Best-One
“Trane, Aaron and Steve at the desk and my mechanic, Eric, really went to the nth degree to give a second exam of my problem and found a more economic resolution.”
Best Flat Tire Repair in Indianapolis, IN
24 experts listed · all 24 in Indianapolis · 15 open weekends · 20 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 18, 2026
All Star Tire & Auto Service
“I had been swindled by a roadside mechanic that abandoned the job and the guys at All Star straightened the whole mess up and got me back on the road within 24 hrs of dropping off my car.”
Harris Tire and Auto
“Did a really good job, when I called they were polite they answered all my questions and I was able to get In and out for a bent rim and got a really nice deal on a nice used tire.”
Tire Central AND Service Beech Grove
“Unfortunately, I have experienced a lot of tire mishaps in the past year and have tried different tire shops resulting in tremendous wait times, installing the wrong size tire etc.”
Beck Service Center
“When I told them I was going to hold off on fixes, he sounded concerned for my safety and wanted reassurance I wouldn't be driving it for long without fixing it.”
Edgar's Tire Shop
“I needed 4 tires mounted and balanced on my E46 M3 and called 3 other shops on a Monday afternoon before I remembered somebody had previously told me to call Edgar's.”
Listed for drivers in and around Indianapolis, IN, these 24 shops repair flats and punctures. Hours, emergency service and whether they come to you are taken from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Indianapolis, IN
All 24 experts we list here are in Indianapolis itself. We have 34 experts in Indianapolis on file; this page shows the highest-rated 24. The experts on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 5,700 reviews; 21 have 50 or more reviews and 20 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price" and "fair". 15 are open on Saturdays and 4 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are oil change (3), fleet services (2) and wheel alignment (2). 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 3 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 8 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 3 offer financing; 1 gives free estimates; 5 are family- or locally-owned and 6 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 15 of the experts on this page; 10 publish a contact page; 5 list a public email and 7 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Can I get a puncture fixed on a Sunday?
15 of the 24 shops here show weekend hours, though Saturday is far more common than Sunday. A puncture repair is a short job, so a shop that takes walk-ins will often squeeze one in between booked work. Call rather than drive over on a flat.
My Pit Crew
“Even though I was not able to get my tire replaced onsite (my own fault) they had my tire and I was able to purchase directly from them onsite and deal with it in my own.”
Jet Tire Center
“The building was extra clean and the amazing thing is they even cleaned the rim where the tire goes before checking for a leak after the tire was put on.”
Freeman Tire & Automotive
“This place did a great job on turning our rotors hard to find any one doing this theses days old school shop with excellent work way to go guys 👊 …”
Ramsey Automotives
“I was praying for a miracle I could somehow get it repaired without putting me into an even bigger bind I was already in and to have a running vehicle again.”
A & A Tire and Auto Service
“I have a second car having issues and I've been dreading taking it to a mechanic, but after my experience today I'll gladly bring my 2nd car here to have it looked at.”
J.r.'s New & Used Tires
“Pleasantly Surprised with the my experience, being from out of town I looked High and Low for Same Day service and after a full day I stumbled across this Gem.”
Tire Express LLC
“They have have a used tire price of $35-$45 and I was quoted at $40, however when I paid I was only charged $35 and it was not by accident at all, they simply just helped me out.”
Stewart Tire & Auto
“I've been bringing my cars here for the past 14yrs, I dont know a thing a maintaining my car but Darren and his staff have always explained everything and been so helpful.”
Eastside Tire & Wheel
“It was literally 35 minutes from getting a flat, driving over to this place (we have run flat tires), getting a new tire on, and hitting the road again.”
Direct Tire
“The guy I spoke to on the phone name was Alan and he said yes they had it so let me I tell y'all I am very pleased with the tire and the excellent service.”
Jr Torres Tire Shop
“While driving through the Near Eastside community, I didn't see an extremely large break in the pavement because I had my eyes on another break in the pavement.”
Budget Tire
“Great friendly service and fair prices.”
Rene Tire & Oil Express
“I live far away but was definitely worth coming here for tires, the guys are nice, quick, and did a great job, plus, very nice set if tires and a great price!!”
Central Indiana Tire & Retreading
“As a semi bringing goods I had to use their pallet jack to get the pallets to the end of the trailer for them but it helped being able to park there overnight.”
IMC Tire and Mufflers Service Inc
“They also do tuneups and minor auto repair and they do a very good jobs on exhaust work I have used Imc for the last couple years and have never had any issues!”
Felipe's Tire Shop
“The Manage Christan Felipe is very professional and courteous, Excellent people skills and it delivered exactly what I needed at a better price then the big chain stores.”
Hurt's Services LLC
“I called several companies that said they would meet me to help with my tire, but the founder of HURT'S Services not only followed thru, but had to come from the other side of town thru, road closers, and worked in the pouring down rain.”
Poor Mann's Tire
“Always courteous and honest service”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
