Best Collision Repair in Appleton, WI

The highest-rated Accident Damage Repair companies out of 156 vetted & reviewed in the Appleton area.

Tim's Body Shop

Tim's Body Shop

(47)
  • Truck
  • Vehicle
  • Fair
“They were all concerned when I came to pick up because they said the new fender came with a tiny dent in it, and when they went to show me, none of us could even see it to point it out, it was that small, but that's how much they paid attention to de...”
In Business Since 2012
Free Initial Consultation
3200 W Main St, Appleton, WI
i
Femal's Auto Body Inc

Femal's Auto Body Inc

(28)
Free Estimates
“They ended up having to write two estimates because American Family is terrible insurance, so despite the other driver being 100% responsible we still had to go through our insurance West Bend.”
In Business Since 1977
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
200 E Northland Ave, Appleton, WI
i
Blankenship's Auto Body & Vinyl Wraps

Blankenship's Auto Body & Vinyl Wraps

(32)
  • Insurance Company
  • Communication
  • Truck
“The workmanship is outstanding and the care for his customers cars is remarkable, I had to get something fix and Teddy went above and beyond and fix some other things for my Infiniti G37x I've stopped there twice now because I had a bird do their bus...”
In Business Since 2020
1604 W Haskel St # A, Appleton, WI
i
Peotter's Collision Center

Peotter's Collision Center

(10)
  • Work
  • Team
  • Insurance Company
“They walk thru everything with me, and called my insurance company and worked with them, I didn't have to do anything but relax and know my vehicle was in good hands.”
In Business Since 1999
Offers Financing Options
5555 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI 54913
i
Sprangers Auto Body

Sprangers Auto Body

(7)
“When I entrusted my BMW to his care, I was genuinely astonished by the expeditious manner in which he completed the task.”
In Business Since 1986
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
N2429 County Rd N, Appleton, WI
i
Legend Auto LLC

Legend Auto LLC

(19)
  • Tires
  • Price
“I do the vast majority of my and my wife's auto repair work, but sometimes, something needs to be repaired that's either "over my head" or I don't have the time, the space or even the interest to do it myself.”
715 W Bell Ave, Appleton, WI
i
I-Car Tech Center

I-Car Tech Center

(2)
“The most kind, caring and supportive group of people you will ever meet.”
In Business Since 1996
N127 S Park Dr, Appleton, WI
i
Jim's Auto Body

Jim's Auto Body

(7)
“He also took the time to explain everything he did and why he did it.”
In Business Since 1987
W3023 Van Roy Rd, Appleton, WI
i
Tri Five Trike Conversions LLC

Tri Five Trike Conversions LLC

(1)
“Very good business”
2808 E Crestview Dr, Appleton, WI
i
Cartech Auto Repair

Cartech Auto Repair

(50)
  • Fair
  • Vehicle
  • Team
“Mike and his team have never let me down with both my foreign and domestic vehicles Services Electrical repair, Battery service, Air & cabin filter replacement, Tires, Auto power window repair, Steering & suspension repair, Auto water leak repair, Au...”
In Business Since 2000
Licensed, BBB Accredited
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Coupons & Offers
Serving Appleton Area
i
Wisconsin Auto & Truck Repair

Wisconsin Auto & Truck Repair

(46)
  • Trucks
  • Prices
  • Job
“Bob and Rob are legends in the local car industry old cars and new cars these guys know there stuff and take amazing care of their customers I say this from a year relationship I've had with these guys I've taken multiple vehicles there and bought on...”
In Business Since 2012
ASE Certified
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Serving Appleton Area
i
Rob's Repair LLC

Rob's Repair LLC

(39)
Napa Autocare Center Benefits, Classic Car Repair, Napa Peace of Mind Warranty
“Although at no ones fault, it took a little longer than expected, they went out of there way to save me money compared to all other shops I had talked to.”
In Business Since 2007
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Offers Financing Options
Serving Appleton Area
i
Dave's Auto Body Inc

Dave's Auto Body Inc

(49)
Insurance Claims
“Very friendly, professional and get the job done well and in time.”
In Business Since 1991
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
1748 W Paulson Rd, Green Bay, WI
i
Goss Auto Body

Goss Auto Body

(46)
“They have Honesty and integrity which goes a long way, They did an awesome job on my truck and they called me and told me that there were scratches on my tinted windows that they did, I would have never known it was them that did it but they told me ...”
In Business Since 1999
ASE Certified
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
Serving Appleton Area
i
Joe's Collision & Restoration

Joe's Collision & Restoration

(24)
“I like the game Positive Professionalism”
In Business Since 1983
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Appleton Area
i
Geiger Auto Body

Geiger Auto Body

(18)
  • Price
  • Vehicle
  • Cleaning
“They repaired my daughter's front bumper last week that I put a hole in it with the muffler from my power washer that rolled up against it which I caught to late anyways my fault but as usual they fixed it and did an excellent job and very reasonabl...”
In Business Since 1978
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Appleton Area
i
Krons Service Center

Krons Service Center

(12)
Air Conditioning, Engine Service, Cooling Systems
“They do really good work on your ride!”
In Business Since 1988
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Appleton Area
i
RJ Auto

RJ Auto

(4)
Brakes, Transmissions, Suspension and Steering
“They are able to provide maintenence on everything from small to big, and even has an auto collision department.”
In Business Since 2023
ASE, ASE, ASE, ASE, ASE, ASE Certified
Free Initial Consultation
Family Business
2690 Calaway Dr, Green Bay, WI
i
Auto Body Solutions

Auto Body Solutions

(7)
Car and Truck Auto Body and Paint
“Phil was very good at communication on all he was doing to find what I need to fix my bumper and painted it and put it on for me and it turned out amazing.”
In Business Since 2012
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Accepts Check, Cash
Serving Appleton Area
i
Arcs n Sparks

Arcs n Sparks

(13)
  • Price
“Great place good work”
In Business Since 2019
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Serving Appleton Area
i
Collision Specialists

Collision Specialists

(3)
“Don't be scared when you drive up they have lots of wrecked cars because they tow for the insurance company they know what they are doing good work both body and mechanical”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
2690 Calaway Dr, Green Bay, WI
i
Russ Auto Repair

Russ Auto Repair

(9)
  • Price
  • Call
“Quotes that I have received from more than five different auto repair shops and/or dealerships have been excessively overcharged…Time and time again Russ auto repair has always been a better price, a better quality, a better experience!”
In Business Since 2005
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Appleton Area
i
Seefeldt Collision Repair

Seefeldt Collision Repair

(12)
  • Company
  • Insurance
“If you are looking for a body/collision repair shop that is ran by honest people who do top notch work at fair prices, save yourself the headache and just go to Seefeldt Collision Repair.”
In Business Since 1985
Family Business
Serving Appleton Area
i
Frank & Mike's Service Center

Frank & Mike's Service Center

(4)
“They quoted me a very fair price and walked me through the exact repair when I arrived to pick up my vehicle.”
In Business Since 1980
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
Serving Appleton Area
i

Collision Services in Appleton, WI Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$446
Maximum cost
$7245
National Average
$1996
Avg Per Hour Rates
$143
$1672
$2787
Fair price range is based on 348 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $1996
Minimum cost $446
Maximum cost $7245
Avg Per Hour Rates $143

Fair range $1672 to $2787 is based on 348 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top

12 of these 24 technicians are in Appleton; the rest are in Green Bay and Manitowoc.

About Accident Damage Repair services in Appleton

Of the 24 technicians listed here, 12 are in Appleton itself; the others are in Green Bay (10), Manitowoc (2).

Ratings range from 4.4 to 5.0 across 1,084 reviews; 8 technicians have 50 or more reviews; 22 are rated 4.5 or higher.

2 are BBB-accredited; 2 mention certified staff (ASE).

2 give free estimates; 2 describe themselves as family- or locally-owned.

Services most often listed on their websites: napa autocare center benefits (2), napa peace of mind warranty (2), car care tips (2), wheel alignments (2), custom exhaust (2) and classic car repair (2).

In structured review feedback, customers of these technicians most often flagged quality (100%), professionalism (94%) and value (88%).

18 of the 24 technicians have a website on file; 12 publish a contact page; 2 list a public email; 2 take online bookings.

12 of these technicians have had their website domain for ten or more years; the oldest was registered in 1996.

Figures are counted over the technicians on this page from public listings and company websites collected in 2026; distances are straight-line; hours and prices change, so confirm before you visit.

The 24 shops on this page handle collision and accident repair in and around Appleton, WI. What each one says about insurer programs, certifications and rentals comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

FAQ

What do I need before a shop can start work?

A claim number, the adjuster's contact, photos from the scene if you have them, and your authorization to begin. The shop cannot order parts until the estimate is approved. If you are paying yourself, none of that applies and the car goes in as soon as they have a bay.

Can I get a second estimate on accident damage?

Yes, and it is worth doing when the first one looks thin or the shop was chosen for you. Two estimates written from the same photos can differ by a lot, because one counted the blend panels and the recalibration and the other did not. Bring both to the adjuster.

Will my repair use factory parts or aftermarket ones?

That is the insurer's call more often than the shop's, and your policy spells it out. Aftermarket and recycled parts are common on older cars, and on a newer one they can affect fit and safety systems. Ask for the parts list before work starts, then ask what it costs to upgrade a line on it.

What customers in Appleton say about local technicians

Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.

Data verified September 19, 2026