View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
“They have always taken great care of my vehicle.”
Tire Shops in Westerville, OH
24 experts listed · 4 in Westerville · 15 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+
View Profile
Boyd's Northgate Tire & Service
“Not only did Boyd's quickly diagnose the issue - they showed true integrity and fixed a loose liner and didn't try and upsell unnecessary expensive parts like a new bearing even though I initially thought that may be the issue.”
View Profile
Buckeye Complete Auto Care
- Communication
- Price
- Vehicle
“From that point had the car fixed by them and when an issued occurred, they were extremely responsive, caring and took care of not only the car but with a loaner so I can get to and from with my son.”
View Profile
Joe's Service Station
- Fair
- Honest
- Money
“We are from Washington DC and were desperately looking for a place to help as the plastic covering on the bottom of my Toyota Prius had come loose and was dragging on the highway.”
View Profile
Shad Used Tires
- Flat
- Price
“Simply unbelievable I think I found it honest hard-working used tire business with family run ethics and morals time will tell I got the tires today we will see good price good service.”
View Profile
Agler Road Tires Inc
“Good place to buy spare parts”
Area overview: Westerville, OH
Of the 24 experts we list here, 4 are in Westerville itself and 20 come from towns including Columbus (12, 10 mi), Lewis Center (1, 6 mi) and Sunbury (1, 9 mi). The experts on this page are rated from 4.2 to 4.9 across 4,546 reviews; 23 have 50 or more reviews and 23 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these experts on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (93%), quality (63%) and punctuality (59%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the experts on this page are "price", "honest" and "communication". 15 are open on Saturdays and 5 on Sundays. 4 list staff certifications (ASE) and 14 have a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 12 websites of the experts on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1997. 11 offer financing; 2 give free estimates; 7 are family- or locally-owned and 14 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 20 of the experts on this page; 17 publish a contact page; 9 list a public email and 7 take bookings online. We count these figures across the experts on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the expert before you visit.
Data verified October 10, 2026
Listed for drivers in and around Westerville, OH, these 24 shops sell and fit tires. Brands carried, warranties and installation charges come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
View Profile
Eagle Auto Repair
- Truck
- Vehicle
- Trip
“I'll always trust them with my vehicle Services Electrical repair, Steering & suspension repair, Brakes, Air conditioning, Wiper blade installation, Oil change”
View Profile
State Tire & Service
“I would also highly recommend them for any ladies who want to get their cars worked on, the staff are all extremely police, courteous, well mannered and very comfortable to work with.”
View Profile
Hilliard Tire & Auto Center
“Over multiple years and vehicles, they've handled tires, brakes, steering, and exhaust problems for my family, and we've always been exceptionally happy.”
View Profile
Premier Tire & Auto Care
- Job
- Price
- Money
“I had my car towed in for an alternator replacement, but ended up replacing my timing belt too, which was badly in need of replacement (12 years old 😲).”
View Profile
Scott's Complete Car Care
- Oil
- Honest
- Mechanic
“I've known scott for over 15 years he has done work on my chevy and dodge truck hes very knowledgeable in his profession i would highly recommend scott's complete car care thanks scott”
View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
- Desk
- Oil
- Team
“As I waited for my car I could here the other service advisor take phone calls and give great advise to customers with the customer's needs being first and foremost.”
View Profile
Mr. USA New and Used Tires
- Brand
- Flat
- Job
“They were the only ones with a used tire in the size I needed, I was honestly going to give up after having no luck with previous places but they were the very last place I was going to check.”
View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
- Mechanic
- Vehicle
- Oil
“They fixed my car and it runs a lot better, but what really made a difference was he asked me to bring the car back in a month so he can look at his workmanship and make sure everything is still good.”
View Profile
JDS Commercial Tires
“Tire price and service better than competitors in the area, real knowledgeable on helping get the right tire and offers 90 day same as cash financing, to help you out if you qualify Just a great place”
View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
- Truck
- Vehicle
- Job
“I trust the staff of this Tuffy impeccably to not only treat each vehicle they touch with the care and attention they would of it belonged to their own family, but to go the extra mile to explain, prioritize, and go the extra mile to take care of the...”
View Profile
Ohio State Used & New Tires + Brakes
“Had a bad tire, got an authentic Mitchellin tire for a decent price, they are experience with tired and all work on cars mostly good customer experience......”
View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
- Work
- Oil
- Driving
“My car was having electrical issues that literally disabled it and caused a lot of stress, when I took it in I was very up front about my budget and after a few hours I received a call with the diagnosed problem and a very transparent cost.”
View Profile
Chet's Auto Repair
“Fabulous as always!!”
View Profile
Trail Quest
- Suspension
- Work
- Job
“Stefan took many calls from me, met with my insurance adjuster and answered all of my questions along with squeezing my work in when they only had one tech working.”
View Profile
Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center
- Engine
- Manager
- Flat
“I had a check engine light indicating a failed knock sensor, took it in, and instead of just blindly replacing the sensor and charging me, they took the time to determine that the sensor itself wasn't actually faulty.”
View Profile
Garage 36
- Room
- Truck
- Oil
“I had this shop replace the starter on my Honda Fit last fall, they found the most efficient way to do the job without removing extra stuff and the cost came in a little lower than the quote.”
View Profile
ABC New & Used Tires
- Rim
- Brakes
- Drive
“The owner is an amazing guy and they actually repaired our tire, repainted our rim and installed a new valve stem all for free while they were fixing our brakes (Meanwhile AAA said we needed a whole new tire and new rim!!!”
View Profile
Alan Used & New Tires + Brakes
- Town
- Honest
- Light
“This is my favorite place to go when I need tires & mechanical services they are 1st come 1st serve the owner Hajar is a comedian guy but truly honest and a devoted person !”
Tire Repair Services in Westerville, OH Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$15
Maximum cost
$50
National Average
$25
$20
$40
Average price range is based on 470 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
FAQ
Which shops listed for Westerville offer financing on a full set?
Financing is mentioned on this page by 11 of the 24 shops. For tires that usually means a store card or a third-party plan with a promotional interest-free window. The number that matters is what the rate becomes when the window closes, so ask for it before you sign.