View Profile
Traction Plus Discount Tires
“Everyone worked well together and they were not only able to beat the prices around but they were able to do the job sooner then all the other spots around town.”
Best Tire Shops near Brookhaven, NY
These experts serve Brookhaven from nearby bases in towns including Patchogue, St James and Islip.
24 experts listed · 19 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Smittys Garage
- Car Battery
- Happy
- Tire
“Smitty's is a fair priced and honest repair shop who focusses on the customer experience to ensure expedient repair and over communicates what is needed or not.”
View Profile
Terry Bros Tires
- Gentleman
- Rims
- Truck
“I was first customer of the day and got two awesome quality used tires and they fixed my very jacked up rims (thanks LI potholes) and now my passenger tire can finally hold air.”
View Profile
Tire City
“2 of the tires on my Mustang had a slow leak, so I stopped there last Saturday around noon, expected it to take forever because it's such a busy time, took 20 minutes.”
View Profile
Route 111 Tire & Auto
- Oil
- Inspection
- Job
“Been coming here for a few years and I wouldn't go anywhere else Pete “the owner” always does the right thing and I leave with my car worry free every time and the issue is always fixed !”
View Profile
Nico's Way Auto Repair
- Understanding
- Period
- Work
“Steve called and said it's the transmission (as we suspected) and quoted me the thousands of dollars it would cost but then added that as much as he'd love to take my money, he suggested that I contact Infiniti as I was just over the 6 year warranty ...”
Listed for drivers in and around Brookhaven, NY, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Brookhaven, NY
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.4 to 5.0 across 3,917 reviews; 21 have 50 or more reviews and 23 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (97%), quality (85%) and value (79%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "fair" and "honest". 19 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brake repair (4), tires (4), oil changes (3), auto repair (2) and diagnostics (2). 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 13 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2001. 3 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 5 are family- or locally-owned and 10 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 20 of the experts on this page; 17 publish a contact page; 9 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Which shops listed for Brookhaven open on Saturdays or Sundays?
19 of the 24 shops on this page post weekend hours. Saturday morning is when everyone else has the same idea, so a booked slot is worth more than an early start. Sunday openings are rare and often run with one fitter and a short parts counter.
View Profile
Sayville Discount Tires
“Spoke with John over the phone about getting 37 inch tires mounted on my jeep very polite went in same day great service from himself and the crew happy with the service they provide.”
View Profile
Barnwell House
“They checked it out asap and helped me immensely.”
View Profile
Central Islip Firestone
“Good local mechanic and tire shop”
View Profile
Dave Kunzler Tire
- RV
- Inspection
- Team
“I went to a local mechanic by my house "specializing" in classic cars and they gave me a 2 page list of what I needed and said the work needed to be done immediately.”
View Profile
Smithwest Service Center Inc.
- Brakes
- Flat Tire
- Driver
“Couldn't have asked for a better driver to come help me when I needed it.”
View Profile
Gene's 112 Auto Service Center
“Gene was able to quickly diagnose the problem, obtain the parts needed, road test the car and get it back to me within one day – even with the Thanksgiving holiday.”
View Profile
Sound Trax
- Amp
- Technicians
- Job
“Charlie and Scott came to listen what the issues were, attentious, friendly and always make me feel like I'm priority regardless of crazy busy they always are.”
View Profile
Bo's Auto and Truck Repair
- Mechanic
- Name
- Inspection
“I know it's hard to believe but I found an honest mechanic Pleasure to deal with The man is not looking to overcharge you He is quite fair I would highly recommend them”
View Profile
Tire Guys Complete Auto Repair
- Rim
- Job
- Pricing
“I know most people write reviews when their experience with a business is not pleasant but today I write this review to RAVE about the most amazing experience at The Tire Guys!”
View Profile
F&C Tires Inc.
“I pulled in, had the puncture repaired, and all of the other tires aired up to the proper air pressure in under 30 minutes, and for a very fair charge.”
View Profile
Elite Foreign & Domestic Auto
- Mechanic
- Honest
- Vehicles
“Intending to schedule an appointment for my return, I called them - but they told me it wasn't a great idea to let the car sit on a flat tire for a week.”
View Profile
Los Brother's Auto Repair & Towing
“I have 2019 Cadillac XTS went to them they diagnosed my problem with 2 minutes which 3 dealerships could not diagnose and they are very professional and responsible priced the competition now I take all of my cars to them.”
View Profile
Tire Warehouse
- Truck
- Brothers
- Prices
“Honest and fast service and great conversation very hospitable haven't seen such service in such a long time, it was refreshing will highly recommend to anyone.”
View Profile
Family Tires & Auto Repair
- Money
- Inspection
- Prices
“Prices are great, and the parking lot is easily accessible.”
View Profile
Tire Express
- Engine
- Light
- Oil
“Rob has serviced (or overseen the servicing of) my family's vehicles on numerous occasions; he pays attention to detail, he gets the job right, and he doesn't beat around the bush.”
View Profile
Mt. Sinai Tire Inc.
- Tires
“I only needes one valve stem to be replaced but they went ahead and checked all my tires to make sure they were safe and even went as far as checking a fuse for me for something unrelated!”
View Profile
Gary's Precision Auto Repair
“Gary is the most honest mechanic I know.”
View Profile
Island Car Care Center
- Job
- Prices
- Mechanics
“I am a permanent customer, and I have payment plan with them, so that without having money to pay them , I still get back to work, and pay them later, Today I hit a big pile of snow, my cooling system broke down, They did instant replacement, on pa...”
Tire Repair Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$19
Maximum cost
$62
National Average
$31
$25
$50
Typical price range is based on 458 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
