business
Accepts Financing available, Company card
Offers Financing Options
Serving Amherst Area
i
Gene Finks Tire

Gene Finks Tire

(17)
  • Inspection
  • Vehicle
  • Gas Station
“When stopped by them for a flat-tire which ended up not repairable, they gave me an old tire for free as an tentative one so that I could drive to a tire shop where I got the tire.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
Family Business
Serving Amherst Area
i
Chris' Automotive Repair Service LLC

Chris' Automotive Repair Service LLC

(19)
Oil Changes
“I brought my vehicle here recently for heating issues and I have to say I was really pleased with the service provided both with my vehicle and the professionalism, and courtesy of which I received.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1986
6080 Old Ct St, Syracuse, NY
i
Layland Motors

Layland Motors

(18)
  • Business
  • Prices
“Very knowlegable and do great work.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1982
1132 30th St NE, Canton, OH
i

Engine Repair Services in Amherst, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$714
Maximum cost
$5353
National Average
$2141
Avg Per Hour Rates
$105
$1844
$2974
Average price range is based on 480 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $2141
Minimum cost $714
Maximum cost $5353
Avg Per Hour Rates $105

Average range $1844 to $2974 is based on 480 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top