Best Auto Repair in York, PA

21 professionals listed · all 21 in York · 3 open weekends · all 21 rated 4.5+ · 2 show a license

Data verified November 16, 2026

CR Smith Radiator and Auto Repair

CR Smith Radiator and Auto Repair

4.8 107 reviews
“My Hupmobile runs so cool now I may have to add a thermostat!”
Pennsylvania inspection stationSince 1956LicensedFamily-owned
2515 W Market St
i
Jim's Auto Repairing

Jim's Auto Repairing

4.8 76 reviews
“We have been working with Jim's Auto for a little over a year and have been extremely pleased with the exceptional customer service and quality auto services they have provided.”
Coupons & offersBBB A+Since 1944Financing
108 E 11th Ave
i
Bradford Automotive

Bradford Automotive

4.9 58 reviews
“My husband and I have been taking our cars there for years and highly recommend them!”
BBB A+Since 2002
1245 W Locust St
i
York Transmissions

York Transmissions

4.5 61 reviews
“Highly recommend this business, and if you choose to retain their services, you must realize that transmissions are complicated mechanical, electrical, and hydraulic systems, and to give them ample time to complete the repairs on your vehicle”
BBB A+Since 2012
2199 Bannister St
i
Pilgrim's Car Care Center

Pilgrim's Car Care Center

4.9 70 reviews
“They called me when it was giving issues just to let me know it was going to be more expensive than anticipated.”
BBB A+Since 2000Insurance accepted
367 Rose Ave
i
Stouch's Auto Repair Shop

Stouch's Auto Repair Shop

4.7 75 reviews
“Kristin (sp?) at the front desk was so warm and kind, I immediately felt a sense of relief being there.”
Coupons & offersSince 2002Family-ownedFinancing
221 N East St
i

Listed for drivers in and around York, PA, these 21 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.

Area overview: York, PA

All 21 professionals we list here are in York itself. We have 52 professionals in York on file; this page shows the highest-rated 21. The professionals on this page are rated from 4.5 to 4.9 across 3,758 reviews; all 21 have 50 or more reviews. The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "price", "honest" and "quality". 3 are open on Saturdays and 1 on Sundays. The services the professionals on this page list most often on their websites are alignments (2), brake repair (2), check engine light (2), engine repair (2) and oil change (2). 2 show a license on their websites; 2 list staff certifications (ASE) and 7 have a BBB rating of A or A+. 19 have ten or more years of experience, the longest 94 years. 5 offer financing; 1 gives free estimates; 6 are family- or locally-owned and 9 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for 20 of the professionals on this page; 16 publish a contact page; 13 list a public email and 6 take bookings online. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.

Do any shops listed for York let me spread repair costs?

Financing is offered by 5 of the 21 shops. It is normally a third-party credit line rather than the shop's own money, so read the interest terms before you sign anything. Settle the written estimate first and the payment plan second.

Quality Service Center

Quality Service Center

4.8 124 reviews
“Great customer service and really loved the inspection report they send you via Email and Text of all their findings with pictures and descriptions of each.”
Coupons & offers36-mo/36k-mi warrantyLoaner carsFinancing availableSince 1998ASE certified
28 S Oxford St
i
Kars

Kars

4.8 114 reviews
“Tom always takes care of me and doesn't try to upsell for no reason, or gouge prices.”
Coupons & offersFree consultationSince 2010Family-ownedFinancing
1985 Carlisle Rd
i
Al's Auto Parts & Service Inc.

Al's Auto Parts & Service Inc.

4.8 72 reviews
“Their solid and efficient service got us back on the road quickly so that we did not miss our appointment.”
Coupons & offersSince 1969
1301 N Sherman St
i
Witmer Automotive LLC

Witmer Automotive LLC

4.6 113 reviews
“They kept me informed of the situation and progress on a daily basis and were eager to explain the why and how of each service.”
Coupons & offersSince 2019Financing
1512 S George St
i
Fadely's Auto Masters

Fadely's Auto Masters

4.9 123 reviews
“Fadely's did an excellent job with my recent service; top-notch from the mechanics to customer service!”
Coupons & offersASE certifiedSince 1977Family-ownedFinancing
3177 W Market St
i
Skyline Drive Automotive

Skyline Drive Automotive

4.8 44 reviews
“When the light came back on a few days later, they got me back in immediatly and went above and beyond to make sure I made the 1000 mile drive back to Florida with no issues.”
BBB A+Since 1987
741 Skyline Dr
i
Queensgate Auto Sales

Queensgate Auto Sales

4.9 84 reviews
“Jean Carlos treated me very well, they did a good job on my vehicle!”
Since 2022
2609 N George St
i
Autocare Service Center

Autocare Service Center

4.8 125 reviews
“Fair pricing, fits us in the schedule in a convenient timely manner.”
Coupons & offersLicensedSince 1993
450 Loucks Rd
i
Finks Garage

Finks Garage

4.6 59 reviews
“Very good work lineaments, brakes, engine,oil changes.”
Since 1936Family-owned
929 Linden Ave
i
Trone Service Station

Trone Service Station

4.9 58 reviews
“Awesome service and very good work”
BBB A+Since 1986
2400 W Market St
i
Complete Automotive Repair & Service

Complete Automotive Repair & Service

4.7 95 reviews
“The car was in their hands for a while due to these factors and did need a 2nd pass at service due to a part issue which they replaced in a timely manner and under warranty.”
Since 2007
470 Allegheny Dr
i
Main Car Care

Main Car Care

4.9 65 reviews
“I have since moved out of the area, but went to them for years, always with a peace of mind that work would be done with excellence, and I'd be treated as a valued guest, not just a dollar sign.”
Coupons & offersSince 2015Family-owned
57 Locust Grove Rd
i
Ultimotive Service Center LLC

Ultimotive Service Center LLC

4.5 43 reviews
“Austin is a very diligent worker and was very straight forward with what my car needed and I got my car back as a good as new!”
Since 2012
2790 Woodberry Rd
i
L.J. Allen Tire & Auto Service

L.J. Allen Tire & Auto Service

4.8 62 reviews
“I have been taking my car there for a year or two and I have never had any issues with the work they do.”
Since 1932
104 Memory Ln
i
Anderson's Service Center

Anderson's Service Center

4.7 70 reviews
“Had a work truck break down this morning and Andy was there within 30 minutes.”
Since 1978
1214 W Market St
i
HomeAuto Repair ShopsPennsylvaniaYork, PA

Why these companies made our list

What customers say about professionals in York

  • “They quickly diagnosed the issue and even let me know that my repair was covered under an extended warranty I didn't know existed, which saved me a lot of money and stress.” — customer of Fadely's Auto Masters
  • “Will not take advantage of you. I recommend them to anyone who needs auto repairs and emergencies.” — customer of Main Car Care
  • “Price was what they quoted, also a good warranty to go with it.” — customer of York Transmissions
  • “Very fair and honest estimate for a convertible top and vehicle inspection.” — customer of Ultimotive Service Center LLC
  • “They did a great job and even replaced some parts under warranty and a few months out of warranty.” — customer of York Transmissions

Excerpts from public reviews of the professionals listed on this page.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top