Best Collision Repair in Madison, WI

15 technicians listed · 11 in Madison · 2 open weekends · 13 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 8, 2026

Advance Collision & Repair

Advance Collision & Repair

4.9 62 reviews
“Also Shawn was amazing in dealing with the insurance claim side of things and just made the whole process easy.”
5% off deductible discountLifetime warrantyFree estimatesASE-certified techsLoaner cars5,000 vehicles serviced
2533 Advance Rd
i
Roman Auto Body

Roman Auto Body

5.0 58 reviews
“Great to work with and if I never need future body work this will be the place I go.”
Lifetime warrantyFree estimatesLoaner carsInsurance claim helpSince 2003BBB A+
2409 Daniels St
i
Lynch Auto Body Inc

Lynch Auto Body Inc

4.9 137 reviews
“As well, he told me that he was able to get the insurance company to cover purchasing a new steel reinforcement bar for my bumper after he discovered the most minuscule damage to it after the collision.”
Lifetime warrantyFree estimates24/7 towingWalk-ins welcomeInsurance claim helpSince 1956
2305 Atwood Ave
i
Rodell Auto Inc.

Rodell Auto Inc.

4.8 52 reviews
“They were creative in being able to make it near perfect for less than half the cost by reusing the plastic pieces.”
BBB A+Since 1990
2123 N Stoughton Rd
i
Russ Darrow Collision Center

Russ Darrow Collision Center

4.1 39 reviews
“Autumn at Russ Darrow was very friendly, professional and kept me apprised of progress on the extensive accident repairs to my Jeep Trailhawk.”
Since 2020Financing
6525 Odana Rd
i
Rose Custom & Collision Llc

Rose Custom & Collision Llc

4.8 69 reviews
“I know I can count on him for any custom or collision job I need done on my car, and the results will be exceptional.”
Since 2009
2413 Pennsylvania Ave
i

Listed for drivers in and around Madison, WI, these 15 shops handle collision and accident repair. What each one says about insurer programs, certifications and rentals comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Getting collision damage repaired in Madison

Of the 15 technicians we list here, 11 are in Madison itself and 4 come from Middleton (2, 6 mi), McFarland (1, 6 mi) and Waunakee (1, 8 mi). The technicians on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 1,679 reviews; 10 have 50 or more reviews and 13 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the technicians on this page are "price", "estimates" and "communication". We count these figures across the technicians on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the technician before you visit.

What federal rules say about car repair
Oscar's Auto Repair

Oscar's Auto Repair

4.6 71 reviews
“They fix your Car and don't care about providing cookies and coffee because they charge fair rates.”
Since 2016
2518 Packers Ave
i
National Coatings & Supplies (Formerly Body Shop Supply Co Inc)

National Coatings & Supplies (Formerly Body Shop Supply Co Inc)

4.6 33 reviews
“I like this place good customer service”
1212 Greenway Cross
i
Madison Automotive

Madison Automotive

4.8 14 reviews
“Troy was able to get our Jeep in last minute when the clutch went out.”
Since 2014
715 Post Rd
i
Mad-Town Auto

Mad-Town Auto

4.1 7 reviews
“Honest hard worker just trying to go that extra mile for his family and overall success.”
1016 Stewart St suite b
i
Alliance Trailer Body Shop

Alliance Trailer Body Shop

5.0 2 reviews
“Matt and Rick are great and nice”
301 Atlas Ave
i
Collision Masters

Collision Masters

4.9 78 reviews
“The estimate was quick and efficient, and she worked directly with State Farm, making this part of the process seamless.”
Insurance claim helpBBB A+Since 2012
Waunakee, WI · 8 mi from Madison
i
Auto Color Inc

Auto Color Inc

4.8 79 reviews
“Andy was thorough in explaining the work needed and I had my car back looking new in less than 24 hours for dent and paint repair on my tailgate.”
Free estimatesMobile serviceBBB accreditedSince 1995
Middleton, WI · 6 mi from Madison
i
Avenue Auto Body

Avenue Auto Body

4.7 37 reviews
“Working on a short-time frame for when my son needed to return, he came up with a great solution and the car is not only drivable, it almost looks fully repaired.”
Lifetime warrantyInsurer direct-repair shopPick-up & drop-offInsurance claim helpSince 1964
Middleton, WI · 6 mi from Madison
i
A-One Autoworks

A-One Autoworks

4.8 30 reviews
“You won't pay the overhead other shops charge because of added employees, you get above and beyond quality work at a very fair price.”
Since 1979
McFarland, WI · 6 mi from Madison
i
HomeCollision CentersWisconsinMadison, WI

Compare Collision Repair in Madison, WI

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Roman Auto Body5.0 · 58 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5 (varies)LifetimeClaim helpSince 2003Loaner car
Lynch Auto Body Inc4.9 · 137 reviews
Mon–Fri 7:30–6 (varies) · Sat 7:30–5LifetimeClaim helpSince 1956
Avenue Auto Body4.7 · 37 reviews · Middleton
Mon–Fri 8–5 (varies)LifetimeDirect-repair shopSince 1964Pick-up & drop-off
Advance Collision & Repair4.9 · 62 reviews
Mon–Fri 8:30–5LifetimeLoaner car
Auto Color Inc4.8 · 79 reviews · Middleton
Mon–Fri 8–5 (varies)As long you own your carSince 1995
Collision Masters4.9 · 78 reviews · Waunakee
Mon–Fri 7–6Claim helpSince 2012
Rose Custom & Collision Llc4.8 · 69 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–5 (varies)Since 2009
Rodell Auto Inc.4.8 · 52 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–12Since 1990
A-One Autoworks4.8 · 30 reviews · McFarland
Mon–Fri 8–4:30Since 1979
Oscar's Auto Repair4.6 · 71 reviews
Mon–Fri 9–6Since 2016
Madison Automotive4.8 · 14 reviews
Mon–Fri 8:30–6 (varies)Since 2014
Russ Darrow Collision Center4.1 · 39 reviews
Mon–Fri 7–5Since 2020
National Coatings & Supplies (Formerly Body Shop Supply Co Inc)4.6 · 33 reviews
Mon–Fri 7:30–4
Alliance Trailer Body Shop5.0 · 2 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–4:30
Mad-Town Auto4.1 · 7 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5:30

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo shop pays us anything. Nobody can buy a place, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedPermanently closed shops, call centers posing as local garages and duplicate chain branches stay off our list.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, ASE certification and years in business come from each shop's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: hours, phone, website and reviews.

For Collision Centers we compared 209 shops in and around Madison. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then shops in Madison, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

What customers say about technicians in Madison

  • “Very professional, prompt, courteous, and friendly. I would recommend Rose Custom Collision without a doubt.” — customer of Rose Custom & Collision Llc
  • “I've been doing business with Advance Collision & Repair for more than 2 decades now and they've never failed to impress me with their communications, service, completion timeframes and outstanding quality.” — customer of Advance Collision & Repair
  • “Tim went above and beyond. He took the extra step of getting my parking pass out of my car, which I hadn’t even thought about in the moment, and later retrieved my license plates for me once the car was deemed a total loss.” — customer of Lynch Auto Body Inc
  • “Rose Collision is a locally-owned business that operates with integrity and produces quality work.” — customer of Rose Custom & Collision Llc

Excerpts from public reviews of the technicians listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top