Best Collision Repair in Brookhaven, NY

The highest-rated Accident Damage Repair companies out of 158 vetted & reviewed in the Brookhaven area.

Newton Collision Repair

Newton Collision Repair

(17)
  • Business
  • Job
  • Insurance
“Brought the car in Thursday, and while I waited for Richie to get back from an errand, Lori (introduced to me as “my right hand” by Richie) took all the pictures, filled out all the forms and sent them up to the insurance company in Massachusetts....”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1987
I-CAR Certified
1170 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood, NY
i
Sals Auto Body

Sals Auto Body

(19)
  • Pleasure
  • Office
  • Brand
“More details on Yelp, but had an amazing experience throughout the process, customer service with respect to handling insurance and rental car, and was completely satisfied.”
In Business Since 1983
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Royal Collision Corp

Royal Collision Corp

(14)
24h Towing, Suspension Repairs, Dent Repairs
“With limited parts available for my 87 buick century which my wife rear ended a lexus suv in they still made it look better then it was before and the car looked new when i got it.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1992
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
G & B Collision (Port Jefferson Collision Center Inc.)

G & B Collision (Port Jefferson Collision Center Inc.)

(20)
  • Job
  • Prices
“They were awesome very friendly and helpful Steve and Andy were very knowledgeable about what was needed to be done on our car and didn't try and to over charge us”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 2002
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Precision Collision

Precision Collision

(20)
  • Cleaned
  • Back
  • Rental
“The car looks amazing, looks brand new.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1989
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Perfect Bodies Auto-Body Inc

Perfect Bodies Auto-Body Inc

(18)
Paint-Less Dent Removal, Rental Cars, Body Shop
“We were so thrilled with the knowledge, problem-solving, and dedication of Joe and his staff - it was 100% better than working with an RV service tech, and even better that they're local!”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1996
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
A-1 Auto Body Inc

A-1 Auto Body Inc

(20)
Hail Damage, Member of L.i.a.b.r.a., Center For the Full Line of Retro USA Products
“They also were able to get the safety sensors re-calibrated, after installation, an important part of replacing a modern windshield (it's a cluster of sensors behind the rear view mirror that does stuff like sense impending collision or when the car ...”
Family Business
In Business Since 2014
Free Initial Consultation
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Smithtown Auto Body

Smithtown Auto Body

(18)
  • Brand
  • Pickup
  • Price
“I called them as soon as I was rear ended and they walked me through EVERYTHING step by step including calling my insurance company, setting up my rental car, etc.”
Coupons & Offers
Se Habla Español
In Business Since 1987
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
157 W Main St, Smithtown, NY
i
M & I Autobody Collision

M & I Autobody Collision

(15)
Classic Car Restorations, Paintless Dent Repair, Dent & Ding Repair
“They are professional, consummate, HONEST, and the nicest staff I've ever dealt with at any auto facility I have ever been to (and I have been to many in the past).”
In Business Since 2017
Free Initial Consultation
390 E Main St, Smithtown, NY
i
Tier 1 Collision Center Under NEW Owners

Tier 1 Collision Center Under NEW Owners

(19)
Auto Body & Collision Repair
“When he then took a look at her, popped the bumper back into alignment, wiped the paint scratches from the other car off and gave me a quote for $380, which he proceeded to knock down to $300 right on the spot, I was sold.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2016
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
J & J Auto Body

J & J Auto Body

(19)
“Great work on my 2005 trail blazer , thank you George, also turn around time was only 1 week awesome, would recommend as a great place to get auto body repair”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1988
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Lee's Auto Body & Glass

Lee's Auto Body & Glass

(10)
“Reliable and dependable”
In Business Since 1918
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
76 E Main St F, East Islip, NY
i
Continental Car Care

Continental Car Care

(17)
  • Priced
  • Feel
  • Insurance Company
“Even when the parts that were needed for the repair were delayed by post-Covid unavailability of parts from the manufacturer, they reassured us and allowed us to feel confident in an ultimate happy ending for our car.”
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 1984
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Blue Point Auto Body

Blue Point Auto Body

(11)
Unibody Specialists​, 24 Hour Towing Service, Wheel Alignment
“Last time they even did some extra touch up work on the other side of the car on some scratches that I forgot about while the car was in for a bumper replacement.”
Accepts Cash, Check
In Business Since 1993
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Grobens Auto Body

Grobens Auto Body

(20)
  • Rent a Car
  • Communication
  • Business
“I had the misfortune of being rear-ended and colliding with Bambi in a span of twelve months, and in both cases, Groben's was professional, friendly, timely, and reassuring in an obviously stressful time.”
In Business Since 2015
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Matt's One Stop Service

Matt's One Stop Service

(20)
  • Price
  • Job
“After someone hit my car while It was parked in the street (I was not in it and thank god the nice man who accidentally hit my car was not injured), I knew I wanted to go to Matt's One Stop because they have done excellent work on my car in the past,...”
In Business Since 1980
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Kraken Auto & Collision Inc.

Kraken Auto & Collision Inc.

(16)
  • Insurance
  • Professional
  • Truck
“These guys are all absolutely great, I brought a few panels in for my 01 Cherokee to be fixed and painted they were in bad condition and I couldn't believe my eyes when I seen the work they did and there prices are outstanding, not only that but ever...”
In Business Since 2019
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Nolan's Auto Collision Inc

Nolan's Auto Collision Inc

(20)
  • Owner
  • Professional
  • Insurance
“Joe and Danny went above and beyond to help me, I've never had to any of this I was walking in completely blind not knowing anything I had to do to get my car fixed after I got rear-ended, Joe and Danny help me Through every step, with a rental, deal...”
In Business Since 1933
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
South Shore Auto Collision

South Shore Auto Collision

(19)
  • Reliable
  • Professional
  • Vehicle
“Awesome the best!!!”
In Business Since 1976
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Gus Auto Collision MD

Gus Auto Collision MD

(7)
  • Professional
“The whole experience was stress free from start to finish!!”
Se Habla Español
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 2021
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Michael's Auto Collision

Michael's Auto Collision

(20)
Paintless Dent Repair, Collision Repair, Refinishing
“Honestly my car was totaled so I didnt get work done but the people there were beyond helpful offering boxes to move stuff out of my car, borrowing a screw driver to get the plates off my car and even texting me a picture of registration.”
In Business Since 2014
Family Business
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
County Collision

County Collision

(8)
Paintless Dent Removal, Local Pick-Up & Drop-Off Service, Down Draft Spray Booth
“Took my car in because I could not get the trunk open and Frank who seems to be the owner fixed it without any charge it was just a small problem with the handle sticking.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1987
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
227 Main St, Islip, NY
i
Fair Price Auto Repair

Fair Price Auto Repair

(17)
  • Work
  • Mechanic
  • Prices
“I have a newer car now so it's mainly been just inspections but they do them properly and don't push unnecessary add ons like windshield wipers, brakes etc.”
In Business Since 2016
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Brookhaven Area
i
Ed's Auto Collision

Ed's Auto Collision

(18)
Paintless Dent Removal, Collision Repair, Auto Glass
“Very convenient for me and we do not take our cars anyplace else for body work, always very happy with outcomes and they arranged everything for your rental if needed.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1979
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Brookhaven Area
i

Collision Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$496
Maximum cost
$8056
National Average
$2219
Avg Per Hour Rates
$159
$1859
$3099
Typical price range is based on 401 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $2219
Minimum cost $496
Maximum cost $8056
Avg Per Hour Rates $159

Typical range $1859 to $3099 is based on 401 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top