Brightside Automotive Repair
“They do great work, and they actually work, not a bunch of lazy gabby guys.”
Best Transmission Repair Shops in Bay Shore, NY
15 mechanics listed · 12 in Bay Shore · 8 open weekends · 13 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc
“Joe and the crew are very nice people and their work is clean and proper.”
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare
“Marc is very professional he recommended putting a now transmission in my high mileage car by checking for any sensor in the engine”
D&G Auto Repair and Services
“Very proud to come to the best workshop on all of Long Island.”
John A Carucci Motors Inc
“I've referred many people to him throughout the years and they to are very satisfied with the service.”
All Island Auto Co
“Very respectfull and helped out a lot also good prices !!!”
Listed for drivers in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 15 shops work on transmissions. What each one says about rebuilds, warranty terms and the brands it handles comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
Of the 15 mechanics we list here, 12 are in Bay Shore itself and 3 come from Smithtown (2, 9 mi) and Deer Park (1, 3 mi). The mechanics on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 922 reviews; 6 have 50 or more reviews and 13 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the mechanics on this page are "price", "honest" and "quality". 8 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the mechanics on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (2), oil changes (2), tires (2) and transmissions (2). 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 6 websites of the mechanics on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1998. 1 offers financing; 3 are family- or locally-owned and 4 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 9 of the mechanics on this page; 6 publish a contact page; 2 list a public email and 4 take bookings online. We count these figures across the mechanics on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the mechanic before you visit.
Do years in business matter for transmission work?
Ten or more years in business is claimed by 8 of the 15 shops here. Rebuild quality is hands-on skill, and a shop that has been in one place a long time is easier to hold to a warranty. It is what their listings state, not a guarantee.
Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.
“It's hard to find a mechanic you can trust, but these guys are great.”
F B Transmissions
“Freddy was very knowledgable and helpful in guiding me to what I needed to accomplish my goals with this project.”
Rev's Auto Services
“No overcharging, have used for over 10 years!!”
Gomez Auto Repair
“Always grateful for your attention and services.”
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc
“Not only we're they so quick, they were nice and it was at little cost as well!”
I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC
“Great service , mechanic roy is the best”
Royal Bodies & Repair
“Herman is a great guy that can fix anything .”
Smithtown Auto Works
“Howard provided excellent service on my vehicle as always.”
Rob's Auto Service LTD
“I have dealt with many shops over the years and can't say I have ever found one that I trust as much to do the job right than Rob's.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
