View Profile
Brightside Automotive Repair
- Prices
- Job
- Donuts
“No run around, up sells or bs, they made space to look at my car immediately, they showed me the rock removed it checked out the rest of the car and sent me on my way.”
Best Transmission Repair Shops in Bay Shore, NY
24 mechanics listed · 12 in Bay Shore · 11 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Great Neck Auto Tech
- Price
- Tire
- Dealership
“The first time they saved me thousands from a "Dealership diagnostic" to a simple repair on a Mercedes and just recently saved me again with their superior diagnostics on my BMW.”
View Profile
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc
- Inspection
- Team
- Work
“..my car had a laundry list of things wrong and the guys tended to them as they found them kept me up to date every step of the process and give fair pricing can't recommend them enough definitely my go to mechanic from this point forward”
View Profile
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare
- Price
- Rental
- Truck
“I brought my 2003 Honda minivan in thinking the transmission needed to be rebuilt but Mark was so honest telling me all it needed was an electronic sensor component.”
View Profile
D&G Auto Repair and Services
- Prices
- Honest
- Quality
“Highly recommend this shop if you're looking for quality work for a great price, they put in a new transmission & clutch on my car and it's feels brand new again.”
View Profile
John A Carucci Motors Inc
- Prices
- Job
- Ownership
“Been using John for years - he and Michael are great along with Oscar the mechanic - but, I guess they have decided it's time to relax - now we have Ricky who we already like - very nice guy good pricing and great work.”
Listed for drivers in and around Bay Shore, NY, these 24 shops work on transmissions. What each one says about rebuilds, warranty terms and the brands it handles comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
Of the 24 mechanics we list here, 12 are in Bay Shore itself and 12 come from towns including Smithtown (2, 9 mi), Deer Park (1, 3 mi) and Lindenhurst (1, 7 mi). The mechanics on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 2,526 reviews; 13 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these mechanics on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), quality (85%) and value (68%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the mechanics on this page are "honest", "fair" and "communication". 11 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the mechanics on this page list most often on their websites are oil change (5), brake repair (3), brakes (3), transmissions (3) and fleet services (2). 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 8 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 11 websites of the mechanics on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1998. 4 offer financing; 1 gives free estimates; 6 are family- or locally-owned and 7 list coupons or special offers. We count these figures across the mechanics on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the mechanic before you visit.
Do years in business matter for transmission work?
Ten or more years in business is claimed by 16 of the 24 shops here. Rebuild quality is hands-on skill, and a shop that has been in one place a long time is easier to hold to a warranty. It is what their listings state, not a guarantee.
View Profile
Pro Tech Benz
- Mechanic
- Job
- Price
“Through the years I've gone to them many times for service and each time I brought my car to them they were not only detail oriented with the repair but also extremely comprehensive and fitted my vehicle with only genuine Mercedes Benz parts.”
View Profile
All Island Auto Co
“If you want the job done right definitely bring your vehicle over to All Island Auto.”
View Profile
Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.
- Prices
“They gave me a phone call to let me know what the problem is and how much it was going to cost to repair it and the time that it would be ready.”
View Profile
L & D Services Station Inc
“It's very busy, the best part is they are honest not a lot of places like this left, I should be selfish and tell people to go elsewhere so the wait isn't so long but I can't they are to nice”
View Profile
F B Transmissions
- Price
“I've had 5 transmissions in my car and got tired of them blowing up, so I finally got Freddy's 4stb after a recommendation from a friend that races and now I can try to blow up other things on the car and not worry about the trans!”
View Profile
Rev's Auto Services
- Vehicle
- Money
“They will explain things over the phone, usually take the cars when requested (unless they're very busy which is always a good sign anyway), works with our time requests, fair price for repairs, Paul has worked with us many times with costs and time,...”
View Profile
Gomez Auto Repair
“Very pleasant service,,, nice place to fix your car and at the same time eat and drink something as you wait 😊 …”
View Profile
Extreme Tire Car Care Inc
- Flat Tire
“My bridal party and I were on our way to the Hamptons for my Bachelorette weekend and we got a flat tire, total vibe kill !!”
View Profile
I&M Auto Repair & Tire INC
“Great service , mechanic roy is the best”
View Profile
Royal Bodies & Repair
“Best place around for Coffee Truck & Food Truck parts, service, and sales!”
View Profile
Road Ready
- Inspection
- Report
- Used Car
“I had a very pleasant experience at Road Ready today I was having some problems with my tires and being a typical damsel in distress I thought it was in my best interest to have it checked , John and Frank were more than ready and willing to help me ...”
View Profile
Smithtown Auto Works
- Honest
- Mechanic
- Team
“Great place to service any problems with your car they don't make you wait long time and customer service is great soon I walk in they take care of me you should check out this place while you have any service towards your car!”
View Profile
Sunrise Tire & Auto Repair
- Honest
- Team
- Manager
“Scott and John the mechanic are terrific, Scott listen to my concerns and told me what had to be done and John preformed the work on my car perfectly.”
View Profile
Rob's Auto Service LTD
- Prices
- Vehicle
- Upsell
“At first, I was suspicious due to my past experiences with several other auto mechanics in the area; however, my suspicious emtions were gone when he told me in detail why I need to do the things to my car to make it last as long as possible.”
View Profile
US-1 Auto Repair
- Price
- Truck
- Work
“I had a timing chain done on my 2010 Camaro, they had it done in no time and the price was fair for the work done, also the person who worked on it car took cert good care of it, better than another shop I went to.”
View Profile
Transmission Technicians
- Job
- Work
- Review
“Was told it would be several days to complete the work (including new drive shaft U joints and real main seal which I requested to be done), but Dennis called me the next day and said it I could pick it up the next day.”
View Profile
Village Automotive Center
“Rich diagnosed the problem but rather than just giving us an estimate for doing the work (which was very substantial) he suggested we contact the manufacturer rep to have them fix it since it was just beyond the warranty and shouldn't have happened.”
View Profile
RAF Rides
“I can't express my gratitude for the workers at this place I had a situation a few weeks ago I ran over a orange cone which ruin my R reverse gear so I thought I drove it Honda 4,000 they wanted to charge me my insurance sent me to higbie collision w...”
Transmission Repair Services in Bay Shore, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$800
Maximum cost
$3500
National Average
$1400
Avg Per Hour Rates
$128
$1100
$2800
Fair price range is based on 386 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
