View Profile
Traction Plus Discount Tires
“Great service … had a small issue with a used tire purchased … the manager John went above and beyond to back his tire repair and fix the problem permanently!”
Flat Tire Repair near Brookhaven, NY
There are no experts listed in Brookhaven itself yet; the 24 below are the closest options, from towns including Patchogue (5, 5 mi), Shirley (3, 6 mi) and Ronkonkoma (3, 9 mi).
2 open 24/7 · 23 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license
View Profile
MD Auto Repair
- Diagnostic
- Warranty
- Inspection
“They are professional and courteous and usually timely on their repairs but their prices are a bit higher then average by a good amount and that isn't reflected in the work or quality of parts used in comparison to any other shop.”
View Profile
Kraken Auto & Collision Inc.
“I bought a Mercedes c230 Kompressor off Kraken and it ran great until I nailed a pothole that you could swim in and i called Kraken and spoke w Alex and they towed me back to the shop.”
View Profile
Tire City
“Iv been going to tire city for years now they are my go to for my tires wheel alignments inspection and macanic work mike and his brother Tim are great guys highly recommend 👌 …”
View Profile
Terry Bros Tires
- Money
- Rims
- Owner
“I was first customer of the day and got two awesome quality used tires and they fixed my very jacked up rims (thanks LI potholes) and now my passenger tire can finally hold air.”
View Profile
A & R Auto Repair
“This brings me to the main focus of my comments: Every member of the team treated me, and my car, with extreme care, dignity and respect - as if it was their own - at all times throughout the process.”
Area overview: Brookhaven, NY
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 5,005 reviews; 23 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (92%), quality (83%) and value (64%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "honest" and "fair". 2 are open around the clock; 23 are open on Saturdays and 4 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brake repair (3), oil change (3), steering & suspension (3), auto repair (2) and diagnostics (2). 2 show a license on their websites; 1 lists staff certifications (ASE) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 11 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2001. 2 offer emergency or roadside call-outs; 4 offer financing; 4 give free estimates; 6 are family- or locally-owned and 10 list coupons or special offers. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Data verified October 9, 2026
Listed for drivers in and around Brookhaven, NY, these 24 shops repair flats and punctures. Hours, emergency service and whether they come to you are taken from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
View Profile
Sayville Discount Tires
“I don't live very close to Sayville, but I came here when I needed to have a tire replaced because I happened to be near Sayville when I had a blowout.”
View Profile
Arthur's Auto Repair Patchogue. Inc
- Job
- Oil
- Prices
“I highly recommend going here people who works there was very professional and patience and kind I'm definitely coming back there when I need my car fix again way better than the other mechanics that I went to”
View Profile
Northeast Towing & Recovery Inc.
- Laws
- Number
- Price
“Not only are Northeast Towing the most professional and reliable, they give realistic and accurate wait times, show up quickly, and keep you updated the whole time.”
View Profile
Barnwell House
“They checked it out asap and helped me immensely.”
View Profile
Azion Auto Service
- Brakes
- Truck
- Inspection
“The shop is located in Shirley NY on Montauk Hwy, if you're in the area, and need a good, no I should say GREAT Mechanic Azion Auto is the place to go”
View Profile
Central Islip Firestone
“Good local mechanic and tire shop”
View Profile
Smithwest Service Center Inc.
- Efficient
- Flat Tire
- Work
“Couldn't have asked for a better driver to come help me when I needed it.”
View Profile
Gene's 112 Auto Service Center
“Shortly after my drop off of the initial diagnostic I received a text with a link to the results listing what was good, what would need to be done at some point in the future and what needs to be done ASAP.”
View Profile
Bo's Auto and Truck Repair
- Morning
- Name
- Oil
“I've never been surprised at unexpectedly high cost repairs, they have always checked out what needs to be done and let me know the costs before doing the work and will update me as needed as the work progresses.”
View Profile
Lakeview Car Care
“I always bring my car to Lakeview Car Care due their impeccable service.”
View Profile
Yaphank Towing and Recovery Inc.
- Tires
- Company
- Need
“Kam is great, he help me tow my BMW, my car is very low cause it is a sports car and he knew how to handle the situation so my cars bumper won't get damaged go in or out of the towing truck .”
View Profile
Tire Guys Complete Auto Repair
- Fair
- Job
- Vehicle
“Rich and The shop came highly recommended from a friend and now because of their excellent, professional, fextremely knowledgeable expertise and consistent willingness to accommodate whatever car needs may arise They have become my regular trusted go...”
View Profile
F&C Tires Inc.
“I remember coming to this place for the past 20 years with my family, this place always has great customer service and they're very accurate mechanics!”
View Profile
Roadway Tire Corporation
“They are very professional and the pricing is excellent I also like that they're very honest and they also have a sense of humor which I like thank you again I have found my new mechanic.”
View Profile
Hendrickson Towing and Recovery
- Tractor
- Parking
- Company
“We haul tractor trailer loads out of long island and the roads to site take toll on trucks, fixing things weekly, this morning one of our trucks broke air lineand hendricson gave us road side repair, way to far for me to try to go fix it, mechanic di...”
View Profile
Los Brother's Auto Repair & Towing
“The brothers there are breath of fresh air in a world full of crooks he's too of always been honest with me their work is excellent and nice guys all around I would highly recommend them.”
View Profile
Tire Warehouse
- Honest
- Brothers
- Truck
“I have been going to TIRE WAREHOUSE for over 20 years because Howie and Walter, the proprietors, are the most experienced tire guys I have ever done business with.”
View Profile
H&H Towing Services
- Price
“Came to the rescue right away.”
Tire Repair Services in Brookhaven, NY Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$13
Maximum cost
$50
National Average
$25
$19
$38
Average price range is based on 268 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
FAQ
Can I get a puncture fixed on a Sunday?
23 of the 24 shops here show weekend hours, though Saturday is far more common than Sunday. A puncture repair is a short job, so a shop that takes walk-ins will often squeeze one in between booked work. Call rather than drive over on a flat.
What customers say about experts near Brookhaven
- “Highly recommend this place. I had a screw in my car tire and they had it removed and patched in 20 minutes for a very reasonable charge.” — customer of F&C Tires Inc.
- “Came here after I experienced a flat tire a few days ago on my way to work.” — customer of Barnwell House
- “Great service. Stopped in to deal with a flat tire and was greated by a man who very much concerned himself with my needs and did everything to ensure that those needs were met promptly/properly.” — customer of Yaphank Towing and Recovery Inc.
- “I went to get a flat tire plugged and they plugged it and put it back on in a matter of minutes!” — customer of Tire Guys Complete Auto Repair
- “They found the puncture in a few seconds, got my tire off and fixed it quickly and cheaper than I expected.” — customer of F&C Tires Inc.
Excerpts from public reviews of the experts listed on this page.