Best Mechanic Shops near Brookhaven, NY

We have one technician in Brookhaven on file, and it is on this list, along with 14 from towns including Patchogue (4, 5 mi), Bohemia (3, 9 mi) and Lake Ronkonkoma (2, 8 mi).

7 open weekends · all 15 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license

Data verified November 4, 2026

Azion Auto Service

Azion Auto Service

4.8 145 reviews
“I thought something was seriously wrong with my transmission, but Ray checked it out did a transmission tuneup and it seems to work great now!”
Since 2022
2515 Montauk Hwy
i
Lake Auto Service

Lake Auto Service

4.9 131 reviews
“My car is back on the road already after just a few days that would take other mechanic places at least a week.”
BBB accreditedSince 2003Family-owned
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
US-1 Auto Repair

US-1 Auto Repair

4.8 56 reviews
“Just a great shop Stephen and the whole crew nothing but professionals the can fix anything!!”
ASE-certified techsBBB A+Since 1987
Centereach, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Realspeed Automotive

Realspeed Automotive

4.8 88 reviews
“Realspeed is the first shop that really understood how to work on the car and gave me meaningful advice on how to optimize it”
Free phone consultationMustang specialistBBB accreditedSince 2019
Bohemia, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Book onlineBook
MD Auto Repair

MD Auto Repair

4.8 122 reviews
“Stopped by here with an issue that needed immediate attention and they took time out of their days to get me quickly back on the road and were very reasonable on price.”
$46.32 off maintenanceASE-certified techsFinancing availableFree consultationSince 1989
Patchogue, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Ossie's Auto Repair

Ossie's Auto Repair

4.9 124 reviews
“I spent quite some time in their shop and readily became acquainted with their customer service and the friendly, informative manner in which they handled every customer who came and went”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 1999
Bohemia, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i

Listed for drivers in and around Brookhaven, NY, these 15 shops are general mechanics. What each one states about certifications, warranties and financing comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Brookhaven, NY

The 15 technicians on this page are rated from 4.6 to 5.0 across 4,219 reviews; all 15 have 50 or more reviews. When customers rate these technicians on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (100%), quality (82%) and value (75%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "fair" and "honest". 7 are open on Saturdays. The services the technicians on this page list most often on their websites are oil changes (4), brake repair (3), brakes (3), steering & suspension (3) and tires (3). 2 show a license on their websites; 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 12 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 100 years. 1 offers financing; 3 give free estimates; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 6 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 15 of the technicians on this page; 12 publish a contact page; 9 list a public email and 4 take bookings online. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

Which shops listed for Brookhaven work on Saturdays or Sundays?

7 of the 15 shops list weekend hours. Saturday is usually a shorter day; Sunday openings are rarer and often by appointment.

ER Automotive

ER Automotive

4.9 41 reviews
“1st time using ER automotive, got my truck inspected, they went out of their way to fix a couple minor issues free of charge.”
Free consultationLicensed40+ years
Medford, NY · 3 mi from Brookhaven
i
Tire City

Tire City

4.8 87 reviews
“Only place I could find that patches tires along with plugging tires they work very fast and efficient highly recommend”
Coupons & offersSince 1990FinancingLocally owned
Shirley, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Enginetech Auto Repair

Enginetech Auto Repair

4.9 127 reviews
“The owner, Bernie, is always the kinfest and most accommodating trying to do his best to service his customers' automotive needs”
ASE certifiedSince 1997
Patchogue, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Nico's Way Auto Repair

Nico's Way Auto Repair

4.8 75 reviews
“In this day and age it is very hard to find somebody honest and reputable.”
36-mo/36k-mi warrantyLoaner carsSince 2007Family-ownedASE certified
Bohemia, NY · 9 mi from Brookhaven
i
Performance Auto Solutions

Performance Auto Solutions

4.9 86 reviews
“Joe at the front desk is always patient, attentive, and personable when you call and takes the time to listen to your concerns about your car.”
12-mo/12k-mi warrantyIAG Performance-certifiedSubaru specialistWalk-ins welcomeStandard labor $135/hrSince 2015
Holbrook, NY · 6 mi from Brookhaven
i
Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc

4.7 67 reviews
“Arthur and his team take great care of my truck and do superior work.”
Since 1990Licensed
Patchogue, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
Taurus Auto Center

Taurus Auto Center

5.0 66 reviews
“They don't just see another car coming through the shop; they see a customer who has placed their trust in them, and they take that responsibility seriously”
Since 2017
Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

Gene's 112 Auto Service Center

4.8 123 reviews
“Besides the full computer report covering my car top to bottom, they went one by one the areas of most concern and gave me direct and honest pricing and a plan that suited my particular vehicle.”
Coupons & offersSince 2006
Patchogue, NY · 5 mi from Brookhaven
i
3 Brothers Auto Repair

3 Brothers Auto Repair

4.6 71 reviews
“Came in for a tire plug they were fast kind and very helpful!!”
Coupons & offersSince 2014
Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 8 mi from Brookhaven
i
HomeMechanic ShopsNew YorkBrookhaven, NY

Why these companies made our list

What customers say about technicians near Brookhaven

  • “Lucky us, we now have a new place to go and can feel comfortable and confident in the entire interaction, from diagnosis to solution to repair.” — customer of Azion Auto Service
  • “Very friendly atmosphere and very good communication. They found the issue with the car after a very thorough inspection and diagnostics.” — customer of Ossie's Auto Repair
  • “The communication was timely, included diagnostic pictures and a detailed breakdown of the work required along with the associated costs.” — customer of Gene's 112 Auto Service Center
  • “The owner was very welcoming and honest. The mechanic was also honest, took the time to show and explain what was wrong with car and wasn’t pushy in trying to sell me anything.” — customer of 3 Brothers Auto Repair
  • “Knowledgeable tuner (Colin), knowledge team / techs. These guys have been crazy patient with my subi and all of its issues, super friendly, understanding, helpful.” — customer of Performance Auto Solutions

Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top