NB RIM Repair
“No more bends in the rims and I look forward to bringing my wheels to get powder coated.”
Best Tire Shops in Bay Shore, NY
15 experts listed · 6 in Bay Shore · 13 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
All Around Tire and NYS Auto Inspection
“Called ahead to make sure he was available and he gave me a time and I was in and out in no time.”
Tires On the Go Repair Inc (Mobile Tire Shop)
“Very helpful fast and efficient they not only helped me with my tires also fixed my bent rims.”
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc
“A great shop, jose always takes care of me, the prices, the skill and customer service is unbeatable”
Tires R Us
“The staff was friendly and very well experienced had no issue totally recommend it thank you 👍 …”
I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC
“Great service , mechanic roy is the best”
Listed for drivers in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
6 of the 15 experts we list are based in Bay Shore; the other 9 serve Bay Shore from towns including West Islip (2 mi), Islip (3 mi) and West Babylon (6 mi). The experts on this page are rated from 4.4 to 4.9 across 1,946 reviews; 12 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price" and "fair". 13 are open on Saturdays and 3 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), engine repair (2), oil changes (2) and tires (2). 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. 8 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 46 years. 1 offers emergency or roadside call-outs; 3 offer financing; 4 are family- or locally-owned and 7 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 10 of the experts on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 7 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Which shops listed for Bay Shore open on Saturdays or Sundays?
13 of the 15 shops on this page post weekend hours. Saturday morning is when everyone else has the same idea, so a booked slot is worth more than an early start. Sunday openings are rare and often run with one fitter and a short parts counter.
Barnwell House
“Best tire shop around for commercial tire.”
Traction Plus Discount Tires
“As a female it's always a headache to deal with anything car related, however, coming here is always an exceptional experience.”
AA Tire & Service
“I stopped by about closing time and the owner and FOREST were extremely accommodating.”
Bobby's One Stop Custom Exhaust Auto Repair Shop
“Bobby was not only able to save me money, but he also did an amazing job.”
Route 111 Tire & Auto
“Came in for an alignment and a inspection, I was in and out within an hour.”
Automotive Technology
“We are very happy with Gregg & his team they are very honest & reliable most of all not pushy if work needs to be done.”
Billy Auto
“Honestly had great conversation with the gentleman there, will definitely be getting tires there when I need them!”
Sayville Discount Tires
“Excellent place, very professional, quick service, reasonable price, new tires in ten minutes.”
Nico's Way Auto Repair
“Easy to make appointment and great friendly service.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
