View Profile
Finger Lakes Automotive
- Truck
- Wheels
- Camper
“I've purchased 16 ply camper tires, car/ truck tires and wheels, lift kit, and other accessories from him throughout the years and I wouldn't go anywhere else!”
Best Tire Shops near Ithaca, NY
2 of these experts are based in Ithaca; the others serve Ithaca from towns including Cortland (19 mi), Moravia (20 mi) and Horseheads (26 mi).
6 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Bridgestone
“The best place around!”
View Profile
Bell's Auto Care
- Tire
- Prices
- Inspection
“Recently, because I live further away now, I took my car to the dealership that is only 5 minutes from my house because there was a rattle beneath and it was a little loud.”
View Profile
Munson Tires and Auto
- Prices
- Owner
“Complete transparency which I really appreciate (especially after going to Maguire for the last decade 💀) Plus cute furry friends to keep you company if you decide to wait there!”
View Profile
Team Tiremasters
“I had flat tire on a heavy loaded 53' semi trailer.”
View Profile
Tallmadge Tire and Auto Service
“I stopped in Tallmadge and explained the problem and all the technicians were busy with scheduled appointments and I had a meeting in Ithaca in less than an hour.”
Listed for drivers in and around Ithaca, NY, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Ithaca, NY
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 2,063 reviews; 16 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price", "fair" and "quality". 6 are open on Saturdays. 4 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 13 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 81 years. 5 offer financing; 6 are family- or locally-owned and 12 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 16 of the experts on this page; 16 publish a contact page; 13 list a public email and 3 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Why are some shops here not in Ithaca?
2 of the 24 shops sit in Ithaca itself; the rest come from other towns within 45 mi. The drive is sometimes the point, because stores stock what sells locally and an odd size may only be on a shelf one town over. Distances are straight-line.
View Profile
Young's Tires
“Very helpful”
View Profile
GLF Performance LLC
“Amazing garage with extremely fair prices, they helped me in a very tough time and i would recommend them to the moon and back, if you need something done right, go with Paul Bennett's Garage you wont regret it, to the staff THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK...”
View Profile
O'Shea Tire & Service Center
“I feel right in saying : you won't have a better experience anywhere in this area and you'll drive away knowing the work is done right ,you are alerted to any future potential problems .”
View Profile
Tim Voorhees Auto Repair Shop
- Dog
- Prices
- Questions
“Have been going too tim for idk how long some times with minor repairs others well not so minor but tim has always been honest and fair oh his shop dog is def worth going for.”
View Profile
Buckley's Automotive
- Vehicle
- Price
- Engine
“I just had "Shannon" replace struts and an alternator on my mothers vehicle and I received the same good service and great prices that I've been used to over the years.”
View Profile
After Hours Tires
“Dont ever tell the Endicott police you need your car towed they automatically call this company which in turn charges you an additional 250 for a police call.”
View Profile
Crc-Campbells Repair and Collision
- Work
- Price
- Vehicle
“This is a tough and specialized job that not many places in the area were willing to take on, or if they were willing the prices were completely unreasonable.”
View Profile
Pine Ridge Tire and Automotive
- Pricing
- Tires
- Team
“Spent a lot of time with me on the phone even though he knew it was going to be a one time deal as it was for an inspection of a vehicle that I was going to purchase as I'm in another state.”
View Profile
Trucks-n-Stuff
“Got me in and out fast and didn't charge over the moon for anything they didn't do.”
View Profile
Escher's Tire & Services Center
“Not to mention I drop the car off and expect a two to three day wait but they call me the day I dropped it off and its always done faster than I expected.”
View Profile
Sherman Wholesale Tire
- Prices
“Can't beat the price and a good person to deal with”
View Profile
Shively Tire and Auto
- Price
“Stayed in the shop way after hours and did what he could do.”
View Profile
Seneca Lake Tire Automotive
“Had a good experience”
View Profile
Avery Auto Service Inc
“These mechanics are exceptional professionals, I can tell by their level of precision with the little things such as very clean fluids (flushes) and even aligning the value stems on the tires.”
View Profile
Nolt's Tire Service
“My wife broke down I was lucky enough to choose Nolt's tire the customer service was great fast friendly and great prices you don't find many places like this anymore plus they fixed another problem I had in no time at all.”
View Profile
Kapral Tire and Auto LLC
“I always take my vehicles to Kaprals, good down to earth honest people, fair prices and no sales hassles got an oil change full synthetic, and an inspection for $95, Valvoline tried to tell me $120 just for an oil change.”
View Profile
Rolling Tire Shop
“They know what their are doing and they get it done fast some other place u have to wait for weeks to get your car back not here a day or two and your car is done”
View Profile
Fulmer Brothers Tire
- Prices
- Inspection
“Not only car care but tires and wheels at fair prices and Ryan has a full gun shop in the same building with guns, ammo and shooting supplies always at fair prices.”
Tire Repair Services in Ithaca, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$15
Maximum cost
$50
National Average
$25
$20
$40
Typical price range is based on 437 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
What customers say about experts near Ithaca
- “They were knowledgeable and got the new tires on in a timely manner and were extremely nice.” — customer of Kapral Tire and Auto LLC
- “These guys are great to work with! They worked me right into their schedule and gave me a loaner car while mounting new tires on my car!” — customer of Pine Ridge Tire and Automotive
- “New tires were reasonably priced as was a pre-trip oil change and inspection.” — customer of Rolling Tire Shop
Excerpts from public reviews of the experts listed on this page.
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
