Best Collision Repair near Millcreek, PA

There are no technicians listed in Millcreek itself yet; the 24 below are the closest options, from towns including Erie (19, 3 mi), Waterford (2, 11 mi) and Fairview (1, 8 mi).

1 open 24/7 · 3 open weekends · 20 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 16, 2026

Platinum Auto Body

Platinum Auto Body

(50)
  • Total Loss
  • Vehicle
  • Insurance Company
“They assisted me with navigating through the Insurance claim process, were open and transparent about their repair process, and were always available to answer any questions I had.”
In Business Since 2001
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
I-CAR Certified
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Bates Collision

Bates Collision

(49)
  • Future
  • Vehicle
  • Truck
“They helped us with our insurance claim, and kept us updated every time they had new information about their progress, as well as the insurance company's progress.”
In Business Since 1985
Accepts Insurance
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Bonnell's Collision Center Erie

Bonnell's Collision Center Erie

(33)
“They explained everything in detail and treated me with respect, unlike other auto services who think a woman doesn't know the difference between a two-door and a four-door.”
In Business Since 1988
Accepts Insurance
OEM Certified
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Dick Deutsch Auto Body

Dick Deutsch Auto Body

(31)
  • Work
  • Vehicle
  • Price
“Call Pam, Gary and his team will make your automobile look showroom new or they will fix it until they do, but they always get it right, I know 5 accidents this year, waiting to get in right now!”
In Business Since 1995
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Eagle Auto Service & Collision Center

Eagle Auto Service & Collision Center

(23)
  • Towed
  • Tow Truck
“After hitting a deer he completely calmed us down and assured us everything was going to be okay as we waited along side the highway for a ride home from a friend who was almost there.”
In Business Since 2012
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
BBB Rating: A+
Cranesville, PA · 15 mi from Millcreek
i
Musolf's Auto Service

Musolf's Auto Service

(49)
  • Heart
  • Mechanic
  • Vehicle
“I am away from home right now and was recommended this place and he made sure I understood everything that was going on with my car and explained it all very thoroughly so I could pass it along to my parents.”
In Business Since 1979
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i

Listed for drivers in and around Millcreek, PA, these 24 shops handle collision and accident repair. What each one says about insurer programs, certifications and rentals comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Millcreek, PA

The 24 technicians on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 1,373 reviews; 5 have 50 or more reviews and 20 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these technicians on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (88%), quality (85%) and value (70%). 1 is open around the clock; 3 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. 2 list staff certifications (I-CAR and OEM) and 18 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 6 websites of the technicians on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2000. 1 offers emergency or roadside call-outs; 3 give free estimates and 1 is family- or locally-owned. We have a website on file for 10 of the technicians on this page; 5 publish a contact page; 3 list a public email and 1 takes bookings online. We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

Are there collision shops in Millcreek itself?

Not yet. The 24 shops here are the nearest listed; the largest group is in Erie, roughly 3 mi away. Frame benches and paint booths are expensive, so smaller towns often feed a larger center, and after a crash the car is usually towed anyway.

Laughlin Collision Service and Sales

Laughlin Collision Service and Sales

(20)
  • Work
  • Inspection
“During the repair process, they contacted the rental car company for me and had everything all set up so all I had to do was drop off my car and I had a ride waiting for me to complete the rental car agreement.”
In Business Since 1972
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Kurt's Collision & Auto Body

Kurt's Collision & Auto Body

(10)
“Called the number listed when I got a flat tire driving late through PA; not only did he calm me down through my panic he gave the best instructions via phone on changing my tire out.”
In Business Since 2017
Emergency Services
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Hi-Tech Collision Services

Hi-Tech Collision Services

(10)
“The quality of service is exceptional”
In Business Since 1989
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
D'Amico's Collision & Paint

D'Amico's Collision & Paint

(20)
  • Job
  • Price
“They did a fantastic job on my Lincoln, I would highly recommend them.”
In Business Since 1980
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
BBB Accredited
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Johnson's Car Care & Collision

Johnson's Car Care & Collision

(39)
“Some people were clearly trying to take advantage of the situation, but Gizmo and the guys at Johnsons were the most down to earth, reasonably priced, and honest people I've worked with.”
In Business Since 1979
Accepts All Major Credit Cards, Check, Debit, Insurance, Travelers checks
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Smith Collision Inc

Smith Collision Inc

(15)
  • Job
  • Insurance
  • Vehicle
“As a woman, it has been my experience in the past of consistently being taken advantage of due to my lack of knowledge on cars and car parts, only to discover later that I was both way overcharged and had things “replaced/repaired” that did not requi...”
In Business Since 1995
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Bill Watson's Autobody-Detail

Bill Watson's Autobody-Detail

(25)
  • Insurance
  • Vehicle
“The insurance they had which was Geico was completely awful and he dealt with them the whole time INCLUDING making sure I had a rental to pick up at the shop instead of having to get a ride somewhere to pick up a rental.”
In Business Since 1991
BBB Rating: A+
Fairview, PA · 8 mi from Millcreek
i
J & W Collision Services

J & W Collision Services

(3)
“Did a great job explaining the issue and my options followed by thorough work on the repair --- and finished ahead of schedule!”
In Business Since 1965
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Abbey's Auto Services

Abbey's Auto Services

(13)
  • Vehicle
“Excellent service and much knowledge on any vehicle with quick service, Mike was one of the best mechanics in the field,thanks Randy for allways getting it done”
In Business Since 1987
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Below Average Price Tag
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Import Collision

Import Collision

(12)
“Perfetional service and a great team”
In Business Since 2013
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Unlimited Auto Body

Unlimited Auto Body

(9)
  • Rust
  • Price
“Great work good price”
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
The Autobody Outlet

The Autobody Outlet

(12)
  • Team
  • Ford
  • Vehicle
“I came in for what I thought was a subframe replacement turns out it was a few bent and broken pieces instead, Evan gave me a call as soon as they found out and let me know rather than just getting the money out of me and fixed what really needed to ...”
In Business Since 2021
Free Initial Consultation
Waterford, PA · 11 mi from Millcreek
i
Downtown Motors & Service

Downtown Motors & Service

(5)
  • Prices
“Hayden and Eddis are very good mechanics best in town with very reasonable prices and excellent work and they take good care of your car highly recommend them for getting your vehicle fixed”
In Business Since 2019
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Custom Auto Body

Custom Auto Body

(5)
  • Work
“The insurance company wanted to put used parts on my 2 year old car and they fought for me and got all new parts and even pointed out damage the adjuster missed.”
In Business Since 1980
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Lakeshore Auto & Body

Lakeshore Auto & Body

(25)
  • Inspection
  • Vehicle
  • Fair
“Honest people couldn't ask for a better group of people to look after my car I had my car for 16 years from the time I bought it brand new well always do business with these people”
In Business Since 1989
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Kitcey's Collision-Auto Sales

Kitcey's Collision-Auto Sales

(2)
“Nicest place in town with attention to detail”
In Business Since 1985
BBB Rating: A+
Erie, PA · 3 mi from Millcreek
i
Randy's Auto & Truck Collision

Randy's Auto & Truck Collision

(1)
“He does body work for the MTSD bus garage, we send our accident damage his way and they come out cleaner than they are from the factory.”
In Business Since 1997
BBB Rating: A+
Waterford, PA · 11 mi from Millcreek
i
West Penn Collision

West Penn Collision

(21)
  • Deer
  • Vehicle
  • Job
“West Penn Collision did a great repair job on my car after hitting a deer, they even cleaned the inside and washed and waxed the outside of my car before I picked it up.”
In Business Since 2009
Albion, PA · 18 mi from Millcreek
i
HomeCollision CentersPennsylvaniaMillcreek, PA

Collision Services in Millcreek, PA Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$416
Maximum cost
$6756
National Average
$1861
Avg Per Hour Rates
$134
$1559
$2599
Fair price range is based on 496 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $1861
Minimum cost $416
Maximum cost $6756
Avg Per Hour Rates $134

Fair range $1559 to $2599 is based on 496 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top