Best Collision Repair in Westerville, OH

The highest-rated Accident Damage Repair companies out of 174 vetted & reviewed in the Westerville area.

Kevin's Car Repair & Body Shop LLC

Kevin's Car Repair & Body Shop LLC

(43)
Shocks & Struts, Tire Replacement, Air Conditioning & Heating
“Hands down the best shop in Columbus Ohio I would recommend them to anyone and everyone Positive Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Electrical repair, General repairs & maintenance”
In Business Since 2008
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
5985 Westerville Rd, Westerville, OH
i
Napa Global Collision Center

Napa Global Collision Center

(49)
  • People
  • Happy
  • Insurance Company
“Excellent experience from intake of my damaged vehicle gave a quick evaluation and cost of repair and did fantastic work and repairs upon receiving my vehicle back.”
In Business Since 2020
Free Initial Consultation
3174 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Achbach Auto Industries

Achbach Auto Industries

(49)
  • Rental
  • Attention
  • Questions
“Auchbach owners and staff worked patiently and tirelessly, communicating over and over again to a totally combative and incommunicative insurance agent (who after a MONTH of back and forth, did finally agree to all the fixes because the body shop was...”
In Business Since 1982
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
3476 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville, OH 43081
i
Combs Collision & Body Shops

Combs Collision & Body Shops

(44)
Paintless Dent Repair, Rental Cars, Collision Repair
“I did NOT expect that--they previous work was done correctly and it was just my bad luck that the trim came off when I drove through a huge puddle at high speed on a freeway ramp.”
In Business Since 2022
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
64 Israel St, Westerville, OH 43081
i
Trio Body Shop

Trio Body Shop

(11)
“The only place I trust my car to be fixed!”
In Business Since 1989
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
3190 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Joe's Service Station

Joe's Service Station

(50)
  • Vehicles
  • Oil
  • Mechanic
“This shop and these guys went out of their way to raise the bar though and I'll definitely take my truck back and give them another opportunity to restore my faith”
80 N State St, Westerville, OH
i
Raffys Auto Repair & Body Shop

Raffys Auto Repair & Body Shop

(17)
  • Pay
“They're professional,honest and they return your vehicle in a timely manner!”
In Business Since 2008
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
2919 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Excite Collision Repair Westerville

Excite Collision Repair Westerville

(14)
  • Communication
  • Patient
  • Work
“I delayed getting the repairs addressed due to the fact that I had two separate claims with two different insurance companies; honestly I was intimidated by the prospect of it.”
In Business Since 2023
Licensed, BBB Accredited
5511 Westerville Rd, Westerville, OH
i
Montiel Auto Service

Montiel Auto Service

(9)
“Excellent workshop”
In Business Since 2024
Se Habla Español
3047 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH
i
NJB Automotive

NJB Automotive

(6)
“Contacted to have my 1969 Alfa Romeo Spider renovated.”
In Business Since 2007
10877 R Fancher Rd, Westerville, OH 43082
i
Five Star Body Shop

Five Star Body Shop

(13)
“They are highly professional, talented, timely, and nice.”
In Business Since 2012
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
2782 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Studio 47

Studio 47

(4)
“Great service”
In Business Since 2010
10840 Fancher Rd, Westerville, OH
i
Luke's Auto Repair

Luke's Auto Repair

(47)
Check Engine Light, Drivetrain & Differential, Brake Repair
“We live in a world where most businesses, auto shops in this case, do take advantage of their customers but based on my experience, I think these are honest people.”
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2013
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
1107 Dublin Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Car Pro Auto Body

Car Pro Auto Body

(49)
Bumper Repair, Auto Painting
“He made a wrong into a right by helping me better understand the painting process, repairing the needed area, and did even more to make me a happy customer.”
Family Business
Locally Owned & Operated
In Business Since 2018
Free Initial Consultation
3370 Refugee Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Collision Solutions LLC

Collision Solutions LLC

(46)
  • Estimate
  • Toyota
  • Rental Car
“Helped he get everything put together for the insurance & even drop me to the closest rental car place where my insurance had a rental ready for me thanks to Collision Solution.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2021
Free Initial Consultation
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
1024 McKinley Ave, Columbus, OH
i
Auto Body Specialist

Auto Body Specialist

(46)
  • Racing
  • Students
  • Drive
“I've brought my car here twice, once in the spring to have the air conditioner recharged (still working to this day) and the other today to have a flat tire plugged.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1991
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
1058 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH
i
Premier Tire & Auto Care

Premier Tire & Auto Care

(45)
Heater Services, Tires Services, Alignment Services
“He inspected what the problem was (loud noise next to wheel), explained and showed me what part I'd need (wheel bearing), and got me in for an appointment ASAP.”
In Business Since 2015
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
3374 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Kraft's Body & Fender Co

Kraft's Body & Fender Co

(50)
Dent Removal, Bumper and Grill Work, Frame Repair
“Kraft provided regular updates for when the parts would be in, and he managed to squeeze my truck into their busy schedule once the parts did arrive since I had to wait so long.”
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 1979
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
600 Greenlawn Ave, Columbus, OH
i
Rader Collision Center

Rader Collision Center

(47)
  • Job
  • Truck
  • Insurance
“Right away he told me that, if I decide to use Rader, I should swing by any time and he will at least make it so the door will open for me until they could get the car in for the repairs.”
In Business Since 1998
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
3130 Switzer Rd, Columbus, OH
i
Gorman's Body Shop

Gorman's Body Shop

(45)
Auto Body Shop, Graphic's Shop, Truck Rental
“I took my son's Mustang in because the plastic piece under the front bumper had been partially torn off when he accidentally went over a large rock that he didn't see when parking in slightly tall grass.”
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1987
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
2625 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH
i
Central Collision

Central Collision

(44)
  • Drive
  • Call
  • Insurance Company
“I checked around at three repair shops around Clintonville for a broken bumper and their price was substantially lower and they got everything fixed quickly.”
In Business Since 2015
NAPA, NAPA Certified
2934 N High St, Columbus, OH
i
A+ Collision LLC

A+ Collision LLC

(30)
Auto Body Shop, Collision Repair
“My wife's Jeep was in an accident and they did a very good job with all the repairs and were proactive when telling me the job might take longer than expected for reasons out of their hands.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2017
Free Initial Consultation
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
830 W Broad St, Columbus, OH
i
Davidson's Collision Center Inc

Davidson's Collision Center Inc

(48)
“My Wrangler looks and drives as good as new, and they took the time to make sure everything was right before I came to pick it up and drive it three and a half hours home to Michigan.”
Free Initial Consultation
In Business Since 1976
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
2140 Integrity Dr S, Columbus, OH
i
Mowery's Collision Inc

Mowery's Collision Inc

(48)
  • Price
  • Informative
  • Insurance Company
“My understanding is there was a death of a spouse during the time of my vehicle being repaired, yet still prior to the funeral the office personnel took time to call.”
In Business Since 1983
Free Initial Consultation
BBB Certified
155 Phillipi Rd, Columbus, OH
i

Collision Services in Westerville, OH Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$400
Maximum cost
$6500
National Average
$1790
Avg Per Hour Rates
$128
$1500
$2500
Fair price range is based on 449 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $1790
Minimum cost $400
Maximum cost $6500
Avg Per Hour Rates $128

Fair range $1500 to $2500 is based on 449 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top

22 of these 24 technicians are in Westerville; the rest are in Columbus.

About Accident Damage Repair services in Westerville

Of the 24 technicians listed here, 22 are in Westerville itself; the others are in Columbus (2).

Ratings range from 4.3 to 5.0 across 1,496 reviews; 10 technicians have 50 or more reviews; 18 are rated 4.5 or higher.

2 are BBB-accredited.

2 give free estimates; 2 describe themselves as family- or locally-owned.

Services most often listed on their websites: volkswagen repair (2), audi repair (2), wheel alignment (2), air conditioning & heating (2), oil changes (2), brakes services & repair (2) and shocks & struts (2).

2 mention Spanish-speaking staff.

In structured review feedback, customers of these technicians most often flagged quality (92%), professionalism (77%) and value (62%).

16 of the 24 technicians have a website on file; 14 publish a contact page; 8 list a public email; 2 take online bookings.

6 of these technicians have had their website domain for ten or more years; the oldest was registered in 2007.

Figures are counted over the technicians on this page from public listings and company websites collected in 2026; distances are straight-line; hours and prices change, so confirm before you visit.

The 24 shops on this page handle collision and accident repair in and around Westerville, OH. What each one says about insurer programs, certifications and rentals comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

FAQ

What do I need before a shop can start work?

A claim number, the adjuster's contact, photos from the scene if you have them, and your authorization to begin. The shop cannot order parts until the estimate is approved. If you are paying yourself, none of that applies and the car goes in as soon as they have a bay.

Can I get a second estimate on accident damage?

Yes, and it is worth doing when the first one looks thin or the shop was chosen for you. Two estimates written from the same photos can differ by a lot, because one counted the blend panels and the recalibration and the other did not. Bring both to the adjuster.

Will my repair use factory parts or aftermarket ones?

That is the insurer's call more often than the shop's, and your policy spells it out. Aftermarket and recycled parts are common on older cars, and on a newer one they can affect fit and safety systems. Ask for the parts list before work starts, then ask what it costs to upgrade a line on it.

What customers in Westerville say about local technicians

Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.