View Profile
Route 111 Tire & Auto
- Mechanics
- Oil
- Vehicle
“I have been to other mechanics that have been scammy, so I was nervous but today I got a flat and they patched me up within minutes, and were so sweet.”
Best Tire Shops near Islip, NY
2 of these experts are based in Islip; the others serve Islip from towns including West Islip (6 mi), Central Islip (3 mi) and Huntington Station (13 mi).
19 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Automotive Technology
- Oil
- Expertise
- Mechanic
“During my recent visit for an NYS inspection, as well as to have my battery and brakes checked, Greg and the team once again demonstrated their dedication to quality and precision”
View Profile
Central Islip Firestone
“My family has been going to Jimmy and his crew for decades and trust him with all of our auto mechanic needs.”
View Profile
Mark's Auto Repair & Tire
“But a couple of years ago I put out a call on Facebook for friends to recommend a mechanic in the area and when several of them commented "marks auto" that's where i took my car.”
View Profile
A1 Action Auto & Truck Repair
“They just give you everything they are honest and won't pull your arm and leg about something like others do overall the best on Long Island ED is hell of a guy”
View Profile
Tire Express
- Repair Shop
- Honest
- Light
“Super friendly staff and The greatest service around I had new rims and tires mounted on my F-150 I accidentally told them that I had a 18-in rim so they ordered tires for me but mistakenly I had a 17-in rim Scott was super helpful and got me the cor...”
Listed for drivers in and around Islip, NY, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Islip, NY
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 4,044 reviews; 20 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (94%), quality (88%) and value (70%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "fair", "honest" and "diagnosis". 19 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are oil changes (5), brake repair (4), tires (4), brakes (3) and engine repair (3). 5 list staff certifications (ASE) and 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 16 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 97 years. 1 offers emergency or roadside call-outs; 4 offer financing; 3 give free estimates; 8 are family- or locally-owned and 11 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 19 of the experts on this page; 18 publish a contact page; 10 list a public email and 5 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Why are some shops here not in Islip?
2 of the 24 shops sit in Islip itself; the rest come from other towns within 20 mi. The drive is sometimes the point, because stores stock what sells locally and an odd size may only be on a shelf one town over. Distances are straight-line.
View Profile
Island Car Care Center
- Mechanics
- Work
- Job
“I drove in and Esi and he was so extremely kind and understanding of my plight and started checking my car out on the computer and test driving it to diagnose the problem and solution.”
View Profile
All Island Tires & Rim Repair
- Fair
- Flat Tire
- Price
“My tire was completely flat and he gave me a used one in great condition for a cheap price, couldnt ask for better service or attitude.”
View Profile
All Pro Tire & Auto
- Job
- Inspection
- Vehicle
“I've been dealing with Augie for a good 20 yrs now, he has done everything from a motor swap to brakes and inspections.”
View Profile
Expo Tires
- Prices
“I live in the area and always use expo for tires, I send my friends and family here too.”
View Profile
Island Truck Tire AND Service
“Fast service”
View Profile
Barnwell House
“Got a flat down the road and was abke to just make it into their parking lot before they opened, they got me new tire and got me back on the road as soon as they opened.”
View Profile
Smittys Garage
- Mechanic
- Car Battery
- Inspection
“I dropped it off They took very good care of me They know what they are doing they did a great job I am very very happy with the Service I will not worry about my truck.”
View Profile
Traction Plus Discount Tires
“Great service … had a small issue with a used tire purchased … the manager John went above and beyond to back his tire repair and fix the problem permanently!”
View Profile
AA Tire & Service
“I also observe when other people come to get their cars serviced and they are polite to them and the guys give them options on what to do with the car, not like other garages that say its only this or nothing.”
View Profile
All Weather Tires Sales & Service Inc
“I need a patch done, then it turned out that all 4 of my tires were shot, they helped me quickly with a set of new tires with a very reliable and fair price, highly recommend All Weather Tire”
View Profile
D & D Auto Clinic
- Tires
- Oil
- Team
“What a great first time experience walk in for an inspection and the owner took me right away (great man btw) definitely going back I highly recommend them 10/10”
View Profile
Bobby's One Stop Custom Exhaust Auto Repair Shop
- Mechanic
- Money
- Nice Guy
“My car had a long time problem of a rotted exhaust pipe underneath and I had no idea because when I first got the car my other mechanic never informed me about it, so when Bobby looked at it and brought it to my attention, not only did he give me a g...”
View Profile
Terry Bros Tires
- Owner
- Gentleman
- Leak
“I was first customer of the day and got two awesome quality used tires and they fixed my very jacked up rims (thanks LI potholes) and now my passenger tire can finally hold air.”
View Profile
Oakwood Car Care & Tire Center
- Vehicle
- Wheels
- Team
“Joe encouraged me to take my car to Honda rather than have him do an oil change and replace the rear differential fluid because he said I shouldn't need to replace the rear differential fluid so soon.”
View Profile
Billy Auto
- Prices
- Oil
- Quality
“I had called BMW earlier that morning before I called Billy and they told me they'd have to tow my car and service wouldn't be available until at least Monday and if I wanted a loaner car I'd have to wait 2 weeks.”
View Profile
Nico's Way Auto Repair
- Oil
- Understanding
- Inspection
“Came in with a huge problem, they were very understanding and very thorough they treated my vehicle like it was their own and Steve is an absolute master mechanic if its fixable he can fix it this box isnt big enough to hold my appreciation for Nic...”
View Profile
Sayville Discount Tires
“I don't live very close to Sayville, but I came here when I needed to have a tire replaced because I happened to be near Sayville when I had a blowout.”
View Profile
Hubcaps & Wheel Repair LLC
- Brand
- Factory
- Communication
“Other may cost a little less, not much, but his work is top-notch and if the rims are not re-furbished well, why bother - just get new rims - thanks for giving me brand-new factory rims after you were finished with my old, damaged ones.”
Tire Repair Services in Islip, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$19
Maximum cost
$62
National Average
$31
$25
$50
Average price range is based on 310 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
