Best Mechanic Shops near Ithaca, NY

We have 2 technicians in Ithaca on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: one of them made it, along with 9 from towns including Cortland (3, 18 mi), Freeville (1, 9 mi) and Newfield (1, 9 mi).

3 open weekends · 9 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Taber Street Auto Repair

Taber Street Auto Repair

4.6 72 reviews
“Although there was a glitch with the initial repair due to what turned out to be a defective part, they got it resolved immediately.”
Since 1988
229 Cherry St
i
Bell's Auto Care

Bell's Auto Care

4.6 32 reviews
“They always do great (at both locations), and never try to sell me on something I don't need, which is a struggle I've encountered before.”
Coupons & offersFree consultationBBB A+Since 1989Family-owned
Dryden, NY · 11 mi from Ithaca
i
Scottie's Auto Repair

Scottie's Auto Repair

4.6 66 reviews
“They've always been consistent with their work, polite and reasonable when it comes to pricing.”
BBB A+Since 1996Family-owned
Freeville, NY · 9 mi from Ithaca
i
Tierno Automotive LLC

Tierno Automotive LLC

4.7 20 reviews
“He's been able to diagnose and fix issues that dealerships couldn't and has saved me time and money.”
Cortland, NY · 18 mi from Ithaca
i
Country Automotive

Country Automotive

4.3 2 reviews
“They do good work without having to wonder if the work done was because of a sales quote, like in bigger shops.”
Trumansburg, NY · 11 mi from Ithaca
i
Merriman's Auto

Merriman's Auto

Newfield, NY · 9 mi from Ithaca
i

Listed for drivers in and around Ithaca, NY, these 10 shops are general mechanics. What each one states about certifications, warranties and financing comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Ithaca, NY

The 10 technicians on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 732 reviews; 5 have 50 or more reviews and 9 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "price", "fair" and "honest". 3 are open on Saturdays. 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 5 websites of the technicians on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1997. 1 offers financing; 1 gives free estimates; 4 are family- or locally-owned and 2 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 5 of the technicians on this page; 5 publish a contact page and 4 list a public email. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

Which shops listed for Ithaca work on Saturdays or Sundays?

3 of the 10 shops list weekend hours. Saturday is usually a shorter day; Sunday openings are rarer and often by appointment.

Heyn's Automotive Service

Heyn's Automotive Service

5.0 1 review
“He is someone you can trust.”
Groton, NY · 12 mi from Ithaca
i
O'Shea Tire & Service Center

O'Shea Tire & Service Center

4.7 84 reviews
“O'Shea tire and service center saved the day and got us back on our trip very quickly after AAA towed our vehicle to their shop.”
Coupons & offersSince 1945Family-owned
Cortland, NY · 18 mi from Ithaca
i
Main Street Auto Repair

Main Street Auto Repair

4.9 35 reviews
“I Can't tell you how amazed I am at the service and kindness I experienced!”
Since 2012Family-ownedFinancing
Cortland, NY · 18 mi from Ithaca
i
Rodman's Service Center

Rodman's Service Center

5.0 10 reviews
“Very professional, honest, and reliable shop.”
BBB A+Since 1984
Van Etten, NY · 17 mi from Ithaca
i
HomeMechanic ShopsNew YorkIthaca, NY

Why these companies made our list

What customers say about technicians near Ithaca

  • “They did a huge repair on my engine and took time to explain everything to me at every stage, from diagnosis, estimate, to pick up.” — customer of Taber Street Auto Repair
  • “Honest and reliable small shop. The owner, Mark Bell even took the time to show me what was wrong with my brake calipers and brake hoses.” — customer of Bell's Auto Care
  • “Quick service, friendly staff and great prices. Detailed inspection with my oil change including pictures.” — customer of O'Shea Tire & Service Center
  • “They have some of the most experienced and talented mechanics I have had the pleasure to work with.” — customer of Scottie's Auto Repair
  • “Put in a new battery for me when I brought in my car that wouldn't take a jump and it was reasonably priced.” — customer of Taber Street Auto Repair

Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top