Best Auto Repair in Islip, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Repair companies out of 107 vetted & reviewed in the Islip area.

Eric's Cutting Edge Automotive

Eric's Cutting Edge Automotive

(30)
Tires, Led/Hid Light Conversions, Brakes
“Good people and very helpful without the cliche mechanic sales pitch.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2014
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
455 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
i
Split Second Auto Repair

Split Second Auto Repair

(45)
Napa Peace of Mind Warranty, Preventive Maintenance, Schedule My Service
“Services Transmission, Electrical repair, Air & cabin filter replacement, Auto battery replacement, Steering & suspension repair, Electrical, Auto engine diagnostic”
In Business Since 2016
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
55 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752
i
Route 111 Tire & Auto

Route 111 Tire & Auto

(49)
Other Services, OIL Changes, Shocks/Struts
“Been coming here for a few years and I wouldn't go anywhere else Pete “the owner” always does the right thing and I leave with my car worry free every time and the issue is always fixed !”
In Business Since 1989
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
226 Islip Ave, Islip, NY
i
Automotive Technology

Automotive Technology

(49)
Exhaust, State Inspections, Oil Changes
“They said they will fix it so no one else has this problem going forward (double charge) and genuinely seemed upset and disappointed this happened, and said they would "never charge those prices for filters.”
In Business Since 2009
Coupons & Offers
ASE Certified
836 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Central Islip Firestone

Central Islip Firestone

(42)
“I look forward to continuing my business there.”
In Business Since 2009
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
88 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
i
Mark's Auto Repair & Tire

Mark's Auto Repair & Tire

(48)
New York State Inspection, Auto Repairs and Maintenance, Brakes
“They went above and beyond to help me here, all I needed was an inspection but they helped me make sure my car was prepared for a long road trip tomorrow.”
In Business Since 2019
Family Business
ASE, ASE, ASE Certified
1069 Prospect Ave, West Islip, NY 11795
i
A1 Action Auto & Truck Repair

A1 Action Auto & Truck Repair

(46)
Tires, Towing, Auto Ac/Coolant Services
“I found it so hard to trust auto mechanics and always felt like I was being taken advantage of, but when I came here with a problem, Ed found it right away on the computer he hooked up to my car and explained my options.”
In Business Since 2017
Free Initial Consultation
110 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
i
Chucks Auto Repair S

Chucks Auto Repair S

(48)
  • Island
  • Fair
  • Prices
“Services Electrical repair, Exhaust, Auto power window repair, Auto water leak repair, General repairs & maintenance, Steering & suspension replacement, Auto engine diagnostic, Auto engine tuning, Engine repair, Vehicle Inspection, Brakes, Vehicle sa...”
In Business Since 2014
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
157 Nassau Ave # 1, Islip, NY
i
Art Mo Automotive

Art Mo Automotive

(40)
“More is the best mechanic I ever knew , he is fear respectful , honest he had fix my sister car and keep the maintenance for my car and my teen daughter car he is absolutely the best mechanic in town.”
In Business Since 1969
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
200 Main St, Islip, NY
i
County Collision

County Collision

(24)
Local Pick-Up & Drop-Off Service, Paintless Dent Removal, Foreign & Domestic Repairs
“Best job I could have ever asked for and best staff around especially that young man ando, cleaned my car perfect and will and the guys got it fixed back to better then I could have asked”
In Business Since 1991
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
227 Main St, Islip, NY
i
Madden Automotive

Madden Automotive

(24)
Diesel Fuel
“Services Exhaust, Tires, Steering & suspension repair, General repairs & maintenance, Steering & suspension replacement, Auto brake repair, Tire rotations, Engine repair, Vehicle Inspection, Auto exhaust system replacement, Wheel alignment, Brakes, A...”
In Business Since 2007
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
41 E Main St, East Islip, NY 11730
i
All American Automotive Inc

All American Automotive Inc

(22)
  • Prices
  • Vehicle
  • Mechanic
“Jim Harry and Tommy are exceptionally trustworthy and honest and do excellent quality work which is hard to come by these days you can't go wrong with All American I wouldn't think of going anywhere else they are the BEST”
In Business Since 2013
Family Business
Free Initial Consultation
190 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Tire Express

Tire Express

(45)
  • Engine
  • Oil
  • Flat
“We've been a customer for over 16 years Best customer service, best work, fastest work and the most awesome people I've ever had to deal with I definitely recommend them.”
In Business Since 2001
165 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730
i
Best Deals Auto Repair and Brakes

Best Deals Auto Repair and Brakes

(41)
  • Calipers
  • Island
  • Writing
“The amount of people who came in and were assisted with a vary of troubles and were attended to swiftly and respectfully was just another sign to me I was in the right place for repairs.”
781 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795
i
Sunrise Transmission Corp

Sunrise Transmission Corp

(19)
Warranties & Guarantees, Free Estimates, Same Day Service
“Had 2 done , they paid for the tow.”
In Business Since 1982
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
2877 Sunrise Hwy, Islip Terrace, NY 11752
i
Fair & Square Automotive Group

Fair & Square Automotive Group

(19)
  • Fast
  • Price
  • Excellent
“I picked up a 2006 Ram after searching for a good deal on a truck for 8 months and they really hooked me up worked with my budget and even got me a great Warranty”
In Business Since 2021
46 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752
i
Pride Automotive

Pride Automotive

(8)
“Good shop”
In Business Since 2016
Coupons & Offers
300 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Fast Mobile Auto Repair Fleet Service

Fast Mobile Auto Repair Fleet Service

(30)
  • The Future
  • Price
  • Honest
“Excellent service 100% recommended, in addition to verifying the problem for which I contacted you, he discovered another worse one from a previous, very honest job.”
309 Main St unit 75, Islip, NY
i
Lobato Auto Services

Lobato Auto Services

(26)
  • Vehicles
  • Mechanic
  • Honest
“We have been going to them for 11 years and love Sergio for his honesty and get services as well as his prices, we couldn't go to no one else to get what we get now”
In Business Since 2004
103 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
i
Richie's Service Station

Richie's Service Station

(34)
  • Mechanic
“The auto shop did an excellent job for me, thanks”
In Business Since 1979
Accepts Cash only
92 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752
i
Start To Finish Auto

Start To Finish Auto

(16)
  • Price
  • Engine
  • Diagnosed
“That was months ago and the problem never returned… I will only bring my car to Eric… It has 150,000+ miles and counting… “Thank You “… Services Transmission, Electrical repair, General repairs & maintenance, Auto engine diagnostic, Auto sunroof glas...”
299 Islip Ave, Islip, NY
i
Island Car Care Center

Island Car Care Center

(20)
  • Work
  • Prices
  • Job
“I am a permanent customer, and I have payment plan with them, so that without having money to pay them , I still get back to work, and pay them later, Today I hit a big pile of snow, my cooling system broke down, They did instant replacement, on pa...”
In Business Since 2014
230 Main St, Islip, NY
i
Sav-Way Fuel Oil Co

Sav-Way Fuel Oil Co

“We are proud to say we have been serving our community for over 50 years - that's right five decades! This business started with my Dad and it has passed down to me. My name is Anthony, and I am the proud owner. I am happy that you are with me right ...”
In Business Since 2013
Licensed
269 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Willco Mechanical

Willco Mechanical

(7)
  • Converted
  • Gas
  • Chimney
“In this day of contractor horror stories, I want to commend and give a shout-out to Chris and his team for not only being great at what they do, but also for their excellent customer service and professionalism.”
In Business Since 2009
Free Initial Consultation
73 Dunwoodie Ave, West Islip, NY 11795
i

Auto Repair Services in Islip, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$371
Maximum cost
$3085
National Average
$568
Avg Per Hour Rates
$99
$457
$803
Fair price range is based on 406 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $568
Minimum cost $371
Maximum cost $3085
Avg Per Hour Rates $99

Fair range $457 to $803 is based on 406 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top

0 of these 24 professionals are in Islip.

About Automotive Repair services in Islip

None of the 24 professionals listed here are in Islip itself; they are in the surrounding area.

Ratings range from 4.4 to 5.0 across 2,970 reviews; 16 professionals have 50 or more reviews; 22 are rated 4.5 or higher.

4 mention certified staff (ASE).

8 give free estimates; 4 describe themselves as family- or locally-owned.

Services most often listed on their websites: tires (6), brakes (4), oil changes (4), engine repair (4), brake repair (4), nys inspections & oil changes (2) and state inspections (2).

In structured review feedback, customers of these professionals most often flagged quality (96%), professionalism (91%) and value (87%).

24 of the 24 professionals have a website on file; 18 publish a contact page; 8 list a public email; 2 take online bookings.

12 of these professionals have had their website domain for ten or more years; the oldest was registered in 2009.

Figures are counted over the professionals on this page from public listings and company websites collected in 2026; distances are straight-line; hours and prices change, so confirm before you visit.

The 24 shops on this page handle general repair work in and around Islip, NY. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

FAQ

What should I settle before leaving the car?

Who phones you if the price moves, what the diagnostic charge is and whether it comes off the repair, which grade of parts is in the quote, and what the warranty covers. Ask when you get the car back and what happens if a part has to be ordered in.

Do repair shops take fleet or business accounts?

Plenty of independents do, and it usually means monthly billing, priority scheduling and one named contact rather than whoever answers the phone. Most do not advertise it, so ask directly. The listings show which shops mention fleet or commercial work on their own sites.

What paperwork should I keep after a repair?

The itemized invoice with parts and labor on separate lines, the warranty terms, and the old parts if you asked for them back. It matters when the same fault returns, and it matters at resale, because a folder of receipts is the only proof the car was looked after.

Which shops in Islip estimate for free?

[N_FREE] of the 24 shops on this page advertise estimates at no charge. That normally covers a look and a price on work you can already see. Anything that needs the car on a lift and the codes read is a diagnosis, and a diagnosis is usually billed.

What customers in Islip say about local professionals

Excerpts from public reviews of the professionals listed on this page.