Best Auto Repair in Smithtown, NY

19 professionals listed · all 19 in Smithtown · 14 open weekends · 17 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Smithtown Auto Works

Smithtown Auto Works

4.9 48 reviews
“I would recommend smithown auto works to anyone who has cat troubles.”
Coupons & offersBBB A+Since 1977
324 E Main St
i
Rob's Auto Service LTD

Rob's Auto Service LTD

4.9 50 reviews
“If you are looking for an excellent mechanic and all around good person, well then, Robs Auto is the perfect place.”
Coupons & offersSince 1996Financing
100 Smithtown Blvd
i
Bobby's One Stop Custom Exhaust Auto Repair Shop

Bobby's One Stop Custom Exhaust Auto Repair Shop

4.9 48 reviews
“Went there to have an exhaust system installed on my Bronco and it came out perfect.”
Free tire rotationSame-day serviceFleet accounts30+ yearsEmergency serviceFamily-owned
1023 W Jericho Turnpike
i
Independent Motorcar

Independent Motorcar

5.0 42 reviews
“I would highly recommend them to any one looking for a specialty shop that can care for classic Defenders.”
Land Rover specialistRoutine maintenance $500Free consultation25+ years
974 W Jericho Turnpike
i
A & R Auto Repair

A & R Auto Repair

4.9 44 reviews
“They were very patient as it had to be retested for codes many times before it passed inspection.”
ASE-certified techsNew York inspection stationWalk-ins welcomeFinancing availableFleet accountsFree consultation
376 E Main St
i
Trannyman Complete Auto Care

Trannyman Complete Auto Care

4.6 32 reviews
“Mike at Trannyman was awesome and got me on the road with a full service and NYS inspection for 1/2 the price of the dealer and I was done in 1hr and 45 minutes.”
$25 off1-yr warrantyASE certifiedSince 2015Family-owned
1052 W Jericho Turnpike
i

Listed for drivers in and around Smithtown, NY, these 19 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Smithtown, NY

All 19 professionals we list here are in Smithtown itself. The professionals on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 1,121 reviews; 6 have 50 or more reviews and 17 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these professionals on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (90%), quality (78%) and value (61%). 14 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the professionals on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), computer diagnostics (2), fleet maintenance (2), preventative maintenance (2) and tires (2). 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 2 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 10 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 49 years. 1 offers emergency or roadside call-outs; 2 offer financing; 3 give free estimates; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 4 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 9 of the professionals on this page; 9 publish a contact page; 4 list a public email and 2 take bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.

How long have the listed shops been open?

10 of the 19 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.

Smithtown General Tire

Smithtown General Tire

4.7 45 reviews
“Had a problem with my tire, they resolved the issue quickly and thoroughly.”
Since 1990
890 W Jericho Turnpike
i
Smithtown CAR Service Inc.

Smithtown CAR Service Inc.

4.4 46 reviews
“They went above and beyond to ensure my car was fixed promptly and at a very fair price.”
1007 W Jericho Turnpike
i
Gerard's Quality Auto & Truck

Gerard's Quality Auto & Truck

4.6 22 reviews
“A1 shop, always a Great experience, fair pricing, and they are thorough, Highly recommend”
New York inspection stationForeign & domestic carsSince 1986
988 W Jericho Turnpike
i
Classic Auto Services

Classic Auto Services

4.7 32 reviews
“Have used them twice in the past few months and extremely happy with the service I have received.”
Since 2009
240 W Main St
i
Jaxson's Automotive

Jaxson's Automotive

4.9 32 reviews
“Felt prioritized and respected throughout the entire process of working with them on car repair and state inspection, with up front pricing and clear explanations of service and issues.”
376 E Main St
i
Island Auto Repair

Island Auto Repair

5.0 6 reviews
“From convenient scheduling to expert repairs, we find Vinny's Island Auto Repair to be consistent and reliable, and appreciate the positive experience every time.”
Since 2018
917 W Jericho Turnpike
i
Nesconset Auto Service

Nesconset Auto Service

4.8 20 reviews
“They definitely know what they are doing and very nice to customers.”
209 Smithtown Blvd
i
Andre's Precision Auto

Andre's Precision Auto

4.7 20 reviews
“He quickly diagnosed and fixed the issues with my car and was honest and respectful throughout the process.”
Since 2011
62 Smithtown Blvd
i
Pete's Stop Automobile Care

Pete's Stop Automobile Care

4.9 12 reviews
“Going to him for 10 plus years!”
Since 2013
241 Terry Rd
i
North Shore Automotive Group Inc

North Shore Automotive Group Inc

4.3 11 reviews
“The service provided was excellent and top-notch.”
9 Bank Ave
i
Branch Auto Collision

Branch Auto Collision

4.7 11 reviews
“Dave is a great repair guy”
Since 1979
397 E Main St
i
Manny Auto Diagnostics

Manny Auto Diagnostics

4.9 9 reviews
“"I had the pleasure of meeting manny and picking him as my new Car Doctor, he has taken care of my car issues a few times, from regular maintenance to unselected issues, he has been transparent every single time, walking me through the process of what needs to be done and choices I may have, which I appreciate so much!!!”
331 E Main St
i
North Shore Automotive LLC

North Shore Automotive LLC

5.0 2 reviews
“They fixed my mother's old car with a good price.”
9 Bank Ave
i
HomeAuto Repair ShopsNew YorkSmithtown, NY

Why these companies made our list

What customers say about professionals in Smithtown

  • “Took my car with front end damage right away and gave a very reasonable estimate for repair.” — customer of Branch Auto Collision
  • “Communication was solid. Got texts updating me on the findings and an attached estimate.” — customer of Rob's Auto Service LTD
  • “Honest, thorough, clean & pleasant. They handle all auto repairs, not just tires.” — customer of Smithtown General Tire
  • “I received a detailed estimate of parts and labor so there were no surprises.” — customer of Independent Motorcar

Excerpts from public reviews of the professionals listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top