View Profile
Island Car Care
- Team
- Mechanic
- Battery
“And they always suggest what you may NEED next or what you SHOULD get done, (and as someone who's not a "car guy", I appreciate that), but with no pressure to do it now.”
Flat Tire Repair near Oyster Bay, NY
There are no experts listed in Oyster Bay itself yet; the 24 below are the closest options, from towns including Bay Shore (4, 14 mi), Hempstead (2, 10 mi) and Queens (2, 15 mi).
3 open 24/7 · 21 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+
View Profile
Brightside Automotive Repair
Tires, Transmissions, Auto Repair / Maintenance
“No run around, up sells or bs, they made space to look at my car immediately, they showed me the rock removed it checked out the rest of the car and sent me on my way.”
View Profile
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc
- Mechanic
- Oil
- Pickup
“..my car had a laundry list of things wrong and the guys tended to them as they found them kept me up to date every step of the process and give fair pricing can't recommend them enough definitely my go to mechanic from this point forward”
View Profile
All Around Tire and NYS Auto Inspection
- Brand
- Price
- Gentleman
“Very friendly very helpful sweet guy goes over and beyond for you talks to you too lightly great place cheap tires love this guy he is awesome makes you feel right at home even though it's a tire place”
View Profile
Tires On the Go Repair Inc (Mobile Tire Shop)
- Company
- Phone
- Rainy
“I called tires on the go at around 6pm since I waited 3 hrs for a tow truck because I had a flat tire and no spare on a rainy day and got to tires on the go around 6:55 pm.”
View Profile
Crossbay Tire Shop
- Leak
- Flat
- Job
“Oh my God they were so good they were courteous they help me so much they was a joy and a pleasure to be around”
Area overview: Oyster Bay, NY
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.0 to 5.0 across 7,230 reviews; 23 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. 3 are open around the clock; 21 are open on Saturdays and 8 on Sundays. Going by visit data for 8 of the experts on this page, Sunday evenings are the quietest and weekdays around midday the busiest. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are oil change (7), brake repair (5), wheel alignment (5), preventative maintenance (4) and schedule appointment (4). 6 list staff certifications (ASE) and 6 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 15 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 84 years. 3 offer emergency or roadside call-outs; 4 give free estimates and 13 are family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 20 of the experts on this page; 20 publish a contact page; 11 list a public email and 6 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Data verified October 6, 2026
Listed for drivers in and around Oyster Bay, NY, these 24 shops repair flats and punctures. Hours, emergency service and whether they come to you are taken from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
View Profile
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc
- Flat Tire
“Not only we're they so quick, they were nice and it was at little cost as well!”
View Profile
Tire Town Tire Pros
Nationwide Warranties, Car Winterization, Schedule Appointment
“Mind you I didn't even purchase the tire through this place and I was waiting over 2 weeks at the tire store inc in Freeport (They are a nightmare) where I had originally purchased it.”
View Profile
Bang's Towing Inc.
Diesel Fuel
“My family and I have tried many different towing companies over the years and I have to be truly honest, Bangs Towing in Amityville is hands down the best towing company we've ever used.”
View Profile
Merrick Tire Center
Oil Change in Queens NY, Nitrogen Inflation in Queens NY, Tires in Queens NY
“The Extremely friendly staff was incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to explain everything to me in detail, ensuring I understood the work being done.”
View Profile
Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair
Wheel Alignment, Tire Pressure Monitoring System (Tpms), Brake Repair
“Services Air & cabin filter replacement, Tires, General repairs & maintenance, Auto engine diagnostic, Tire rotations, Vehicle Inspection, Wheel alignment, Brakes, Wiper blade installation, Brake service & repair, Battery, Oil change”
View Profile
Frontline Auto Repair & NYS Inspection
Alternator Repair and Services, Tire Services, Inspection Diagnostics
“Frontline provides photos and videos of each recommended service before preforming any job, allowing the vehicle owner to see all the issues affecting their vehicle.”
View Profile
Hank May's Discount Tire & Auto Center
Schedule Appointment, CT & NY Inspections, Auto Repair
“They quoted me a price for the repairs I was looking to have performed, followed up over the phone when they saw other issues, gave me time to think about the additional costs associated, didn't pressure or upsell me.”
View Profile
Guanaco's Auto Repair
Auto Body/ Collision and General Auto Repair
“It's hard to find a good mechanic my experience here is fantastic Carlos the owner he will inspect your car and give you a price and time that is fare for job to be done (I price around) and always deliver what was agreed”
View Profile
Hewlett House
Tires, Repair Services, Preventative Maintenance
“Once again the guys at house of tires fixed a problem with my truck that I knew was going to be a nightmare to fix, they got it done quickly and for a fare price, Services Service not listed”
View Profile
Barnwell House
“My car is a 2009 and the spare was never used, he asked his mechanics to remove the blown tire and replace it with the spare, the mechanics made sure that the spare was up to par for my ride back to Queens.”
View Profile
Barnwell House
Hunter Wheel Alignment, Schedule My Service, Preventative Maintenance
“The staff are polite and very helpful, and as they are close to my job, I'm thinking about bringing my car to them from now on for most basic maintenance like oil changes and inspections.”
View Profile
Tire Discount Tire Pros
Diagnostic Center, Maintenance Adviser
“I can tell you that the old tradition of giving a straight answer, being charged for what I asked for, and being completed in a decent amount of time for my vehicle and for every every customer waiting there, I've nothing other than very good recomme...”
View Profile
And 1 Towing Inc
- van
- Second-Hand Car
- Towing Service
“One of the best companies I have ever dealt with very helpful and knowledgeable when it came to having my junk car removed call two companies They did not help me I would definitely highly recommend this company”
View Profile
AA Tire & Service
Rim and Tire Upgrades, Vehicle Glass Repair, Schedule Appointment
“Everything from fixing a flat to getting a replacement tier quickly to squeezing me in on a Saturday morning for an inspection, I know I can always count on him to take care of me.”
View Profile
The Body Shop
Auto Windshield Replacement, On-Site Car Rentals & Assistance, Full-Service Auto Body & Collision Repair
“From dealing with the insurance company to having a rental car waiting for me, Bill turned a highly stressful situation into one that was easy to manage and returned my car in “like new” condition.”
View Profile
Wond A Rama Tire
Schedule A Repair
“So happy she did, my car was collecting water because my ac drain was clogged and they cleared it for free since I came here a few times for other maintenance jobs!”
View Profile
All Weather Tires Sales & Service Inc
“They graciously let me take a couple days to decide whether to keep what I had or go with what I originally wanted, and when I decided to change them, the exchange was easy and they stayed very kind to me during the process.”
View Profile
Quick Used Tires
- Team
- Rim
- Money
“I would highly recommend this place reasonable pricing fast service and they took me a few minutes before they close a lot of places don't do that thank you so much much for your help and your kindness.”
Tire Repair Services in Oyster Bay, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$13
Maximum cost
$50
National Average
$25
$19
$37
Fair price range is based on 413 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
FAQ
Which shops listed for Oyster Bay fix punctures around the clock?
3 of the 24 shops here list round-the-clock hours every day of the week. For a flat that usually means a roadside truck rather than a lit workshop at 3 a.m., so say on the phone whether you need someone to come out or you can get the car there.