Best Flat Tire Repair near Oyster Bay, NY

These experts serve Oyster Bay from nearby bases in towns including West Babylon, East Meadow and Farmingdale.

15 experts listed · 10 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 4, 2026

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

4.8 129 reviews
“They got my car taken care of quickly and the whole process was smooth.”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 2007Family-owned
Deer Park, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc

Extreme Tire Car Care Inc

4.7 13 reviews
“Not only we're they so quick, they were nice and it was at little cost as well!”
Bay Shore, NY · 14 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Tire Town Tire Pros

Tire Town Tire Pros

4.5 71 reviews
“Long story short Mike and everyone there could not have been more helpful!”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 1939Financing
Rockville Centre, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair

Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair

4.9 119 reviews
“The gentleman very kind and chill said no problem plugged and told me may last a month or more / less and bring it back !!”
Coupons & offersFree consultationSince 2010Family-ownedFinancing
Seaford, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Frontline Automotive (Get Off Exit 40 NY-27 Both Directions)

Frontline Automotive (Get Off Exit 40 NY-27 Both Directions)

4.9 130 reviews
“Nice friendly staff they did the work quick excellent and at a very fair price.”
24-mo/24k-mi warrantyASE-certified techsAll makes and modelsLoaner carsSince 2005Family-owned
West Babylon, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
AA Tire & Service

AA Tire & Service

4.8 119 reviews
“The real important aspect besides getting your car fixed is the level of repair, communication, and actually caring about their customer base is unmatched in this area”
ASE-certified techsPick-up & drop-offFinancing availableSince 1997Family-owned
Farmingdale, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i

Listed for drivers in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 15 shops repair flats and punctures. Hours, emergency service and whether they come to you are taken from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY

The 15 experts on this page are rated from 4.5 to 4.9 across 5,237 reviews; 14 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price", "honest" and "fair". 10 are open on Saturdays and 2 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are oil change (4), wheel alignments (4), brake repairs (3), transmission repair (3) and auto body (2). 5 list staff certifications (ASE) and 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 13 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 87 years. 7 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 7 are family- or locally-owned and 8 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 14 of the experts on this page; 14 publish a contact page; 10 list a public email and 8 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.

Can I get a puncture fixed on a Sunday?

10 of the 15 shops here show weekend hours, though Saturday is far more common than Sunday. A puncture repair is a short job, so a shop that takes walk-ins will often squeeze one in between booked work. Call rather than drive over on a flat.

Guanaco's Auto Repair

Guanaco's Auto Repair

4.5 50 reviews
“Don Carlos is a good, honest and serious man who knows how to do his job well.”
New York inspection stationInsurance claim helpSince 1996BBB A+
Hempstead, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Barnwell House of Tires, Inc.

Barnwell House of Tires, Inc.

4.8 70 reviews
“Blow out 645 am opened at 700 back on the road bye 715.”
Coupons & offersSince 2001Financing
West Babylon, NY · 10 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Barnwell House of Tires

Barnwell House of Tires

4.8 141 reviews
“He was so helpful, the environment was so kind, his brother and the other workers were so great and I felt so comfortable with my car in their hands!”
Since 1983Family-ownedFinancing
Mineola, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Billy Auto

Billy Auto

4.5 50 reviews
“My SUV had been having intermittent stalling issues, and after they installed the new system, everything started running more smoothly within a couple of days.”
Coupons & offersSince 1980Financing
Amityville, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Nut Just Lube & Tires

Nut Just Lube & Tires

4.9 109 reviews
“I come here all the time to do maintenance on my car and it's a pleasure speaking with the staff here and knowing you're in good hands and taken care of.”
Coupons & offersSince 2004Financing
Port Washington, NY · 9 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Hubcaps & Wheel Repair LLC

Hubcaps & Wheel Repair LLC

4.9 63 reviews
“Bryan was amazing, quick to respond, great follow up, and shared photos of the process along the way.”
Free estimatesWheel repair specialistSince 2016
East Northport, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Paul's Auto Repair

Paul's Auto Repair

4.8 124 reviews
“I always have the best experience bringing my car here for inspections, maintenance, and repairs.”
ASE certifiedSince 1994Family-ownedInsurance accepted
Great Neck, NY · 11 mi from Oyster Bay
i
Masters Auto Collision

Masters Auto Collision

4.7 92 reviews
“I recently had my 2016 KIA Soul repaired at Masters Auto Collison and I am so pleased with how the car came out.”
Since 2003Family-owned
East Meadow, NY · 5 mi from Oyster Bay
i
D & D Auto Clinic

D & D Auto Clinic

4.8 109 reviews
“Even when I had a blonde moment when i picked up my vehicle; they did humor me and answered my question with grace/patience.”
Coupons & offersSince 1988Insurance accepted
Massapequa, NY · 8 mi from Oyster Bay
i
HomeFlat Tire Repair ShopsNew YorkOyster Bay, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top