Best Collision Repair in Ithaca, NY

The highest-rated Accident Damage Repair companies out of 178 vetted & reviewed in the Ithaca area.

Wink's Body Shop

Wink's Body Shop

(43)
“Winks took care of everything, scheduled a repair date, which was spot on, kept us informed daily of work progress and got our car back to us exactly when promised.”
Family Business
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1994
Accepts Insurance
724 W Court St, Ithaca, NY
i
Guidi's Collision Services Inc

Guidi's Collision Services Inc

(32)
  • Communication
  • Work
  • Price
“Does very good work, much better than the Maguire body shop, excellent customer service”
In Business Since 1993
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Phoenix Auto

Phoenix Auto

(32)
“I woke up today to two slashed tires called the shop and cant get new ones till Monday so to help me out the garage put two used tires on for me until the new ones come in and did it right away and didn't ask for athing its nice to know that ther are...”
In Business Since 2012
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Petrella Brothers Auto Body

Petrella Brothers Auto Body

(15)
  • Door
  • Vehicle
“I was able to call and check in frequently for updates, get information for my insurance company, and Matt even communicated with my insurance for me for the most part.”
In Business Since 2009
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Cj's Kustom Auto

Cj's Kustom Auto

(9)
Services, Rental Request, Service Quote Request
“Kevin was quick on fixing our alternator!”
In Business Since 2024
Serving Ithaca Area
i
One Thirty Nine Auto

One Thirty Nine Auto

(28)
“Services Carburetor cleaning, Tires, Auto exhaust system repair, General repairs & maintenance, Auto brake repair, Tire rotations, Engine repair, Vehicle Inspection, Brakes, Vehicle safety inspection, Auto maintenance, Auto brake replacement, Oil cha...”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Epiq Auto

Epiq Auto

(11)
  • Team
  • Oil
“No it's never fun to have to get body work, but it was a pleasant discovery to come here where Nathan and Logan are quick to help and offer a very professional service.”
In Business Since 2018
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Tierno Automotive LLC

Tierno Automotive LLC

(13)
  • Prices
  • Fair
  • Mechanic
“I have use John many times over the years nothing but a great professional he does great work at a fair price for the customer and for himself thanks a lot John for all your help!”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Brent's Service

Brent's Service

(10)
“Someone you can trust without a doubt!”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Valley Automotive Repair

Valley Automotive Repair

(7)
“Great guy very knowledgeable reasonable on repairs tries to get you right in in emergencies more than willing to help”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Country Automotive

Country Automotive

(1)
“They do good work without having to wonder if the work done was because of a sales quote, like in bigger shops.”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Oshea Collision Center

Oshea Collision Center

(50)
Auto Glass Replacementlearn More, Fleet Body Repairlearn More, Body Damage Serviceslearn More
“He is friendly, competent, and went the extra mile by assuring quality parts were used, he took total charge of communicating with the insurance company and even arranged to have the pin striping done which exactly matched what was there before.”
In Business Since 2020
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Diamond Collision

Diamond Collision

(47)
“The girls in the office always go above and beyond with helping dealing with insurance companies and helping schedule around when to get your vehicle fixed.”
In Business Since 2005
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Leon's Body Shop

Leon's Body Shop

(34)
  • Deer
“Great work”
In Business Since 2009
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Nick's Automobile Repair

Nick's Automobile Repair

(48)
  • Quality
  • Mechanic
  • Prices
“They are friendly and so nice and will also let you know right away if there is a problem with your vehicle never had a problem communicating with them ever”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Joe Yaman's Automotive

Joe Yaman's Automotive

(48)
  • Prices
“Needed car inspection for my car(realized it was late) made appointment for me same day I called dropped car off and they had it done by the time I needed it back”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Mi High Teck Auto Repairs Inc.

Mi High Teck Auto Repairs Inc.

(27)
  • Mechanic
“Benny is the best mechanic that I have come across, he diagnoses the problem explains it to you, You always have a choice and he's reasonable with his rates....”
In Business Since 2014
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Crc-Campbells Repair and Collision

Crc-Campbells Repair and Collision

(27)
  • Price
  • Work
  • Vehicle
“While on a road trip to do maintenance on family property, loaded with various landscaping equipment and other tooling, the exhaust system on our 2008 Toyota "Taco-Ma" ,protested in the loudest of terms.”
In Business Since 2019
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Discount Auto Repair

Discount Auto Repair

(46)
“Well I broke my exhaust today in vestal and luckily I was right across from discount auto bc they fixed my car and did a good job and had great service and were fast Services General repairs & maintenance”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Joe V's Auto & Diesel Repair

Joe V's Auto & Diesel Repair

(45)
“I'm taking my car there for troubleshooting and other things and they are good at what they do and I do not have to worry about the quality of service there I would not question it then recommend this garage to anybody excellent service.”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Gils Auto Sales

Gils Auto Sales

(44)
  • Respect
  • Prices
  • School
“Not the BEST with customer service they're kind of old school kind of gruff and can be kind of short and to the point with you which makes you think they are being rude but generally they're good people.”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Terenzi's Auto Body Shop

Terenzi's Auto Body Shop

(19)
  • Job
  • Price
“Was referred by EPD here for body work very happy with the car an how fast it was done Positive Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Painting, Body & Trim”
In Business Since 2016
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Pine Ridge Tire and Automotive

Pine Ridge Tire and Automotive

(42)
  • Christmas Eve
  • Team
  • Tires
“Spent a lot of time with me on the phone even though he knew it was going to be a one time deal as it was for an inspection of a vehicle that I was going to purchase as I'm in another state.”
Serving Ithaca Area
i
Quality Repair Service

Quality Repair Service

(13)
Lawn Mower Repair, Lawn Mower Sharpening
“Just a note, he only takes cash.”
In Business Since 2000
Accepts Check
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Ithaca Area
i

Collision Services in Ithaca, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$400
Maximum cost
$6500
National Average
$1790
Avg Per Hour Rates
$128
$1500
$2500
Fair price range is based on 399 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $1790
Minimum cost $400
Maximum cost $6500
Avg Per Hour Rates $128

Fair range $1500 to $2500 is based on 399 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top