Best Auto Repair in Lancaster, PA

Handpicked from 293 vetted & reviewed Automotive Repair professionals in the Lancaster area, explore the top 5 standout choices among the selected group of 23 finalists.

Steves Automotive Technology

Steves Automotive Technology

(20)
  • Job
  • Inspection
  • Quick
“Very friendly staff!”
In Business Since 2014
1027 Dillerville Rd #16, Lancaster, PA
i
CNM Auto Repair

CNM Auto Repair

(19)
  • Dealership
  • Job
  • Family
“I had a very excellent experience with CNM everyone there have excellent customer service and they always make sure that you vehicle is fix correctly and at a timely fashion.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2013
202 Seymour St, Lancaster, PA
i
Hallman's Silver Springs

Hallman's Silver Springs

(19)
  • Inspection
  • Prices
  • Vehicle
“Glad I found a shop I can trust.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1985
3569 Marietta Ave, Lancaster, PA
i
Manheim Tire & Auto Center

Manheim Tire & Auto Center

(19)
Schedule A Repair
“Good fair Prices fast service”
Coupons & Offers
Transparent Fees & Pricing
Free Initial Consultation
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Oxford Automotive

Oxford Automotive

(13)
Transmission Service, Diesel Repair & Service, State Inspection
“Nice and friendly place to have service done.”
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2021
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Best of 2023

Qualification Criteria for best of Winners

Minimum Overall Score
96 (100)
Minimum Reputation Rank
97.6 Percentile
All of our award winners are based on identifiable facts - reviews, performance, and experience - collected by scientific means. We use this data to assess each business’s essential features, weighting them according to their importance to customers.
Read our methodology
Prominent finalists
Hertzog's Garage

Hertzog's Garage

(20)
  • Prices
“Friendly and reliable service.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
In Business Since 1988
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Franklin Street Garage

Franklin Street Garage

(19)
Other Car Services, Brake Repair, Air Conditioning
“Was having problems with my car that another large shop on E Main St tried several times to fix and could not (but charged me a LOT to try) Todd found the problem right away and fixed it right the first time for a LOT less then the other shop was cha...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
In Business Since 1990
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Alex Gerz Radiator Co

Alex Gerz Radiator Co

(18)
  • Business
  • Price
  • Family
“And they love my 91 s10”
Family Business
Accepts Cash only
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1935
435 N Mulberry St, Lancaster, PA
i
McKonly's Garage Inc

McKonly's Garage Inc

(20)
  • Integrity
  • Reliable
  • Business
“We trust Mc Konly's, and they do a great job recommending and performing the services that we need to keep us on the road without worries at an affordable price.”
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1957
3651 Horizon Dr, Lancaster, PA
i
Gilbert's Automotive

Gilbert's Automotive

(19)
Oil Changes, Exhaust Systems Repaired, Electrical Systems Repaired
“They took my husband to the back and showed him the car on the lift and what would need to be fixed versus what the previous garage told us needed to be replaced.”
Offers Financing Options
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1964
32 Pitney Rd, Lancaster, PA
i
Conestoga Valley Automotive

Conestoga Valley Automotive

(20)
Preventative Maintenance, Oil Change, Electrical Repair
“I had to post this seeing some reviews if I dont have time to fix my ride I drop my vehicles off here and the jobs always done correctly I also wanna say thanks to all the hard workers there!”
Family Business
Coupons & Offers
In Business Since 2021
2008-D Horseshoe Rd, Lancaster, PA
i
Good's Auto Service

Good's Auto Service

(20)
Timing Belt Replacement, Shocks & Struts Replacement, Vehicle Fluid Flushes
“Technicians and service advisor are very patient with my many questions and my general lack of knowledge when it comes to anything technical/car related.”
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards, Check, Debit
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Roberts Automotive Inc.

Roberts Automotive Inc.

(20)
Fuel Induction Service, Transmission Repair, Brake Repair & Service
“I was looking for a new inspection station for my car, I had a very positive experience at Robert's, I didn't feel ripped off and the repairs were reasonable and done fast.”
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Automotive Masters LLC

Automotive Masters LLC

(19)
Waste Oil Drop-Off, Tpms Diagnostics, Electrical Diagnostics
“While we were at Dutch Wonderland, they quickly diagnosed the problem and performed quite a tricky fix, basically saving our engine and our entire road trip!”
Family Business
In Business Since 2007
2090 E Lincoln Hwy, Lancaster, PA
i
Autotech Lancaster

Autotech Lancaster

(20)
PA State Inspections, Drivability, Diagnostics
“When a work van was vandalized, the folks at Auto Tech went above and beyond to get it back on the road in half a week and communicated with insurance so that the claim went sailing through.”
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2019
620 E Mifflin St, Lancaster, PA
i
Heistand Automotive

Heistand Automotive

(20)
  • Expensive
  • Family
  • Quality
“Treated me like a first class citizen was fare on price compared to a bmw dealer down the road that wanted 5k for service bill that chuck got down for me less then 2k.”
Family Business
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2011
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Garman's Garage

Garman's Garage

(18)
Tire Rotation, Emissions Test, State Inspection
“They were reasonable on repair charges Although they were not able to fully fix my problem in the short time I had, they did diagnose it and I was able to drive it home and completed the repair today.”
Family Business
Accepts Debit
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1930
Serving Lancaster Area
i
M & R Auto Center

M & R Auto Center

(18)
Ecm & Pcm Programming, Ball Joints, Collision Repair and Auto Painting
“From securing an emergency procedure, to pre purchase inspection and yearly maintenance, M & R has given us countless hours of dependable service and advice.”
Family Business
Accepts Check, Cash, All Major Credit Cards, Insurance, Travelers checks, Debit
In Business Since 1984
535 E Ross St B, Lancaster, PA
i
Weaver's Garage

Weaver's Garage

(18)
Inspection & Diagnostic Services, Emission & Exhaust Systems, Wheels & Alignments
“The trust that is established, knowing the service is done correctly, sustains a confidence that is unparalleled to any other service provider in the area!”
Family Business
Coupons & Offers
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Warner Holdings LLC

Warner Holdings LLC

(20)
  • Job
  • Business
  • Family
“Replaced the water pump on my trailblazer was done quickly and haven't had a drop of coolant leak since, very friendly staff always go here for my inspections and any major issues”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1951
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Dale's Automotive

Dale's Automotive

(19)
  • Fluid
  • Job
  • Mechanic
“I met with Dale prior to scheduling my appointment and found him to be kind, respectful and able to answer all my questions and concerns about using an independent shop rather than the Subaru dealership.”
Coupons & Offers
Accepts Debit
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1996
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Singh Automotive

Singh Automotive

(19)
  • Charge
  • Tire
  • Price
“Out of any garage that I take my vehicle to they screwed me over or didn't do a good job i went to Singh automotive and they were very generous helpful and honest they save me a lot of money that I would have spent anywhere else I do recommend this p...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 1980
Serving Lancaster Area
i
Cain and Sons' Automotive

Cain and Sons' Automotive

(20)
Fleet Vehicle Maintenance, Suspension & Alignments, Tires
“My car had many issues that couldn't be fixed in one day, but they fixed what I thought was most important and even fixed some mistakes from another shop.”
Family Business
Coupons & Offers
Offers Financing Options
In Business Since 2012
Serving Lancaster Area
i

Auto Repair Services in Lancaster, PA Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$320
Maximum cost
$2666
National Average
$491
Avg Per Hour Rates
$86
$395
$693
Typical price range is based on 441 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $491
Minimum cost $320
Maximum cost $2666
Avg Per Hour Rates $86

Typical range $395 to $693 is based on 441 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top