Best Car Mechanics in Brookhaven, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Service companies out of 127 vetted & reviewed in the Brookhaven area.

Medford Fast Lube

Medford Fast Lube

(1)
Axle Repair, Engine Repair, Battery Replacement
“James is the best !!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Brigandi Brothers

Brigandi Brothers

(20)
  • Family
  • Reliable
  • Job
“Family has used these guys for over 40 years, nothing but positive experiences and fair pricing.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1983
227 Smithtown Blvd, Smithtown, NY
i
Rob's Auto Service LTD

Rob's Auto Service LTD

(20)
Wheel Straightening, Antique Car Repair & Sales, Fleet Services
“I Have been going to Rob for over ten years now he is very knowledgeable about all makes of cars and finds a reasonable solution and does quality work .”
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1997
100 Smithtown Blvd, Smithtown, NY
i
Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

(19)
Fleet Services
“They are always friendly, extremely knowledgeable, and keep you informed about the progress of the work being done (they use a cool program that shows you the progress as well as positives, areas of concern, and recommendations).”
Offers Financing Options
Free Initial Consultation
ASE, ASE Certified
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
MD Auto Repair

MD Auto Repair

(18)
Collision Repair, Auto Repair
“Recently new to the area it's very hard to find a good mechanic I did my homework and went with the reviews for MD Auto Repair all I can say is I consider myself lucky I asked them to look over my whole car they gave me a list what was wrong I am ver...”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1990
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Barnwell House

Barnwell House

(17)
  • Professional
  • Area
  • Job
“Took me right away amd fixed both tire valves on RV reasonable price and great service”
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2001
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Bo's Auto and Truck Repair

Bo's Auto and Truck Repair

(20)
  • Fair
  • Fast
  • Oil
“And Crystal is amazing at making you real comfortable in bringing in your vehicle to there shop and rest a shore it goes in sick and comes out with a dealer tag trust me.”
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2021
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Route 111 Tire & Auto

Route 111 Tire & Auto

(20)
Brake Service, OIL Changes, Other Services
“Over the years I've been extremely satisfied with the world, level of professionalism form the crew members.”
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1989
226 Islip Ave, Islip, NY
i
Acme Auto Radiator Incorporation

Acme Auto Radiator Incorporation

(18)
  • Business
  • Price
“Very honest and if you go there and tell him you want to change a part on your car he he makes sure it's not something else before he changes it for no reason”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1954
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Ossies Auto Repair

Ossies Auto Repair

(20)
Undercar Services, Transmission Services, Brake Services
“I've always hated bringing my cars to mechanics for repair because unfortunately the industry in general isn't very trustworthy- until you come here.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
ASE, ASE Certified
Locally Owned & Operated
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

(18)
Tire & Tire Repair, Visibility & Accessories, Alignments
“I asked for a wheel alignment and Chris the owner told me yesterday to go back to Costco where I bought the Michelin tires from and have them balance the front again because it shakes at 75mph.”
Licensed
100+ Years Experience
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
L.I. Bimmer Pros

L.I. Bimmer Pros

(20)
Although we Specialize in Bmw
“He has even helped me fix things I broke while trying to install aftermarket parts without any judgement about me using duct tape and zip ties to patch it together to drive it over to him.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards, Cash
BMWNA Certified
In Business Since 2019
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Bohemia Autocare

Bohemia Autocare

(20)
  • Oil
  • Pleasure
  • Team
“I felt comfortable with their assessment and chose to just have the A/C system repaired but not the faulty passenger seat lights since it wasn't detrimental to the function of the vehicle.”
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2017
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
County Collision

County Collision

(8)
Assistance With Paperwork & Insurance Forms, Free Computerized Estimates, Computerized Color Matching
“They were amazing because I felt they really had great customer service and fought hard for me with the insurance company to get the best value on my repairs.”
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1987
227 Main St, Islip, NY
i
D & S Automotive Center

D & S Automotive Center

(13)
  • Family
“I left my registration sticker on my passenger seat to remind myself to replace it when I got home and when I was driving home, I realized they did it for me.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1974
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Pete B Service Inc

Pete B Service Inc

(17)
A/C Service, Services Offered, Check Engine Light
“They didn't work on the TLX besides determine what was wrong with it - I actually ended up returning the vehicle 3 weeks later after the dealership gave up on attempting to repair it.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1975
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
United Exhaust Shop II Inc

United Exhaust Shop II Inc

(19)
  • Work
  • Quick
  • Quality
“I recommend his work to anyone that is looking to get their exhaust done , the headers were install by him for a reasonable fee and they look awesome , the flow master sounds nice too not too loud.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1993
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
King Bear Auto Services Center

King Bear Auto Services Center

(19)
  • Family
  • Honest
  • Prices
“I've been going here for over 10yrs for a reason, Eddie and his team are amazing at what they do, they are upfront about everything and their work speaks for itself.”
In Business Since 2021
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Jetski Repair

Jetski Repair

(19)
  • Call
  • Professional
  • Job
“Professional fast affordable service , fixed my problem when no one else could , very knowledgeable, also did my winterized and Shrink-wrapped my skis boat and patio furniture.”
Emergency Services
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
CPL Automotive Inc

CPL Automotive Inc

(15)
  • Work
  • Family
  • Volvo
“Charlie and all the guys went above and beyond and were very patient diagnosing the issue with my Volvo and they refused payment until they figured out the problem.”
In Business Since 2019
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Appel Auto Service

Appel Auto Service

(11)
  • Cost
  • Mechanic
“I did and he inspected the certified used car before I bought it (a silver toyota corolla w/ ~10K miles) and Kevin said it was a great car with no issues and no accidents.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE, ASE Certified
In Business Since 1996
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Master Muffler & Brakes

Master Muffler & Brakes

(20)
Shocks & Struts, Oil Changes, Custom Bending
“I took my jeep here 2 days ago and my check engine light wouldn't go off and they were able to figure it out and fix it and they were quick with repairs and the inspection AMAZING service 5 stars easy definitely going back to them.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2001
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Double N Automotive

Double N Automotive

(15)
Automotive Battery Repair, Filter Change, Brake Service
“My car is a lowered mustang, it practically scrapes the ground as i drive, had a failed ball joint and he got it on the flat bed and off with no damage.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1991
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Tom's Mid Island Auto

Tom's Mid Island Auto

(18)
  • Business
  • Vehicle
  • Inspection
“Then a month later I had hit a pot hole and experienced some damage and one of the tubes under the hood was leaking fluid into the transmission and it caused the transmission to malfunction.”
Serving Brookhaven Area
i

Auto Mechanic Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$310
Maximum cost
$3099
National Average
$682
Avg Per Hour Rates
$112
$496
$868
Typical price range is based on 265 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $682
Minimum cost $310
Maximum cost $3099
Avg Per Hour Rates $112

Typical range $496 to $868 is based on 265 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top