Best Auto Repair near Oyster Bay, NY

We have 2 professionals in Oyster Bay on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: one of them made it, along with 14 from Bay Shore (13, 14 mi) and Deer Park (1, 11 mi).

9 open weekends · 11 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 4, 2026

MB Automotive

MB Automotive

4.9 64 reviews
“It's hard to find a shop you can trust with an older car, but these guys are the real deal.”
ASE-certified techsEuropean car specialistFree consultationSince 2017Family-owned
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Brightside

Brightside

4.7 65 reviews
“I'm a new customer and very happy with the service I received.”
24/7 towingSe habla españolSince 1984Family-owned
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

4.9 77 reviews
“Wade is amazing, did a great job on my vehicle and did it quick too!”
Fleet accountsSince 1968Family-owned
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
True Street Performance

True Street Performance

4.7 80 reviews
“They stand behind their work, deliver quality service, and maintain excellent communication throughout the process.”
Since 2013
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Carucci Motors

Carucci Motors

4.8 67 reviews
“I've used their services for 2 different collision damages, inspections, glass repairs, etc.”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

4.4 36 reviews
“He is honest, reliable, and only speaks the truth,, never lies about anything,, straight forward about what to expect,, great man”
ASE-certified techs43+ yearsFamily-owned
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i

Listed for drivers in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 15 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY

The 15 professionals on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 1,462 reviews; 9 have 50 or more reviews and 11 are rated 4.5 or higher. 9 are open on Saturdays. The services the professionals on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), tires (2) and transmissions (2). 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 9 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 42 years. 1 gives free estimates; 5 are family- or locally-owned and 2 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 11 of the professionals on this page; 7 publish a contact page; 4 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.

How long have the listed shops been open?

9 of the 15 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

4.8 129 reviews
“The service is consistently exceptional, and the level of care provided goes above and beyond expectations.”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 2007Family-owned
Deer Park, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Sagamore Collision

Sagamore Collision

4.3 64 reviews
“The crew working on my car is undoubtedly the most skilled and professional I've ever encountered.”
24/7 towingSince 2012
91 Pine Hollow Rd
i
Sunrise Collision and Towing

Sunrise Collision and Towing

4.4 48 reviews
“The tow truck was clean and well-maintained, and the driver handled my car with care, ensuring it was securely loaded and transported”
Since 1984Insurance accepted
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
All Island Auto Co

All Island Auto Co

4.7 18 reviews
“Always comes through when you need it most!”
BBB A+Since 2004
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Rev's Auto Services

Rev's Auto Services

4.7 24 reviews
“Great guy definitely knows what he is doing”
Since 1997
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

4.7 16 reviews
“Great customer service and honest mechanics.”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Tom's Vette Shop Inc

Tom's Vette Shop Inc

4.9 5 reviews
“Tom's a great guy and knows his vetts quality original parts and some amazing cars out back”
Since 1995
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Gomez Auto Repair

Gomez Auto Repair

4.3 13 reviews
“Antonio is a good mechanic, reasonable and honest price, and he works very well.”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Royal Bodies & Repair

Royal Bodies & Repair

5.0 2 reviews
“Herman is a great guy that can fix anything .”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
HomeAuto Repair ShopsNew YorkOyster Bay, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top