Best Mechanic Shops in Smithtown, NY
15 technicians listed · 9 in Smithtown · 9 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+
Data verified November 4, 2026
Rob's Auto Service LTD
Independent Motorcar
Trannyman Complete Auto Care
A & R Auto Repair
Smithtown General Tire & Service
Listed for drivers in and around Smithtown, NY, these 15 shops are general mechanics. What each one states about certifications, warranties and financing comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Smithtown, NY
Of the 15 technicians we list here, 9 are in Smithtown itself and 6 come from towns including Kings Park (1, 3 mi), Nesconset (1, 4 mi) and Central Islip (1, 5 mi). The technicians on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 2,793 reviews; 11 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "price", "honest" and "fair". 9 are open on Saturdays. The services the technicians on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), preventative maintenance (2) and wheel alignment (2). 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 5 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 9 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 47 years. 3 offer financing; 3 give free estimates; 3 are family- or locally-owned and 3 list coupons or special offers. 1 has Spanish-speaking staff. We have a website on file for 12 of the technicians on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 9 list a public email and 2 take bookings online. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.
Which shops listed for Smithtown work on Saturdays or Sundays?
9 of the 15 shops list weekend hours. Saturday is usually a shorter day; Sunday openings are rarer and often by appointment.
Island Auto Repair
Branch Auto Collision
North Shore Automotive Group Inc
Manny Auto Diagnostics
Lake Auto Service
US-1 Auto Repair
Globe Transmissions
Bohemia Autocare
King's Park Car Care Center
Why these companies made our list
What customers say about technicians in Smithtown
- “Got tires and brakes done here. Friendly staff, knowledgeable, priced well, honest hard working people.” — customer of Smithtown General Tire & Service
- “There is no issue that Eric (manager) cannot diagnose, nor work that their professional techs cannot complete.” — customer of Independent Motorcar
- “They were absolutely amazing and extremely friendly. Would highly recommend going to them for any repairs needed.” — customer of A & R Auto Repair
- “Skilled auto mechanics that know their stuff. The turnaround time was the same day.” — customer of Rob's Auto Service LTD
- “Super friendly and helpful, they truly care about their customers and this has become my go-to place for oil changes, inspections, and tires.” — customer of Smithtown General Tire & Service
Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.
Mechanic Shops near Smithtown
Popular in Smithtown
, NYGuides: Mechanic Shops
Brake Pad Replacement Cost: Do You Really Need Rotors?
Can a Mechanic Charge More Than the Estimate? State Rules
Can I Bring My Own Parts to a Mechanic? What It Saves
Car Battery Replacement Cost 2026: Price by Where You Buy
Car Won't Start? What the Sound Means and What It Costs
Do Mechanics Have to Warranty Their Work? (2026)