Dunn Tire
“Danny and his crew got my in on an emergency basis and got me out on the road in a hour!”
Best Auto Repair in Amherst, NY
15 professionals listed · 5 in Amherst · 5 open weekends · 12 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 16, 2026
Amherst Car Care Center
“Thought my headlight would be a big problem: fast, good price i get all my service there 😀 …”
Gerry's Service-Complete Auto Repair
“Gerry's thought they had one on hand; turned out not right but they called and found the right one and fixed it the same day.”
Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care
“I was so pleased at how kind and efficient this establishment was in the repair of my vehicle.”
Amherst Automotive LLC
“Will be going to them for whatever I need from now on.”
Mike Barney Nissan Service
“But to get the repair covered, the dealership went the extra mile and called Nissan to get the repair covered.”
Listed for drivers in and around Amherst, NY, these 15 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Amherst, NY
Of the 15 professionals we list here, 5 are in Amherst itself and 10 come from towns including East Amherst (4, 4 mi), Tonawanda (2, 5 mi) and Kenmore (1, 7 mi). The professionals on this page are rated from 3.8 to 5.0 across 3,736 reviews; 13 have 50 or more reviews and 12 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these professionals on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (96%), value (89%) and punctuality (79%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "fair", "honest" and "quality". 5 are open on Saturdays. 3 list staff certifications (ASE) and 9 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 13 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 89 years. 7 offer financing; 1 gives free estimates; 3 are family- or locally-owned and 10 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 14 of the professionals on this page; 11 publish a contact page; 7 list a public email and 6 take bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.
How long have the listed shops been open?
13 of the 15 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.
Steve Lumia's Auto & Truck Rpr
“Steve and his crew are the only people I trust with our vehicles .”
Becker Towing 24hr Towing
“We send all our friends and family to Becker's, couldn't be more satisfied.”
Transit Auto Services Center
“I went to multiple repair shops before finally getting an excellent job performed at Transit Auto.”
Amherst
“They are the best in the area”
Ross Service Station
“I would give them 10 stars if possible they go above and beyond sent my truck on a tow truck died and got it back sounding and driving like new I would send everyone i know there”
WNY One Stop Automotive
“I went for just a oil change and they checked and corrected tire pressure, lube fittings on the steering also.”
S & S Auto Body
“Friendly service and very willing to be sure everything is done to your satisfaction!!”
Amton Auto & Truck
“Staff is excellent and quick to follow-up on any questions or concerns you may have.”
Walt's Garage
“Ray and Len are wonderful and I will only be using Walt's garage for my vehicle maintenance/repairs.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
More Auto Repair in New York
Popular in Amherst
, NYGuides: Auto Repair
Brake Pad Replacement Cost: Do You Really Need Rotors?
Can a Mechanic Charge More Than the Estimate? State Rules
Can I Bring My Own Parts to a Mechanic? What It Saves
Car Diagnostic Test Cost 2026: What the Fee Really Buys
Do Mechanics Have to Warranty Their Work? (2026)
Does a Different Mechanic Void Your Car Warranty? (2026)