Appleton, WI

Popular Cities

Appleton, WI
Join as a Pro

Tire Shops in Appleton, WI

24 experts listed · 12 in Appleton · 4 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+

View Profile
Baumgart Tire & Wheel Inc

Baumgart Tire & Wheel Inc

(47)
“Today I took my wife's car and a very friendly young man named Ben encouraged me to stick around when I was ready to take off, he came back in less than 10 minutes telling me the problem was minor and had been fixed for free.”
BBB Rating: A+
Family Business
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
914 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Matthews Tire

Matthews Tire

(49)
  • Fair
  • Tires
  • Work
“They were able to inspect the car right away and order the parts for my 16yr old car and get me back on the road with only a minimal amount of time needing a rental.”
ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1962
2930 W College Ave, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Zentner's Auto Service LLC

Zentner's Auto Service LLC

(48)
  • Work
  • Honest
  • Truck
“Hi it was a great experience people are very nice they get the job done and they're honest and that's all you can ask for especially nowadays thank you”
ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1970
4510 W Greenville Dr, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Richmond Street Automotive

Richmond Street Automotive

(48)
“Also, if you're willing to receive texts they will text a link to a quote page once they've done their assessment (which includes pictures when appropriate), and usually follow up a week or so after your service to check in to see how things are goin...”
ASE Certified
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
1731 N Richmond St, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Pete's Auto Repair and Sales

Pete's Auto Repair and Sales

(48)
“Their prices seem very fair, scheduled openings are reasonable, urgent spots seem available when needed, they are quite personable, and don't try to sell you stuff you don't need.”
BBB Rating: A+
Family Business
Accepts Check
Coupons & Offers
2006 N Meade St, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Rob's Import Repair

Rob's Import Repair

(47)
  • Technicians
  • Diagnostic
  • Dealership
“I've always been a “take it to the dealer” but when it became obvious that the dealer wasn't quite living up to the service provided in the past it was time for a change.”
BBB Accredited
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1994
310 Allegiance Ct, Appleton, WI
i

Area overview: Appleton, WI

Of the 24 experts we list here, 12 are in Appleton itself and 12 come from towns including Menasha (3, 5 mi), Kaukauna (3, 6 mi) and Neenah (2, 8 mi). The experts on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 20,148 reviews; 23 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (90%), quality (87%) and value (77%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "honest", "fair" and "communication". 4 are open on Saturdays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brakes (3), wheel alignments (3), auto repairs (2), exhaust (2) and oil changes (2). 4 list staff certifications (ASE) and 11 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 17 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1999. 5 offer financing; 4 give free estimates; 12 are family- or locally-owned and 13 list coupons or special offers. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.

Data verified October 9, 2026

Listed for drivers in and around Appleton, WI, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center

(46)
  • Honest
  • Oil
  • Fluids
“Also one time I had to get new Lugnuts because the old ones were swollen and they did them much cheaper than the first place that was going to do them by hundreds of dollars.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
2940 E College Ave, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Autotrust

Autotrust

(44)
  • Work
  • Vehicle
  • Estimate
“Bought my moped from them”
Family Business
In Business Since 1992
2530 S Oneida St, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Auto Aces

Auto Aces

(48)
“I also brought in a 2020 Chevy Equinox that I recently purchased from an out-of-town dealership to look at a leak right before the Independence Day weekend.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Family Business
In Business Since 2004
2212 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
DC Auto Repair LLC

DC Auto Repair LLC

(49)
  • Diagnosis
  • Truck
  • Understanding
“Today was only an oil change, but I have entrusted them with bigger projects and they have come in under the promised budget and in a timely manner with my vehicle repairs.”
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2012
W5463 County Hwy KK, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
American Fleet & Auto Service

American Fleet & Auto Service

(49)
  • Needs
  • Price
  • Tire
“Contacted 7 or 8 other shops to do a catalytic converter replacement on my truck Todd was the only one that called me back and with a lower quote than anyone else and didn't try to up charge me like other places have done.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2006
2010 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Kbautosports

Kbautosports

(9)
  • Work
  • Rims
  • Winter Tires
“I've had a bunch of different work done (tires replaced on beadlock rims, steering components replacements, Brakes & Rotor replacement, Ball Joints, valve stems on another vehicle) all work was done professionally.”
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
Locally Owned & Operated
In Business Since 2022
3090 Spirit Ct Suite #4, Appleton, WI
i
View Profile
Custom Offsets

Custom Offsets

(45)
  • Lugs
  • Rims
  • Custom Wheels
“I love shoping with custom offsets they have very reasonable prices and I have always received my purchase within the delegated time frame if not sooner than expected.”
BBB Rating: A+
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2017
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Al Huss Auto & Truck

Al Huss Auto & Truck

(48)
“We'll always use this place because the last thing anyone wants is to be stranded due to poor mechanic work and then have to deal with poor customer service, both of which, we never have to worry about here.”
BBB Accredited
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Brady's Automotive Center

Brady's Automotive Center

(37)
“I was a mechanic for a while (I've been out of the industry for years now though)and I went to the same school that brady did so I still get a lot of car questions from friends and relatives.”
BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2017
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Cartech Auto Repair

Cartech Auto Repair

(50)
  • Fair
  • Price
  • Trust
“I have been using Car Tech auto for the last couple years, recently I had some repairs on both my vehicles which bringing them to Mike (owner) I trust him greatly.”
BBB Accredited
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 1998
Serving Appleton Area
Featured

How are your drive belts doing? Your drive belts transfer power from your cam or crankshaft to the car's alternator, air conditioning compressor, power steering pump, air pump, water pump and any other device that relies on mechanical power. These belts are made of rubber and wear down over time....

i
View Profile
Rob's Repair LLC

Rob's Repair LLC

(39)
  • Vehicle
  • Oil
  • Fair
“Although at no ones fault, it took a little longer than expected, they went out of there way to save me money compared to all other shops I had talked to.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Family Business
Offers Financing Options
Coupons & Offers
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Southside Tire & Automotive Repair

Southside Tire & Automotive Repair

(46)
“They gave me a brand new tire for the used price I was baffled the new tire was on a truck for just a few miles an they hooked me up with it sticker was still on it for 44 bucks”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 1968
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Randall's Auto Haus

Randall's Auto Haus

(44)
  • Mechanic
  • Honest
  • Job
“(Thanks to my research, we found out that a previous mechanic had put on the timing gear on backwards, which was causing the harmonic balancer to stick out a bit and the serpentine belt being shredded with in a weeks time)”
BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1990
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Valley Muffler & Brake

Valley Muffler & Brake

(45)
  • Morning
  • Brakes
  • Mechanic
“After spending about $1,300 at a different local auto shop only to have my car check engine light come back on and have the same issue, we took my car to Valley Muffler.”
BBB Accredited
Family Business
In Business Since 2014
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Complete Auto Repair

Complete Auto Repair

(44)
  • Work
  • Honest
  • Vehicle
“Mike and Mike responded to our need quickly, said the car could be repaired and did not need an engine replacement and worked on it as quickly as possible and kept us updated.”
In Business Since 2017
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Goss Auto Body

Goss Auto Body

(46)
“They were really great with setting up a time very quickly for a free estimate, the price was easily $2000 lower than another place I'd looked at, they were thankfully able to squeeze me in right after the Christmas holiday, and the door they got loo...”
ASE Certified
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
In Business Since 1999
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Honest Guys Auto LLC

Honest Guys Auto LLC

(50)
  • Communication
  • Mechanic
  • Information
“I am a supplier of products for the guys there at honest guys auto LLC and they are very nice the customers I have talked to have nothing bad to say a very fair priced and they get on the project as soon as possible which is a plus and thanks for goi...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards, Check
In Business Since 2012
Serving Appleton Area
i
View Profile
Packerland Tire & Auto

Packerland Tire & Auto

(43)
  • Owner
  • Vehicle
  • Brake
“Great communication, very friendly, got the job done faster than expected, and reasonable price for what she needed done very happy with the service we received will definitely be going back again in the future thank you very much @Packerland auto”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 2011
2660 Packerland Dr, Green Bay, WI
i
HomeTire StoresWisconsinAppleton, WI

Tire Repair Services in Appleton, WI Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$17
Maximum cost
$56
National Average
$28
$23
$45
Average price range is based on 396 cost profiles
Embed on your site

Your Embed Code

Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $28
Minimum cost $17
Maximum cost $56

Average range $23 to $45 is based on 396 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?

FAQ

Which shops listed for Appleton offer financing on a full set?

Financing is mentioned on this page by 5 of the 24 shops. For tires that usually means a store card or a third-party plan with a promotional interest-free window. The number that matters is what the rate becomes when the window closes, so ask for it before you sign.

More Tire Shops in Wisconsin

Popular in Appleton

, WI
Back To Top