Best Tires, Tire Repair and Maintenance in Carmel, IN

The highest-rated Tire Sales and Repair companies out of 114 vetted & reviewed in the Carmel area.

PFM Auto & Fleet – Carmel

PFM Auto & Fleet – Carmel

(47)
  • Estimate
  • Dealership
  • Diagnose
“Pointed out cruddy air and cabin filters, which honestly, likely haven't been changed since I owned the vehicle, and vehicle was always maintained at dealer!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1989
Offers Financing Options
1441 S Guilford Rd #100, Carmel, IN
i
Tyler Automotive

Tyler Automotive

(48)
“One of the issues they discovered was a previous shop had put on the wrong serpentine belt and this apparently was causing several of my issues (loud sounds, flashing dash lights, etc.”
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
ASE, ASE Certified
In Business Since 1982
2801 E 62nd St, Indianapolis, IN
i
Bob's Garage

Bob's Garage

(48)
“I have saved so much money over the years because of their expert advice of what needs to be done and what does not, with my older and very dependable car.”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2015
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Carmel Area
i
All Star Tire & Auto Service

All Star Tire & Auto Service

(48)
Transmission Service & Oil Changes, Shocks - Struts & Springs, Battery Sales & Service
“I had been swindled by a roadside mechanic that abandoned the job and the guys at All Star straightened the whole mess up and got me back on the road within 24 hrs of dropping off my car.”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 1943
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
534 N Capitol Ave, Indianapolis, IN
i
Malless Auto Services

Malless Auto Services

(48)
“Diagnosed the issue, explained the problem and what was needed, worked with my warranty company to get repairs approved, had my car ready when promised.”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 1994
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
4525 W 71st St, Indianapolis, IN
i
Harris Tire and Auto

Harris Tire and Auto

(44)
Hunter Alignment, Schedule A Repair
“Did a really good job, when I called they were polite they answered all my questions and I was able to get In and out for a bent rim and got a really nice deal on a nice used tire.”
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2007
Family Business
5425 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN
i
Eastside Tires LLC

Eastside Tires LLC

(47)
  • Spare
  • Nail
  • Team
“There's not a lot of people who take a genuine interest in your well-being and who will go the extra mile to help you with your vehicle like he did for me.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2018
Family Business
8046 E Washington St #6812, Indianapolis, IN
i
Mobile Pitstop

Mobile Pitstop

(49)
Residential, Tire Sales & Installation, Fleets
“Ran over something that caused a flat on my way home between night shifts and so I couldn't take it somewhere since I needed to sleep between shifts.”
In Business Since 2018
8481 Bash St Suite 600, Indianapolis, IN
i
My Pit Crew

My Pit Crew

(50)
Electric Vehicle Service, Schedule a Service
“Even though I was not able to get my tire replaced onsite (my own fault) they had my tire and I was able to purchase directly from them onsite and deal with it in my own.”
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2018
Coupons & Offers
9200 Keystone Crossing Suite 501, Indianapolis, IN
i
Jet Tire Center

Jet Tire Center

(49)
“The building was extra clean and the amazing thing is they even cleaned the rim where the tire goes before checking for a leak after the tire was put on.”
Accepts Debit
In Business Since 1951
9065 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN
i
Jiffy Lube

Jiffy Lube

(48)
Air Filtration Services, Air Conditioning Service, Drivetrain Services
“I really like Jiffy Lube they're very good they're fast they're friendly and they won't change your oil if you don't need it just to get a sale I really appreciate them and I will always get my oil changed at Jiffy Lube.”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2010
Coupons & Offers
7012 Georgetown Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
A & A Tire and Auto Service

A & A Tire and Auto Service

(43)
Regardless of Where it Was Built, So Drop Your Auto, Pickup or Truck
“I have a second car having issues and I've been dreading taking it to a mechanic, but after my experience today I'll gladly bring my 2nd car here to have it looked at.”
Licensed
In Business Since 2000
Accepts Financing available, Insurance, All Major Credit Cards
2603 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
Ben's Garage

Ben's Garage

(49)
Preventative Maintenance, Diagnostics, Tire Services
“Ben's Garage has helped my family out with car repairs over the last few years, and what stand out the most are the quality of the work and their level of customer service.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2021
Serving Carmel Area
i
J.r.'s New & Used Tires

J.r.'s New & Used Tires

(45)
, ,
“Pleasantly Surprised with the my experience, being from out of town I looked High and Low for Same Day service and after a full day I stumbled across this Gem.”
In Business Since 2015
3519 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN
i
Clark Tire Fishers Inc

Clark Tire Fishers Inc

(48)
Brake Service Front End & Steering
“Adam Salyer thank you Sir for helping me out, I roll in at 5:45pm and ask you to reset/program my tire pressure sensors as Porsche couldn't do it on my 911.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1980
12371 Reynolds Dr, Fishers, IN
i
Llantas Durango

Llantas Durango

(37)
“, where the attendants and owners are jerks who have no conscience whatsoever, about ripping you off and who will promise you warranty protection but not honor it.”
In Business Since 2012
3224 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
i
Westfield Tire & Muffler

Westfield Tire & Muffler

(48)
“WT&M actually looks out for their customers best interests and looks for the most cost-effective solution and won't try to oversell or give you something you don't need.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1993
Coupons & Offers
Serving Carmel Area
i
Tire Express LLC

Tire Express LLC

(44)
“They have have a used tire price of $35-$45 and I was quoted at $40, however when I paid I was only charged $35 and it was not by accident at all, they simply just helped me out.”
In Business Since 2011
4609 N Post Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
Lafayette Tire Shop

Lafayette Tire Shop

(37)
“I pointed at the tire and said “I just need a replacement,” and he offered me a place to sit, fresh cold water bottle, and was able to get it changed out in less than 15 mins.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2016
2535 N Tibbs Ave, Indianapolis, IN
i
A & Z Auto Repair & Tires

A & Z Auto Repair & Tires

(49)
  • Fair
  • Brake Pads
  • Diagnose
“In addition to fast and (in my opinion) affordable brake caliper replacement, the team helped me diagnose a problem caused by another shop which was then easily fixed.”
1930 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
Eastside Tire & Wheel

Eastside Tire & Wheel

(48)
“It was literally 35 minutes from getting a flat, driving over to this place (we have run flat tires), getting a new tire on, and hitting the road again.”
3901 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
i
Real Mann's Tire & Indy Custom Wheels

Real Mann's Tire & Indy Custom Wheels

(47)
“Absolutely wonderful me and my son will go to Real Man's tires for the rest of lives father and son are amazing very very very good tires at a wonderful price”
2554 N Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN
i
Direct Tire

Direct Tire

(47)
Tire Repairs, Road Hazard Warranties, Tire Balancing
“The guy I spoke to on the phone name was Alan and he said yes they had it so let me I tell y'all I am very pleased with the tire and the excellent service.”
1506 N Post Rd, Indianapolis, IN
i
Budget Tire

Budget Tire

(46)
  • Fair
  • Prices
  • Donut
“Very quick good service and very reasonably priced.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1993
3351 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN
i

Tire Repair Services in Carmel, IN Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$18
Maximum cost
$59
National Average
$30
$24
$47
Average price range is based on 345 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $30
Minimum cost $18
Maximum cost $59

Average range $24 to $47 is based on 345 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top