Best Auto Body Shops near Amherst, NY

We have one technician in Amherst on file, and it is on this list, along with 14 from towns including Buffalo (8, 9 mi), North Tonawanda (1, 5 mi) and Cheektowaga (1, 7 mi).

4 open weekends · 14 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Autostars

Autostars

4.6 34 reviews
“Trish is great to work with and Rich runs an exceptional team.”
BBB A+Since 1983
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Northtown Collision Centre

Northtown Collision Centre

3.6 39 reviews
“If you're lucky enough to get 'assigned' with her, you were blessed.”
Lifetime warrantyFree estimatesBBB A+Since 1972
3840 Sheridan Dr
i
S & S Auto Body

S & S Auto Body

4.8 85 reviews
“Bill and the gang are great, hard working guys who provide honest work for great prices.”
Free estimatesInsurance claim help42+ yearsFamily-ownedBBB A+
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Scratch Busters Autobody Collision and Dents

Scratch Busters Autobody Collision and Dents

4.9 98 reviews
“Glenn promised to do the best he could, with no guarantee what the finished product would look like.”
Coupons & offersFree estimatesWalk-ins welcome50+ yearsBBB accreditedInsurance accepted
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Mongielo's/ Auto Specialties Auto Repair and Parts

Mongielo's/ Auto Specialties Auto Repair and Parts

4.8 74 reviews
“We have always gone to Mongielo's for auto repairs, and today Dave was also able to give me some advice over the phone to help navigate a car situation.”
10% off first serviceFree estimatesBBB A+Since 1992
Lockport, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
S&S Auto Body

S&S Auto Body

4.8 33 reviews
“I was super impressed even with the estimate process, got to see some of their great work in progress looking thru the window of the shop.”
BBB A+Since 2009Family-owned
Clarence Center, NY · 7 mi from Amherst
i

Listed for drivers in and around Amherst, NY, these 15 shops handle bodywork and paint. What each one says about panel work, paint warranties and insurance jobs comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Amherst, NY

The 15 technicians on this page are rated from 3.6 to 5.0 across 2,724 reviews; 14 have 50 or more reviews and 14 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "price", "communication" and "estimates". 4 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. 8 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 11 websites of the technicians on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 1 offers financing; 4 give free estimates; 2 are family- or locally-owned and 3 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 14 of the technicians on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 5 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

Are any of these shops long established?

14 of the 15 shops claim ten or more years of trading. Longevity counts in body work, because paint systems and bonded panels have changed and a shop that stayed open had to keep retraining. It is what their listings state, not a rating.

Allstar Collision and Paint

Allstar Collision and Paint

5.0 63 reviews
“Dave was extremely helpful with contacting the other party's insurance company also setting me in a rental vehicle through Enterprise.”
5% off total billFree estimatesSince 1960
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Decarlo Collision & Auto Painting

Decarlo Collision & Auto Painting

4.7 66 reviews
“Joe and his team were phenomenal with my truck, i had scratched and dented my door while driving and when I got my truck back, it looks like I never even got my truck into a collision.”
BBB A+Since 1966
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
IN Collision & Auto Repair

IN Collision & Auto Repair

4.8 132 reviews
“Great customer service from the time I walked in until the time I left.”
Coupons & offersFree consultationSince 2008
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Auto Collision & Glass

Auto Collision & Glass

4.6 93 reviews
“Dustin went above and beyond to answer all of my questions and make sure I understood what would be happening and the breakdown of pricing”
BBB accreditedSince 1991
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Auto Image Collision

Auto Image Collision

4.9 70 reviews
“I don't usually bother to leave reviews but my experience with AIC has been remarkable.”
Since 2013Locally owned
Buffalo, NY · 9 mi from Amherst
i
Elmwood Collision

Elmwood Collision

4.8 125 reviews
“From start to finish … the office is exceptionally organized and our vehicle was repaired perfectly and in a timely manner”
Free estimatesAll makes and modelsSame-day serviceInsurance claim helpSince 1982
Kenmore, NY · 7 mi from Amherst
i
In and Out Collision

In and Out Collision

4.6 84 reviews
“Immediately he explained everything and said that if he found more that needed to be fixed he would deal with the insurance!”
Insurance claim helpSince 2021
Cheektowaga, NY · 7 mi from Amherst
i
Joe Walter Auto

Joe Walter Auto

4.7 29 reviews
“He made my car look brand new in a reasonable amount of time.”
BBB A+Since 1994
North Tonawanda, NY · 5 mi from Amherst
i
Gerber Collision & Glass

Gerber Collision & Glass

4.7 66 reviews
“At the outset they gave us a completion date for the work that was required and that promise to us was kept even after they received a wrong part shipped to them in error.”
Since 1958Financing
Clarence, NY · 8 mi from Amherst
i
HomeAuto Body RepairsNew YorkAmherst, NY

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top