Best Collision Repair in Brookhaven, NY

The highest-rated Accident Damage Repair companies out of 158 vetted & reviewed in the Brookhaven area.

South Haven Automobile Inc

South Haven Automobile Inc

(5)
“Quick pleasant service.”
2815 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
i
Jfa Auto Body Collision & Towing

Jfa Auto Body Collision & Towing

(44)
Fender Repair, Windshield Repair, Dent Repair
“After he brought it in he made recommendations to repair the paint on the door handles and the things in the door from those pesky shopping carts and other doors in parking lots.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2001
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Bi-County Auto Body

Bi-County Auto Body

(48)
“Someone had thrown a block of wood at my car while driving on the expressway and I was devastated to learn of the damage when I arrived at work after the incident.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1991
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
400 E Main St, Smithtown, NY
i
J & J Auto Body Specialties

J & J Auto Body Specialties

(38)
Mechanical Repairs, Customized Painting, Collision Repair
“Great work on my 2005 trail blazer , thank you George, also turn around time was only 1 week awesome, would recommend as a great place to get auto body repair Services Painting, Body & Trim”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1989
PPG, ICAR, PPG, ICAR Certified
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Lee's Auto Body & Glass

Lee's Auto Body & Glass

(49)
  • Honest
  • Photos
  • Price
“I've been going there for about 8 years and if I ever have an issue or need some help I know they will be there to service me and help with any matter at hand.”
In Business Since 1921
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
76 E Main St F, East Islip, NY
i
Smithtown Auto Body

Smithtown Auto Body

(50)
  • Door
  • Rental Car
  • Fender
“It was my first time to any body shop, so you can imagine how stressful it can be when you're unsure about the process and how much it would cost you.”
Coupons & Offers
Se Habla Español
In Business Since 1988
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
157 W Main St, Smithtown, NY
i
Perfect Bodies Auto-Body Inc

Perfect Bodies Auto-Body Inc

(49)
Car Rental, Paintless Dent Removal, Towing
“Looks good as new, and they kept me informed about its progress all through the process, they really think outside the box to make repairs better than original with RV repairs .”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1997
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Sal's Auto Body

Sal's Auto Body

(48)
  • Stress
  • Desk
  • Brand
“She explained what was needed for the repair- painting the mirror housing, replacing the trim and matching color, auto dimming and calibrating the unit at the dealer.”
In Business Since 1984
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Continental Car Care

Continental Car Care

(50)
“They are not afraid to fight with the insurance companies either when you have an accident that is not your fault and they try to give you the run around”
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 1985
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Newton Collision Repair

Newton Collision Repair

(34)
  • Insurance
  • Price
  • Job
“The prices were very fair and although my car was totaled and I did not end up having any actual work done there, I couldn't have asked for a better experience.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1986
I-CAR Certified
1170 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood, NY
i
MD Auto Repair

MD Auto Repair

(48)
Auto Repair, Collision Repair
“They are professional and courteous and usually timely on their repairs but their prices are a bit higher then average by a good amount and that isn't reflected in the work or quality of parts used in comparison to any other shop.”
In Business Since 1991
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Kraken Auto & Collision Inc.

Kraken Auto & Collision Inc.

(46)
Auto Collision, Towing Service, Auto Detail
“My year and a half old car died on me yesterday so I had the unfortunate experience of dealing with possibly the worst road side assistance ever (Acura).”
Family Business
In Business Since 2019
GSA Certified
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Nolan's Auto Collision Inc

Nolan's Auto Collision Inc

(49)
  • Number
  • Employees
  • Front Desk
“He laid out all my options, let me know up front what the approximate costs would be, and when I opted to go with the cheaper option I was met with compassion and understanding.”
Family Business
In Business Since 1932
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
BIG n' Littles Auto Body

BIG n' Littles Auto Body

(28)
Collision Repair, Paintless Dent Repair
“He not only fixed the bumper and exhaust issues caused by that accident, but polished and cleaned the car and made sure it looked like the day I drove it off the lot.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
In Business Since 2022
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
South Shore Auto Collision

South Shore Auto Collision

(48)
  • Texted
  • Passenger
  • Holiday
“He made the entire process easy, repaired the car when he said he would, and even did a fantastic job cleaning the inside of my car which I did not expect.”
In Business Since 1992
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Sunwave Auto Repair and Body Works

Sunwave Auto Repair and Body Works

(47)
Tire Services, Accident Vehicles, Motors, Transmissions
“Their responsiveness, friendly attitude, as well as their willingness to work with a customer was beyond amazing and not something you can find anymore.”
In Business Since 2009
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
G & B Collision (Port Jefferson Collision Center Inc.)

G & B Collision (Port Jefferson Collision Center Inc.)

(36)
  • Insurance Broker
  • Management
  • Vehicle
“I've been dealing with Andrew and the team for quite a few years now, and have been totally impressed by their professionalism and attention to detail.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2003
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Grobens Auto Body

Grobens Auto Body

(44)
  • Money
  • Hands
  • Communication
“The first thing I look for is politeness I walked in and was immediately greeted with a hello even from the young man who I'm thinking worked in the back.”
In Business Since 2015
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
A-1 Auto Body Inc

A-1 Auto Body Inc

(36)
Hail Damage, Member of L.i.a.b.r.a., Center For the Full Line of Retro USA Products
“I dealt with Tim who I spoke with on the phone and within 5 minutes once I got there, they took the black scrapes out of that bumper off of my white car.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2014
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Shirley Auto Body Inc

Shirley Auto Body Inc

(49)
Auto Glass Replacement, Collision Repairs, Towing
“Owner was very understanding of my frustration of getting parts from Tesla, which is notoriously bad at getting out parts on time he was very apologetic though no fault of his own”
Family Business
In Business Since 1980
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
South Shore Auto Collision

South Shore Auto Collision

(47)
  • Brand
  • Insurance Company
  • Needs
“Great customer service 👏 quality work .....”
In Business Since 1979
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Autokicks

Autokicks

(48)
Suspension, Accessories, Performance
“Great knowledge base, attention to detail and the drive to do it right the first time, instead of a quick ( shut the customer up and get it out the door) fix.”
In Business Since 2006
Locally Owned & Operated
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Autofix Collision Center Inc

Autofix Collision Center Inc

(45)
  • Quality
  • Rental Car
  • Brand
“Tim Was Highly professional and To the point Of When My Girlfriends Car Would Be Ready He Went above And Beyond To Make Sure she Left Happy And Satisfied”
In Business Since 2002
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Portside Collision Center

Portside Collision Center

(50)
  • Door
  • Truck
  • Attention
“If you have any issues, or questions Juan is very attentive and made me feel comfortable I chose the right spot after checking many other body shops prior.”
20+ Years Experience
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i

Collision Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$496
Maximum cost
$8056
National Average
$2219
Avg Per Hour Rates
$159
$1859
$3099
Typical price range is based on 401 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $2219
Minimum cost $496
Maximum cost $8056
Avg Per Hour Rates $159

Typical range $1859 to $3099 is based on 401 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top