Best Tire Shops near Oyster Bay, NY

These experts serve Oyster Bay from nearby bases in towns including Bay Shore, Rockville Centre and Farmingdale.

15 experts listed · 13 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 3, 2026

NB RIM Repair

NB RIM Repair

4.5 87 reviews
“I don't know why people made some bad reviews this place is so good at what they do my vehicle is driving like normal again and the price is great I will make sure I refer everyone to this location!”
Se habla españolSince 2021
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc

Extreme Tire Car Care Inc

4.7 13 reviews
“They plugged my tire while I waited, usually would go for a patch but can't argue with immediate service, thanks guys”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC

I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC

4.4 8 reviews
“They took the time to explain both the mechanical repairs and what was needed for the paint job, and kept me updated throughout the process.”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Tire Town Tire Pros

Tire Town Tire Pros

4.5 71 reviews
“Joe and his staff are professional, courteous and excell at their craft!”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 1939Financing
Rockville Centre, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair

Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair

4.9 119 reviews
“They brought me in to get a pre purchase inspection got me in and out super quick, then when I needed to get the vehicle inspected it was a very painless experience, shoutout Anthony”
Coupons & offersFree consultationSince 2010Family-ownedFinancing
Seaford, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
AA Tire & Service

AA Tire & Service

4.8 119 reviews
“The service was completed quickly, and the communication throughout the process was outstanding.”
ASE-certified techsPick-up & drop-offFinancing availableSince 1997Family-owned
Farmingdale, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i

Listed for drivers in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 15 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY

The 15 experts on this page are rated from 4.4 to 4.9 across 4,372 reviews; 13 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price", "honest" and "fair". 13 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brake repair (3), oil change (3), preventative maintenance (3), transmission repair (2) and wheel alignments (2). 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 10 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2000. 8 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 5 are family- or locally-owned and 8 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 13 of the experts on this page; 13 publish a contact page; 11 list a public email and 7 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.

Which shops listed for Oyster Bay open on Saturdays or Sundays?

13 of the 15 shops on this page post weekend hours. Saturday morning is when everyone else has the same idea, so a booked slot is worth more than an early start. Sunday openings are rare and often run with one fitter and a short parts counter.

Hewlett House of Tires Tire Pros Complete Auto Service

Hewlett House of Tires Tire Pros Complete Auto Service

4.9 123 reviews
“Me & my family trust their expertise and guidance through countless challenges with our vehicles as they age”
Coupons & offers24-mo/24k-mi warranty24/7 emergency serviceFinancing availableSince 1998Locally owned
Hewlett, NY · 13 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Barnwell House of Tires, Inc.

Barnwell House of Tires, Inc.

4.8 70 reviews
“Danny Miller, Manager, was honest about the options and worked hard to find the matching tire during COVID when so many places were closed.”
Coupons & offersSince 2001Financing
West Babylon, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Barnwell House of Tires

Barnwell House of Tires

4.8 141 reviews
“Brian, Jeff, and the front desk team are great about calling to update you on any findings, explaining any unexpected issues, and giving the customer the information needed to make an informed decision.”
Since 1983Family-ownedFinancing
Mineola, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Cross Island Tire & Wheel

Cross Island Tire & Wheel

4.5 103 reviews
“Junior made sure I was taken care of in a timely manner.”
Coupons & offersSince 2001
Queens Village, NY · 13 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Nut Just Lube & Tires

Nut Just Lube & Tires

4.9 109 reviews
“They are over the top professionals - great service big or small, reliable, honest and always willing to help you out.”
Coupons & offersSince 2004Financing
Port Washington, NY · 9 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Billy Auto

Billy Auto

4.5 50 reviews
“Billy Auto is great place 2 go 2 4 all yure mechanical needs 4 yure car 2 be service, Billy and Jay are great people and they care about all there customers they make yu feel like family.”
Coupons & offersSince 1980Financing
Amityville, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Paul's Auto Repair

Paul's Auto Repair

4.8 124 reviews
“Minutes after I sat down, the car was going in for service, and I was in and out in under an hour including the 15 minutes it took to write my review using one finger to type.”
ASE certifiedSince 1994Family-ownedInsurance accepted
Great Neck, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Hubcaps & Wheel Repair LLC

Hubcaps & Wheel Repair LLC

4.9 63 reviews
“Brian was great and helped me with any and all issues with my wheels”
Free estimatesWheel repair specialistSince 2016
East Northport, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
JMD Auto Care Ltd.

JMD Auto Care Ltd.

4.9 57 reviews
“He is concerned about the customer, the excellent service he gives and the safety of your vehicle.”
Coupons & offersSince 2007
Rockville Centre, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
HomeTire StoresNew YorkOyster Bay, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top