Best Auto Repair in Ithaca, NY

15 professionals listed · 6 in Ithaca · all 15 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 16, 2026

Ithaca Auto Service

Ithaca Auto Service

4.8 65 reviews
“We've been taking our three cars to him for a couple years now, and we've always been pleased with the work.”
Coupons & offersBBB A+Since 2016
618 Elmira Rd
i
Ithaca Foreign Car Service

Ithaca Foreign Car Service

4.9 50 reviews
“I was expecting an expensive payment for the service but I did not.”
Since 1974BBB A+
501 W State St #13
i
Patterson Service Station

Patterson Service Station

4.6 73 reviews
“I've gone several times, at first because they were conveniently located for me, and then also because they seem to do good work.”
Since 1947BBB A+
221 N Aurora St
i
Taber Street Auto Repair

Taber Street Auto Repair

4.6 72 reviews
“I got a flat when I was driving nearby and they happily swapped the flat tire for the spare winter tire in my trunk by the end of the day.”
Since 1988
229 Cherry St
i
Kuntry Kustom Repair & Fabrication

Kuntry Kustom Repair & Fabrication

4.9 26 reviews
“They stopped what they were doing to help me right away, patched my tire quickly, and made sure it was safe for me to continue my drive.”
6-mo warrantyJeep specialistFamily-ownedSince 2021
644 Enfield Falls Rd
i
Phelps Wholesale Auto & Repair

Phelps Wholesale Auto & Repair

4.8 18 reviews
“They're clearly very loyal to their customers and recently went to great lengths to help us out of a difficult situation with an urgent repair.”
13 Waterwagon Rd
i

Listed for drivers in and around Ithaca, NY, these 15 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Ithaca, NY

Of the 15 professionals we list here, 6 are in Ithaca itself and 9 come from towns including Newfield (4, 7 mi), Lansing (2, 8 mi) and Freeville (2, 9 mi). The professionals on this page are rated from 4.6 to 5.0 across 1,012 reviews; 8 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "price" and "fair". 5 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 6 websites of the professionals on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 1 gives free estimates; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 1 lists coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 9 of the professionals on this page; 9 publish a contact page and 5 list a public email. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.

How long have the listed shops been open?

9 of the 15 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.

Scottie's Auto Repair

Scottie's Auto Repair

4.6 66 reviews
“They are incredibly good at fitting you in last minute if needed, and have always been great at communicating.”
BBB A+Since 1996Family-owned
Freeville, NY · 9 mi from Ithaca
i
Guidi's Collision Services Inc

Guidi's Collision Services Inc

4.7 46 reviews
“Josh does a great job and it's all fairly priced (unlike some other shops in the area..”
Since 1991
Newfield, NY · 7 mi from Ithaca
i
Munson Tires and Auto

Munson Tires and Auto

4.9 60 reviews
“The guys are competent, and the work gets done efficiently and quickly.”
Free estimatesSince 2013
Lansing, NY · 8 mi from Ithaca
i
Doo A Little Repair

Doo A Little Repair

4.9 51 reviews
“Bob And His Staff Are Very Capable And Get The Job Done Right The First Time At Very Affordable Prices.”
Newfield, NY · 7 mi from Ithaca
i
Willow Tree Auto Repair

Willow Tree Auto Repair

4.7 22 reviews
“Andy always takes care of his customers with great service and affordable rates”
BBB A+Since 1997
Lansing, NY · 8 mi from Ithaca
i
Hunt's Auto Service

Hunt's Auto Service

4.9 22 reviews
“They got me in and out in a couple days, just before a road trip, when every other place wanted to schedule me for a few weeks out”
Since 1968Family-owned
Slaterville Springs, NY · 7 mi from Ithaca
i
Brent's Service

Brent's Service

5.0 10 reviews
“There is no more caring and qualified mechanic or technician any where in the Southern Tier of New York state.”
Freeville, NY · 9 mi from Ithaca
i
Humphrey Repair

Humphrey Repair

5.0 5 reviews
“I had been told I needed to have my thermostat replaced, so I had him check to see if that was true, and then arranged to have him replace it.”
Newfield, NY · 7 mi from Ithaca
i
Merriman's Auto

Merriman's Auto

Newfield, NY · 7 mi from Ithaca
i
HomeAuto Repair ShopsNew YorkIthaca, NY

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo shop pays us anything. Nobody can buy a place, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedPermanently closed shops, call centers posing as local garages and duplicate chain branches stay off our list.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, ASE certification and years in business come from each shop's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: hours, phone, website and reviews.

For Auto Repair Shops we compared 617 shops in and around Ithaca. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then shops in Ithaca, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top