Best Muffler & Exhaust Shops near Amherst, NY

We have 3 technicians in Amherst on file. Only the highest-rated make our list: 2 of them made it, along with 13 from towns including Buffalo (6, 9 mi), North Tonawanda (2, 6 mi) and Cheektowaga (2, 7 mi).

5 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Dunn Tire & Auto

Dunn Tire & Auto

4.5 104 reviews
“Brought in loose set of wheels for my BMW and they got them done quick and kept me updated!”
Coupons & offersASE-certified techsFinancing availableSince 1973BBB accreditedPrices online
3424 Sheridan Dr
i
Amherst Car Care Center

Amherst Car Care Center

4.6 71 reviews
“In the auto repair industry I challenge you to find these two virtues in the shop's owner.”
Coupons & offersWalk-ins welcome30+ yearsFree consultation
3955 Harlem Rd
i
Steve Lumia's Auto & Truck Rpr

Steve Lumia's Auto & Truck Rpr

4.9 56 reviews
“Quality work, reasonable pricing and the work is always finished on time.”
Since 1988
East Amherst, NY · 6 mi from Amherst
i
Fox Tire

Fox Tire

4.5 107 reviews
“Very professional and quick service at a great price.”
24-mo/24k-mi warranty24/7 towingFinancing availableBBB A+Since 1954
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Bison Automotive & Detail Inc.

Bison Automotive & Detail Inc.

4.8 125 reviews
“Everyone was very courteous, from receptionist to Charlie, who was very thorough in explaining the details and recommendations.”
24-mo/24k-mi warrantyASE-certified techsNew York inspection stationFleet accountsSince 1992Family-owned
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Sweeney's Garage

Sweeney's Garage

4.8 83 reviews
“Phil quickly identified the issue, offered options for resolution, and was able to perform the service all within a few hours.”
Fleet accountsSince 1948BBB A+
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i

Listed for drivers in and around Amherst, NY, these 15 shops handle mufflers, pipes and catalytic converters. What each one says about welding, custom work and warranties comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Amherst, NY

The 15 technicians on this page are rated from 4.4 to 4.9 across 8,982 reviews; all 15 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "price", "fair" and "quality". 5 are open on Saturdays. 5 list staff certifications (ASE) and 7 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 13 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 75 years. 4 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 3 are family- or locally-owned and 6 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 13 of the technicians on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 5 list a public email and 4 take bookings online. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

Why are some of these shops outside Amherst?

2 of the 15 shops sit in Amherst and the others come from other towns within 10 mi. A shop with a bender and a welder is worth a short drive, since it can repair what a parts-only counter would replace.

Ultimate Auto Service

Ultimate Auto Service

4.9 76 reviews
“My car had a bad ignition coil, he fixed it a few hours after I called, and I picked it up same day, running good as new.”
10% offASE-certified techsSince 1988Locally owned
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Greg Kerl Automotive

Greg Kerl Automotive

4.7 60 reviews
“Greg kerl and his employees are amazing at what they do super nice always a good job”
Free estimatesASE certifiedSince 2008
Cheektowaga, NY · 7 mi from Amherst
i
EZ Tire & Auto

EZ Tire & Auto

4.8 123 reviews
“They were very accommodating, did an excellent job replacing our timing chain and for much less than other shops had quoted.”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 2008Financing
North Tonawanda, NY · 6 mi from Amherst
i
Black Forest Motorsport

Black Forest Motorsport

4.5 67 reviews
“I trust them with my car and feel very comfortable having them perform any type of work, knowing it will be performed correctly.”
European automobile models specialistBBB A+Since 2012
Cheektowaga, NY · 7 mi from Amherst
i
Carfix Auto Repair & Service

Carfix Auto Repair & Service

4.8 134 reviews
“Very friendly service, waiting area is clean and comfortable, great price for an oil change.”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 2018Family-owned
North Tonawanda, NY · 6 mi from Amherst
i
Towne Motor Car

Towne Motor Car

4.6 64 reviews
“These guys went the extra mile to help me out.”
BBB ASince 1986
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Hillman Automotive and Tire

Hillman Automotive and Tire

4.5 92 reviews
“I've sent other folks here, and they were impressed with the professionalism and courtesy.”
Since 2011Financing
Lockport, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Jay Bee's

Jay Bee's

4.4 55 reviews
“Friendly and quick, still have good hours during COVID, which is a lifesaver.”
BBB A+Since 2000
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Mufflerman

Mufflerman

4.8 123 reviews
“Not only was the estimate quick and more than reasonable, the service was beyond exceptional.”
Free estimatesWalk-ins welcomeSince 1975
Kenmore, NY · 6 mi from Amherst
i
HomeMuffler ShopsNew YorkAmherst, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top