View Profile
Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros
“They diagnosed my tire leak, rebalanced all of the tire pressure settings on the dashboard and recommended the next set of tires that would be cost-effective.”
Best Tire Shops near Middletown, NJ
These experts serve Middletown from nearby bases in towns including Staten Island, NY, Freehold and South Amboy.
24 experts listed · 19 open weekends · 22 rated 4.5+ · 1 shows a license
Data verified October 16, 2026
View Profile
Emil's All Tire
“Great prices very knowledgeable staff Ralph and Ariella all the best when it comes to customer service and answering all my needs will not go to any other shop”
View Profile
Freehold Tire Pros and Automotive Center
- Fair
- Truck
- Alignments
“After a horrible experience at the Honda dealer now that my Honda Civic is out of warranty, I'm back to my trusted Freehold Tire for maintenance checks.”
View Profile
Breen Bros. Towing Inc
- Gentleman
- Technician
- Roadside Assistance
“Flat tire late at night, called Ford roadside assistance after 2 previous companies were dispatched and were removed due to the excessive delay they assigned Breen Brothers.”
View Profile
West Shore Tires & Auto Center
“When 3 other shops gave me a difficult time and were rude in getting my issue sorted, Pino and then Joe were friendly, accommodating and helped me within 25 minutes.”
View Profile
Mullaney Tire & Car Care Center
- Work
- Fair
- Inspection
“Great service, great price!”
Listed for drivers in and around Middletown, NJ, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Middletown, NJ
The 24 experts on this page are rated from 4.2 to 5.0 across 7,595 reviews; all 24 have 50 or more reviews and 22 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (95%), quality (82%) and value (73%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "fair", "honest" and "diagnosis". 18 are open on Saturdays and 3 on Sundays. The services the experts on this page list most often on their websites are brake repairs (2), oil changes (2), preventative maintenance (2), preventive maintenance (2) and wheel alignments (2). 1 shows a license on its website; 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 7 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 22 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 107 years. 7 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 9 are family- or locally-owned and 18 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 24 of the experts on this page; 22 publish a contact page; 17 list a public email and 9 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Which shops listed for Middletown offer financing on a full set?
Financing is mentioned on this page by 7 of the 24 shops. For tires that usually means a store card or a third-party plan with a promotional interest-free window. The number that matters is what the rate becomes when the window closes, so ask for it before you sign.
View Profile
Medina Tire Service
“Great customer service and labor”
View Profile
BC Tire & Complete Auto Service
“Steve and Francisco were great took care of mounting my tires and rims i purchased online and brought to them,,took care of alignment and truck drove perfect..”
View Profile
B&S Tire and Auto Service Center
- Work
- Ipads
- Waiting Area
“Pleasant environment and I appreciate that when I send my daughter with her car on her own for a tire patch or service you provide a comfortable waiting area that is clean.”
View Profile
Guy's Tire Buys LLC
- People
- Diagnosis
- Pricing
“Good service and honest.”
View Profile
Henderson's Service Center
- Mechanic
- Oil
- Fair
“I had been using a local Midas for the past couple of years, and was getting tired if the heavy sales pitches for 20 unrelated things when I brought my cars in.”
View Profile
Quality 1st Auto Repair
- AC
- BMW
- Job
“They took car in, diagnosed the problem quickly, i also had them replace my brakes and rotors, great service , great work and had my car ready within a few hours.”
View Profile
Van Derveer's Tire & Services Center
- Light
- Fair
- Mechanic
“Had a flat tire but was able to get my truck over to them in the afternoon, left my truck overnight (by my choice) and they had a new tire they ordered on by 9:30 following morning.”
View Profile
Crown Tire
“But the person who assisted was very informative and said the tires are in great condition and still have life, they patched it up quick and I was on my way home.”
View Profile
Thrust Performance
“And so there should not be one single soul that would take any merit or sway their judgment in the opposite direction because of that negative review because of many reasons but the number one reason and it's a very in-your-face reason, and not being...”
View Profile
Middletown Trailer Supply
“The approval was fast and the transaction only lasted 20 minutes in a quick Proseso I went out with my new Traila good prices and good services ZAF ALI service 5 stars”
View Profile
Front End Shop
“They are timely, honest, and have gone above and beyond with my vehicles, whether I'm calling them at 7 am on a Monday or showing up just before closing on the Friday before Christmas.”
View Profile
Tire World
- Rim
- Truck
- Fair
“Unfortunately, they weren't able to find/get the parts to do the necessary work but yeah from my automotive education and knowledge I was able to determine theres honesty here!”
View Profile
ASC Automotive
- Brakes
- Diagnosed
- Mechanic
“Top notch in service and knowledge.”
View Profile
Dr K's Auto Care Center
- Vehicle
- Prices
- Owner
“I was like everyone thinking I'm gonna get robbed or they are gonna upsell, no Mr Kaufman the owner was working with the other guys, came over and asked what's wrong with car, I explained it, he took his time to explain this and that and said I could...”
View Profile
Brookhill Tire & Auto
- Truck
- f250
- Oil
“Great service, needed 4 new tires, new wipers & an oil change, I didn't have an appt so I took a chance & stopped in & was happy when Mike said "no problem", he asked if I was going to wait, which I did, I was out in a little more than an hour.”
View Profile
Precision Transmission & Auto Repair
- Leak
- Check
- Tire
“Even if they don't have the tires this will be my new go to for repairs just by the simple fact they actually care about their business and that is a company I want to use !!!!”
View Profile
Tire Craft
- Honest
- Price
- Mechanic
“An disadvantage of going here though if I recall correctly is there's no actual parking spots and is an very tiny area back there resulting in hardship of maneuvering around.”
View Profile
Boss Audio
- Warranty
- Truck
- Windows
“(Dave let me drop off my car the night before the scheduled appointment and let me keep it there the entire next day until the shop closed to pick it up, even though the car was ready by early afternoon) Overall great work at a good price.”
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
