Best Car Mechanics in Smithtown, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Service companies out of 128 vetted & reviewed in the Smithtown area.

Brigandi Brothers

Brigandi Brothers

(20)
  • Pricing
  • Job
  • Family
“Great mechanics !!!”
In Business Since 1983
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
227 Smithtown Blvd, Smithtown, NY
i
Rob's Auto Service LTD

Rob's Auto Service LTD

(20)
Schedule A Repair, Fleet Services, Technet Warranty
“I Have been going to Rob for over ten years now he is very knowledgeable about all makes of cars and finds a reasonable solution and does quality work .”
In Business Since 1997
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
100 Smithtown Blvd, Smithtown, NY
i
Independent Motorcar

Independent Motorcar

(19)
  • Truck
  • Pricing
  • Range Rover
“I had to drive 3200 miles from New York to San Francisco and took my car in to make sure everything was ready to go before the move, and they took their time to make sure everything was in top notch shape and ready to go for the drive.”
25++ Years Experience
974 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY
i
Medford Fast Lube

Medford Fast Lube

(1)
Engine Repair, Our Auto Repair Services Include:, Fleet Service and Maintenance
“James is the best !!”
In Business Since 2011
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Brightside Automotive Repair

Brightside Automotive Repair

(20)
24-Hour Emergency Towing, Auto Repair / Maintenance, Oil Changes
“No run around, up sells or bs, they made space to look at my car immediately, they showed me the rock removed it checked out the rest of the car and sent me on my way.”
In Business Since 2015
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Automotive Technology

Automotive Technology

(20)
Engine Repair, Transmission Service, AC & Heat Repair
“I need to share my latest experience with my Lexus dealer in Smithtown, my wife went for an oil change and tire rotation fine and dandy tender wrap came up to my wife and said oh by the way your rear struts in your Lexus hybrid 2017 needs replacing m...”
In Business Since 2009
ASE Certified
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
836 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

(20)
Engine Tune-Ups, Transmission Service, NY State Inspections
“00 the first time the brake would disengage but the indicators light on the dash stayed on, causing my cruse control to not work because it thought the brake was on.”
In Business Since 1986
ASE Certified
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Miltner & Sons Auto Care

Miltner & Sons Auto Care

(18)
  • Price
“Thanks guys!”
In Business Since 1992
ASE Certified
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

(19)
Fleet Services
“They are always friendly, extremely knowledgeable, and keep you informed about the progress of the work being done (they use a cool program that shows you the progress as well as positives, areas of concern, and recommendations).”
In Business Since 2006
ASE, ASE Certified
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Tire Discount Tire Pros

Tire Discount Tire Pros

(15)
Diagnostic Center, Maintenance Adviser
“The shop communicated clearly by text and phone calls.”
In Business Since 1981
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
3914 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown, NY
i
Bruno's Towing

Bruno's Towing

(18)
  • Truck
  • Price
  • Drivers
“Recommended by K&M, and was grateful for the prompt, professional, and reasonable cost for a early morning roadside repair that was in urgent need...”
In Business Since 1971
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Emergency Services
Family Business
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Higbie Service Center

Higbie Service Center

(15)
Collision Repair, Custom Painting, Insurance
“Today I brought my 15 year old Frontier in with what I was sure was a brake problem and a muffler issue I was hoping to repair without replacing the whole thing.”
In Business Since 2018
Free Initial Consultation
217 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Roli Tire & Auto Repair

Roli Tire & Auto Repair

(16)
Commercial Tires, Commercial Tire Retreading, 24-Hour Roadside Service
“I definitely use them again .”
In Business Since 1977
Accepts Debit, All Major Credit Cards, Check
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Accord Transmission & Differential

Accord Transmission & Differential

(17)
  • Money
  • Price
  • Fast
“He assisted this single mom with such compassion and assured me he would do everything in his power to fix my sons car without having me worry about a large expense all other places were quoting me .”
In Business Since 1974
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Smithtown Area
i
MD Auto Repair

MD Auto Repair

(18)
Auto Repair, Collision Repair
“Recently new to the area it's very hard to find a good mechanic I did my homework and went with the reviews for MD Auto Repair all I can say is I consider myself lucky I asked them to look over my whole car they gave me a list what was wrong I am ver...”
In Business Since 1990
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Barnwell House

Barnwell House

(17)
  • Area
  • Price
  • Little
“I suggest make appointment and drop vehicle off if possible.”
In Business Since 2001
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Route 111 Tire & Auto

Route 111 Tire & Auto

(20)
Shocks/Struts, Wheel Alignment, Front END
“Guys are 👍 great”
In Business Since 1989
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
226 Islip Ave, Islip, NY
i
Bo's Auto and Truck Repair

Bo's Auto and Truck Repair

(20)
  • Price
  • Oil
  • Fair
“Fast forward to this morning with multiple issues, windshield wipers loose and the pump wasn't working, the right directional was making a fast blinker sound, plus my right passenger door wouldn't open fully due to impact.”
In Business Since 2021
Coupons & Offers
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

(20)
  • Trustworthy
  • Honest
  • Confident
“Wade took a look at my car and told me that, not only did the chain shop (it was a Pep Boys) screw up their work on my car and leave it worse than when I went in, but that the actual repair I needed was something completely different that would only ...”
In Business Since 1970
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Serving Smithtown Area
i
All American Automotive Inc

All American Automotive Inc

(19)
  • Prices
“Jim Harry and Tommy are exceptionally trustworthy and honest and do excellent quality work which is hard to come by these days you can't go wrong with All American I wouldn't think of going anywhere else they are the BEST”
In Business Since 2013
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
190 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY
i
Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

(18)
Visibility & Accessories, Radiator & Engine Cooling, Alignments
“I asked for a wheel alignment and Chris the owner told me yesterday to go back to Costco where I bought the Michelin tires from and have them balance the front again because it shakes at 75mph.”
100+ Years Experience
Licensed
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Ossies Auto Repair

Ossies Auto Repair

(20)
Transmission Services, General Services, AIR Condition & Heating
“I've always hated bringing my cars to mechanics for repair because unfortunately the industry in general isn't very trustworthy- until you come here.”
In Business Since 2002
ASE, ASE Certified
Locally Owned & Operated
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Marrone Service Station

Marrone Service Station

(18)
  • Price
  • Mechanic
  • Quick
“Honda was charging me for almost 1k for leaks but when I came to Marrone, Richard said there was no leak it's just the mess Honda did when they changed my oil.”
In Business Since 1992
ASE, ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Serving Smithtown Area
i
Acme Auto Radiator Incorporation

Acme Auto Radiator Incorporation

(18)
  • Price
  • Business
“Very honest and if you go there and tell him you want to change a part on your car he he makes sure it's not something else before he changes it for no reason”
In Business Since 1952
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Serving Smithtown Area
i

Auto Mechanic Services in Smithtown, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$296
Maximum cost
$2956
National Average
$651
Avg Per Hour Rates
$107
$473
$828
Fair price range is based on 357 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $651
Minimum cost $296
Maximum cost $2956
Avg Per Hour Rates $107

Fair range $473 to $828 is based on 357 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top