Best Auto Repair in Lancaster, PA

20 professionals listed · all 20 in Lancaster · 3 open weekends · all 20 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 31, 2026

Nate's Automotive

Nate's Automotive

4.7 85 reviews
“I recently had my truck inspected and while this may seem like a small thing, they adjusted my headlights without me asking them to do so.”
3-yr warrantyFree estimatesHigh-performance automobiles specialistWalk-ins welcomeFleet accountsAfter-hours key drop
1713 New Holland Pike
i
Hallman's Silver Springs

Hallman's Silver Springs

4.8 68 reviews
“He was able to have a mechanic ride with me the very next day and within 1 mile the young man was able to diagnose the issue.”
BBB A+Since 1986
3569 Marietta Ave
i
Book onlineBook
McKonly's Garage

McKonly's Garage

4.9 130 reviews
“The best way to describe the Conley's garage is friendly, helpful, honest and reliable!”
5-yr warrantyDomestic and import specialistFinancing availableFleet accountsSince 1954BBB A+
3651 Horizon Dr
i
CNM Auto Repair

CNM Auto Repair

4.7 95 reviews
“This auto shop to me is the best in town, I do recommend all my friends to them they are very honest and upfront with out the dealer ship rip offs very friendly and trustworthy with all there work.”
Coupons & offersASE-certified techsSe habla españolSince 2010BBB A+
202 Seymour St
i
Gilbert's Automotive

Gilbert's Automotive

4.5 45 reviews
“Really great people to talk with, as a woman, I never know if a mechanic is being honest with me, here, they take time to explain, even show me what, if any parts/repairs are needed.”
Financing availableSince 1961BBB A+
32 Pitney Rd
i
Accurate Total Car Care

Accurate Total Car Care

4.6 118 reviews
“It was easy to schedule an appointment, they were able to get me in pretty quickly, and everything went smoothly.”
Coupons & offersSame-day serviceWalk-ins welcomeASE certifiedSince 2019Financing
1810 Columbia Ave
i

Listed for drivers in and around Lancaster, PA, these 20 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: Lancaster, PA

All 20 professionals we list here are in Lancaster itself. We have 49 professionals in Lancaster on file; this page shows the highest-rated 20. The professionals on this page are rated from 4.5 to 4.9 across 3,609 reviews; 18 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "price", "fair" and "communication". 3 are open on Saturdays. 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 7 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 17 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 93 years. 2 offer financing; 7 are family- or locally-owned and 4 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 19 of the professionals on this page; 15 publish a contact page; 10 list a public email and 6 take bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.

Which shops listed for Lancaster open on Saturdays?

3 of the 20 shops open on Saturdays. Saturday tends to mean drop-offs and short jobs. If the repair needs a part ordered in, the car will usually sit until the parts trucks run again on Monday.

Alex Gerz Radiator Co

Alex Gerz Radiator Co

4.6 42 reviews
“The prices here are very competitive and the personal service and care is refreshing in this time we are living in.”
Since 1918Family-ownedBBB A+
435 N Mulberry St
i
M & R Auto Center

M & R Auto Center

4.8 125 reviews
“They never try to upsell you on anything, and they are completely honest about what you need to have fixed, but they also will tell you what you need to keep an eye out for IF anything.”
Diesel serviceFleet accountsSince 1982Family-ownedInsurance accepted
535 E Ross St B
i
Autotech Lancaster

Autotech Lancaster

4.7 57 reviews
“I was able to get almost all of the service done over text which is fantastic as an autistic person.”
ASE certifiedSince 1997
620 E Mifflin St
i
Baker's Automotive LLC

Baker's Automotive LLC

4.9 73 reviews
“Tony is honest, very knowledgeable, and always takes good care of our vehicles.”
Since 2014
1810 Lincoln Hwy E
i
Steves Automotive Technology

Steves Automotive Technology

4.7 48 reviews
“Steve took his time and found exactly what was draining my wifes battery 10 outta 10 would definitely recommend”
Since 2014
1027 Dillerville Rd #16
i
C & W Imports

C & W Imports

4.7 65 reviews
“One of the very few places I can trust to bring my car & motorcycle for repairs, maintenance, and inspections.”
BBB A+Since 1984
872 N Prince St
i
Frank's Garage

Frank's Garage

4.5 38 reviews
“Super sweet and friendly, they did the work the next day and left my car in the lot for me to pick up that night.”
Pennsylvania inspection stationSince 1946
653 Union St
i
Daddario Tire & Auto Service

Daddario Tire & Auto Service

4.5 63 reviews
“Rich is very knowledgeable and always willing to help with all your automotive needs.”
Since 2013
1464 Manheim Pike
i
Conestoga Valley Automotive

Conestoga Valley Automotive

4.7 31 reviews
“I've used them for car inspections, a/c condenser replacement/recharge, valve cover gasket replacement and some other things”
Coupons & offersSince 2021Family-owned
2008-D Horseshoe Rd
i
Automotive Masters LLC

Automotive Masters LLC

4.9 32 reviews
“He showed us exactly what was wrong and the old pieces he took out.”
Since 2007Family-owned
2090 Lincoln Hwy E
i
Mike's Motor Zone

Mike's Motor Zone

4.9 124 reviews
“They repair things when it's feasible, not just replace them and don't "fix" things that aren't broke and charge me for it.”
36-mo/36k-mi warrantyLoaner carsSince 2008
2665 Lititz Pike
i
Froy's Auto Service LLC

Froy's Auto Service LLC

4.7 87 reviews
“They did a very good job on my car and the price was affordable”
Since 2008
555 New Holland Ave
i
Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care

Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care

4.7 88 reviews
“Excellent and quick service, gave a date to bring my vehicle in and a date to pick it up with everything being on time and fairly priced.”
Se habla españolSince 2016Locally owned
10 Witmer Rd
i
Primos Auto Repair

Primos Auto Repair

4.7 57 reviews
“I love this shop, everyone is so nice, they do good work at an honest price.”
533 Pacific Ave
i
HomeAuto Repair ShopsPennsylvaniaLancaster, PA

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top