Best Auto Repair in Oyster Bay, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Repair companies out of 270 vetted & reviewed in the Oyster Bay area.

Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros

Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros

(18)
  • Island
  • Matter
  • Work
“Their knowledgeable, friendly, & helpful staff will take all the time you need, answer all your questions, & will even look up stuff that you may have found.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Locally Owned & Operated
Coupons & Offers
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
A1 Towing and Auto Repair

A1 Towing and Auto Repair

(16)
24 Hr Roadside Assistance, Exhaust Systems & Mufflers, Body & Paint Work
“My husband had an emergency and on a Saturday afternoon around closing time, he came over within a very short period of time and fixed our issue with the car.”
Emergency Services
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2017
Coupons & Offers
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Fastrak Oil & Lube

Fastrak Oil & Lube

(16)
Power Steering, Safety, Air Filtration
“When completed I asked to see which lights were replaced - it was a side light next to the headlight, and one of 2 lights illuminating my license plate.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Family Business
In Business Since 1997
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Tilden For Brakes Car Care Center

Tilden For Brakes Car Care Center

(19)
  • Reviews
  • Work
  • Professional
“I will definitely be coming back for any future vehicle maintenance/repair.”
Accepts Financing available
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1925
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Country Road Automotive

Country Road Automotive

(18)
Hybrid Repair & Maintenance, Transmission Repair, Brake Repair
“I took my truck in for regular maintenance, they did some repair work, explained the issues I had, and gave me the option to opt out of some of the repairs or reschedule them.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2011
Coupons & Offers
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Family Tire and Auto Repair

Family Tire and Auto Repair

(20)
  • Mechanic
  • Fast
  • Price
“I was on my way to New York to lay down some Tracks on a high end clients album at 4:30pm when my battery went I saw this guy across from the LIRR WESTBURY said he was finishing a prior job AND WAS CLOSING but took care of me anyway..”
Family Business
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2020
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Glen Head Motors Inc

Glen Head Motors Inc

(13)
Preventative Maintenance
“Great mechanic and very nice person.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2005
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Lincoln Avenue European Auto Service

Lincoln Avenue European Auto Service

(10)
Volkswagen Auto Repair NJ, Volvo Auto Repair NJ, Jaguar Auto Repair
“David checked my car over, gave me some insights on what may need repair/replacement in the near future, but ultimately gave my car a clean bill of health (just a minor power steering leak).”
Family Business
ASE, ASE Certified
In Business Since 2005
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Drive Auto Works

Drive Auto Works

(19)
  • Call
  • Dealership
  • Job
“For over ten years I have tried many shops only to find them swapping parts (at my cost) as opposed to properly diagnosing problems and repairing them.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2010
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
High Velocity Automotive

High Velocity Automotive

(20)
  • Brand
  • Insurance Company
  • Vehicle
“Shout to Marcela at High Velocity and her team if you want your car back looking brand new just like you bought it take your car there you won't be disappointed I highly recommend this shop.”
In Business Since 2013
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
3J Auto Repair

3J Auto Repair

(19)
  • Mechanic
  • Prices
“Been going to Henry for years at this point, I get my oil change there all the time and any other work for my cars, Henry is awesome and get the job done in a reasonable time.”
In Business Since 2017
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Brookville Auto Service Shop

Brookville Auto Service Shop

(17)
  • Pricing
“Highly recommend for high end and European cars.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1931
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Gino Foreign Cars Services

Gino Foreign Cars Services

(13)
  • Prices
“Always attentive and with a great service!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1993
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
L & D Services Station Inc

L & D Services Station Inc

(15)
  • Prices
“I bringing all my cars there”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1966
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Nick's Curbside Automotive Repair

Nick's Curbside Automotive Repair

(10)
  • Mechanic
“Great auto mechanic.”
In Business Since 2015
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Nunzio's Auto Works Inc

Nunzio's Auto Works Inc

(15)
  • Mechanic
“The best of the best and a gentleman to boot!”
In Business Since 2005
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Hana Auto Service

Hana Auto Service

(16)
  • Price
  • Reliable
  • Fast
“Fast service and honest one guy gave jimmy a 1 star he paid them a service and wrecked the suspension work jimmy did and is trying to blame Jimmy ppl are wanting things for free when they do nt get them they leave bad reviews”
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Joe's Garage

Joe's Garage

(10)
New York State Inspections, Foreign Repair, Domestic Repair
“Joe and his staff are extremely knowledgeable able to diagnose some of the most difficult problems and that pricing is very very fair the shop is an asset to the community”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2006
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Ramesh & Son

Ramesh & Son

(20)
  • Prices
  • Electrical
“I came in with a huge Jim I'm converting my 2013 Dodge Durango R/T in to a 2015 I tried to do this myself but I'm no electrician so decided to come here Ramesh and his son made me feel comfortable and assured me that they can get the job done which t...”
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Syosset Railroad Avenue Car Cr

Syosset Railroad Avenue Car Cr

(8)
“Best service”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2012
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Quality Auto Care

Quality Auto Care

(3)
“Best mechanic in area.”
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1986
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Cornerstone Restorations

Cornerstone Restorations

(5)
“High quality work with great customer service.”
Family Business
OSHA Certified
In Business Since 2016
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
John's Auto Repair

John's Auto Repair

(4)
“Would not ever go anywhere else ever again.”
In Business Since 2004
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Jeff's Carmagic

Jeff's Carmagic

(3)
  • Job
“I went to Jeffs car magic last week brought my 1983 ford mustang in which needed alot of tlc not only was Jeff kind but he was also very accommodating.”
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i

Auto Repair Services Estimated Cost in Oyster Bay, NY 2023

Minimum cost
$306
Maximum cost
$2550
National Average
$470
Avg Per Hour Rates
$82
$378
$663
Fair price range based on 245 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $470
Minimum cost $306
Maximum cost $2550
Avg Per Hour Rates $82

Fair range $378 to $663 is based on 245 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes No
Back To Top