View Profile
Island Car Care
- Communication
- Job
- Oil
“And they always suggest what you may NEED next or what you SHOULD get done, (and as someone who's not a "car guy", I appreciate that), but with no pressure to do it now.”
Best Auto Repair near Oyster Bay, NY
We have 2 professionals in Oyster Bay on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: one of them made it, along with 23 from towns including Bay Shore (15, 14 mi), Brooklyn (2, 25 mi) and Staten Island (2, 36 mi).
15 open weekends · 20 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
M B Automotive
- Driving
- Reviews
- Job
“I took my 05 V50 to MB AUTO when I first bought it with the check engine light on and the technician mike knew what was wrong with it right away I'll take my volvo there whenever I have a problem with it.”
View Profile
Brightside Automotive Repair
- Review
- Stars
- Job
“When driving in from out of state to try and catch a ferry to Fire Island, my break calipers on the front ends blew and the breaks began to heat up quick and stick.”
View Profile
Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs
“Wade thankfully didn't give up on a bad engine situation and didn't take any easy way out by replacing every part possibly implicated in the problem and therefore would have driven the repair cost up dramatically.”
View Profile
TK Modern Auto Repair
- Fair
- Oil
- Mechanic
“Tim quickly diagnosed the issue and gave me a reasonable quote for ignition coil replacement and valve gasket cover, in at 9:30, out by 4:30, highly recommend”
View Profile
True Street Performance
- Dealership
- Review
- Truck
“Jim and AJ really know their Hemi engines they really do a phenomenal job, they really know their stuff they fix whatever problem needs to be fixed and you'll never see that problem again.”
Listed for drivers in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 24 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY
The 24 professionals on this page are rated from 4.2 to 4.9 across 2,017 reviews; 13 have 50 or more reviews and 20 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these professionals on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (94%), quality (72%) and value (60%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "communication", "honest" and "fair". 15 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the professionals on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), tires (2) and transmissions (2). 5 list staff certifications (ASE) and 7 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 14 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 59 years. 1 gives free estimates; 7 are family- or locally-owned and 3 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 16 of the professionals on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 5 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.
How long have the listed shops been open?
14 of the 24 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.
View Profile
Sagamore Collision
“From the moment of my accident, and all the way through the repair process, the team at Sagamore Collision was prompt, professional, and 100% attentive to all my concerns.”
View Profile
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc
- Matter
- Communication
- Team
“They are truthful and will let you know what needs to be done and what can wait, they don't take advantage of you unlike other mechanics looking to make a quick buck.”
View Profile
Jmr Garage
- Price
“First thing I like to say is when you call someone actually picks up the phone( which for the majority of shops I have called you get vm or a automated system saying write a email).”
View Profile
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare
- Rental
- Truck
- Price
“I brought my 2003 Honda minivan in thinking the transmission needed to be rebuilt but Mark was so honest telling me all it needed was an electronic sensor component.”
View Profile
D&G Auto Repair and Services
- Honest
- Labor
- Quality
“From a quick oil change to a more complicated service such as cooling system or exhaust system upgrade, D&G team of mechanics will get it done appropriately.”
View Profile
75th Street Auto Center
“I don't need to gratuitously diss local Ford Service, but they on the other hand have no customer service skills, constantly upsell, take forever, charge an arm and a leg, and are just awful to deal with.”
View Profile
Sunrise Collision and Towing
- Paint
- Brand
- Hospital
“Just want to say thank you you guys did great work on my vehicle very professional great timing and got me in and out thank you Danny and his crew five stars definitely will recommend to family and friends from one small business owner to another def...”
View Profile
John A Carucci Motors Inc
- Job
- Photo
- Inspection
“Been using John for years - he and Michael are great along with Oscar the mechanic - but, I guess they have decided it's time to relax - now we have Ricky who we already like - very nice guy good pricing and great work.”
View Profile
All Island Auto Co
“Very professional and excellent work.”
View Profile
David Auto Wreckers
“They have the best prices, i went to 3 location and because i was a woman they tried to rip me off but David's auto took care of me and work with me, no complains!!”
View Profile
Auto Imports
- Audi
- Air-Cooled Engine
- Fair
“You own a VW or Audi well worth the visit.”
View Profile
Kevin Tire Repair Shop
- Tires
- Price
“What an experience as a woman had a flat had no other option than to go to the tire shop here a little hesitant, but I was treated with the upmost respect, they made me feel very welcome and safe.”
View Profile
Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.
- Prices
“They run a tight ship owner operated your in good hands”
View Profile
L & D Services Station Inc
“It's very busy, the best part is they are honest not a lot of places like this left, I should be selfish and tell people to go elsewhere so the wait isn't so long but I can't they are to nice”
View Profile
Rev's Auto Services
- Money
- Vehicle
“Awesome place been using them for over 10 years me and my father have never had any issues Paul is very reasonable and understanding towards your problems and will work with you to fix that very standup guy would highly recommend others to come visit...”
View Profile
Tom's Vette Shop Inc
- Prices
“I have known Tom for many many years , he knows his stuff and his prices are better then catalog prices , very nice person and he will give you great advice .”
View Profile
Gardfield Auto Repair Inc
- Price
- Mechanics
“They are fairly priced knowledgeable and very accommodating I used a mechanic for over 25 years till he retired so was quite nervous about trying someone new.”
View Profile
Gomez Auto Repair
“Great place”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Auto Repair near Oyster Bay
Popular in Oyster Bay
, NYGuides: Auto Repair
Brake Pad Replacement Cost: Do You Really Need Rotors?
Can a Mechanic Charge More Than the Estimate? State Rules
Can I Bring My Own Parts to a Mechanic? What It Saves
Car Diagnostic Test Cost 2026: What the Fee Really Buys
Do Mechanics Have to Warranty Their Work? (2026)
Does a Different Mechanic Void Your Car Warranty? (2026)