Best Tire Service near Middletown, NJ

These mechanics serve Middletown from nearby bases in towns including Brooklyn, NY, Staten Island, NY and Belford.

15 mechanics listed · 12 open weekends · 13 rated 4.5+

Data verified November 7, 2026

Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros

Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros

4.8 127 reviews
“They diagnosed my tire leak, rebalanced all of the tire pressure settings on the dashboard and recommended the next set of tires that would be cost-effective.”
Coupons & offersBBB accreditedSince 1949FinancingVirtual consultationsLocally owned
Staten Island, NY · 14 mi from Middletown
i
Bradley's Auto Service

Bradley's Auto Service

4.7 117 reviews
“Couldnt recommend more from the friendly staff to the highly skilled mechanics definitely have all my future business”
ASE certifiedSince 1977
Red Bank, NJ · 3 mi from Middletown
i
West Shore Tires & Auto Center

West Shore Tires & Auto Center

4.4 56 reviews
“Showed me the tire with the scew that it Couldn't be repaired was very honest.”
Coupons & offersBBB A+Since 1999
Staten Island, NY · 14 mi from Middletown
i
B&S Tire and Auto Service Center

B&S Tire and Auto Service Center

4.8 104 reviews
“Quick , Curteous, fair pricing and the improved waiting area is great!”
Since 2016Financing
Freehold, NJ · 16 mi from Middletown
i
Book onlineBook
TK Modern Auto Repair

TK Modern Auto Repair

4.6 117 reviews
“I've been bringing my cars here for a while the job always gets done and there customer service is always on point there honest and I truly appreciate these guys”
RepairPal-certifiedNew York inspection stationNew York license #7114790Hybrid & EV serviceInsurance claim helpWheel alignment $150
Brooklyn, NY · 19 mi from Middletown
i
Middletown Trailer Supply

Middletown Trailer Supply

4.9 110 reviews
“Zaf was amazing to work with super quick and responsive got me in and out in in 20 minutes and as a business owner time is everything I really appreciate it.”
Coupons & offersSince 2015Financing
Belford, NJ · 2 mi from Middletown
i

Listed for drivers in and around Middletown, NJ, these 15 shops handle tire rotation, balancing and sensor work. Services listed, hours and booking come from each shop's own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Getting tires installed near Middletown

The 15 mechanics on this page are rated from 4.4 to 5.0 across 4,767 reviews; 12 have 50 or more reviews and 13 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the mechanics on this page are "price" and "fair".

Do shops listed for Middletown book rotations or balancing online?

2 of the 15 shops on this page offer online booking. Rotation and balancing are short jobs, so a booked slot usually means a real appointment rather than a place in a queue. Say on the form if the car has pressure sensors, since that changes the tools they need out.

What federal rules say about car repair
Before you call: what to check and what to ask
Crown Tire

Crown Tire

4.6 100 reviews
“We needed a tire repair (new valve stem) quickly, and even though it was toward the end of the day and Crown was very busy, they took care of us.”
Coupons & offersSince 2005Financing
Port Monmouth, NJ · 3 mi from Middletown
i
Quicky Lube Plus III

Quicky Lube Plus III

4.6 51 reviews
“Best shop in the area, the owner has done been nothing short of fantastic”
ASE certified25+ years
Atlantic Highlands, NJ · 3 mi from Middletown
i
Tire Farm

Tire Farm

4.4 122 reviews
“They got the work done quickly and I just appreciate people being honest and they were.”
Coupons & offersSince 1988
Farmingdale, NJ · 13 mi from Middletown
i
Quick Stop Tire Shop

Quick Stop Tire Shop

4.7 69 reviews
“Mr,mo the most honest, friendly, and a professional tire person in brooklyn !!!!!”
Brooklyn, NY · 19 mi from Middletown
i
New York Auto Repair

New York Auto Repair

4.6 46 reviews
“Excellent customer service, everything was done fast and in professional manner.”
Since 1997
Brooklyn, NY · 19 mi from Middletown
i
Garden State Tire & Auto

Garden State Tire & Auto

4.8 46 reviews
“Small autorepair shop with knowledgeable mechanics, friendly people, and reasonable prices, I serviced 6 different cars there - never had any issues with the quality and timeliness of their work.”
Since 2012
West Long Branch, NJ · 8 mi from Middletown
i
Spare Tire

Spare Tire

5.0 1 review
“A lot of tires, very reasonable price”
Brooklyn, NY · 19 mi from Middletown
i
Hart Tire

Hart Tire

4.7 4 reviews
“Very easy to deal with great service”
Since 1996
Matawan, NJ · 7 mi from Middletown
i
Nik & Nate's Auto & Tire Center

Nik & Nate's Auto & Tire Center

4.8 25 reviews
“As a new customer I was extremely satisfied with Taylor work and dedication on restoring my 1985 Trans Am's engine performance back to its original capability.”
Since 1919
Howell, NJ · 16 mi from Middletown
i
HomeTire Service CenterNew JerseyMiddletown, NJ

Compare Tire Service near Middletown, NJ

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
Middletown Trailer Supply4.9 · 110 reviews · Belford
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–1Since 2015
Wil John's Tire Empire Tire Pros4.8 · 127 reviews · Staten Island
Mon–Fri 7:30–5:30 · Sat 7:30–4Since 1949
B&S Tire and Auto Service Center4.8 · 104 reviews · Freehold
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–5Since 2016
Crown Tire4.6 · 100 reviews · Port Monmouth
Mon–Fri 8–7 · Sat 8–5Since 2005
Garden State Tire & Auto4.8 · 46 reviews · West Long Branch
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–12Since 2012
Bradley's Auto Service4.7 · 117 reviews · Red Bank
Mon–Fri 8–5:30Since 1977
Nik & Nate's Auto & Tire Center4.8 · 25 reviews
Mon–Fri 8–5Since 1919
Quicky Lube Plus III4.6 · 51 reviews · Atlantic Highlands
Mon–Fri 8–325+ years
New York Auto Repair4.6 · 46 reviews · Brooklyn
Mon–Fri 8–7 · Sat 8–7 · Sun 9–5Since 1997
Tire Farm4.4 · 122 reviews · Farmingdale
Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 8–3Since 1988
West Shore Tires & Auto Center4.4 · 56 reviews · Staten Island
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–1Since 1999
Hart Tire4.7 · 4 reviews · Matawan
Mon–Fri 8–5 · Sat 8–12Since 1996
Quick Stop Tire Shop4.7 · 69 reviews · Brooklyn
Mon–Fri 7–6 · Sat 8–5 · Sun 8–5
TK Modern Auto Repair4.6 · 117 reviews · Brooklyn
Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 8–1
Spare Tire5.0 · 1 review · Brooklyn
Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 8–6

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo shop pays us anything. Nobody can buy a place, a higher spot or a Best of award.
Checked before listedPermanently closed shops, call centers posing as local garages and duplicate chain branches stay off our list.
Facts from the sourceWarranties, ASE certification and years in business come from each shop's own website, checked against that page.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months: hours, phone, website and reviews.

For Tire Service Center we compared 516 shops in and around Middletown. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then shops in Middletown, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top