Best Auto Repair in Oyster Bay, NY

The highest-rated Automotive Repair companies out of 132 vetted & reviewed in the Oyster Bay area.

Island Car Care

Island Car Care

(45)
  • Communication
  • Job
  • Oil
“I highly recommend Island Car Care because they offer quality comprehensive service inclusive of repairs, NYS inspection and registration, maintenance of your vehicle and most importantly knowledge.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
Family Business
In Business Since 2020
830 Bay St, Staten Island, NY
i
M B Automotive

M B Automotive

(49)
  • Driving
  • Reviews
  • Job
“When I first came here I was not sure exactly to expect, and come by as someone who was curious about the place, rather than a customer, they showed me around and told me all the in house things they're capable of doing.”
Free Initial Consultation
ASE, ASE Certified
In Business Since 2017
Family Business
1460 N Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY
i
Brightside Automotive Repair

Brightside Automotive Repair

(48)
NYS Inspections, Oil Changes, 24-Hour Emergency Towing
“When driving in from out of state to try and catch a ferry to Fire Island, my break calipers on the front ends blew and the breaks began to heat up quick and stick.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2017
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

Bay Shore Auto Radiator & Repairs

(50)
“Since it was a lot of work that needed to be done and some codes that had to be diagnosed by BMW, he did not charge me for the time that was spent on my vehicle.”
Family Business
In Business Since 2016
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
TK Modern Auto Repair

TK Modern Auto Repair

(45)
  • Fair
  • Oil
  • Mechanic
“Tim quickly diagnosed the issue and gave me a reasonable quote for ignition coil replacement and valve gasket cover, in at 9:30, out by 4:30, highly recommend”
Family Business
In Business Since 2022
221 Bay 37th St, Brooklyn, NY
i
True Street Performance

True Street Performance

(47)
  • Dealership
  • Review
  • Truck
“Aside from the competitive pricing and wealth of knowledge, they remember their customers, There's a welcoming voice answering the phone and Jim is always willing to give technical advise long after the work is completed to make sure your happy with ...”
In Business Since 2012
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

Joe Riscica's Auto Repair Inc

(47)
  • Matter
  • Communication
  • Team
“They are truthful and will let you know what needs to be done and what can wait, they don't take advantage of you unlike other mechanics looking to make a quick buck.”
Coupons & Offers
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2007
Family Business
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Sagamore Collision

Sagamore Collision

(45)
“From the moment of my accident, and all the way through the repair process, the team at Sagamore Collision was prompt, professional, and 100% attentive to all my concerns.”
In Business Since 2012
91 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY
i
Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

Lee Myles Transmissions & Autocare

(29)
Signs of Transmission Trouble, Transmission, Scheduled Maintenance
“I brought my 2003 Honda minivan in thinking the transmission needed to be rebuilt but Mark was so honest telling me all it needed was an electronic sensor component.”
Coupons & Offers
ASE Certified
In Business Since 2015
Family Business
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Jmr Garage

Jmr Garage

(21)
  • Price
“These guys are perfectionists and even went as far as to put someone in the driver seat to get the weight perfectly and alignment dead on I haven't seen attention to detail like this in a long time.”
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2015
214 N Fehr Way, Bay Shore, NY
i
D&G Auto Repair and Services

D&G Auto Repair and Services

(38)
  • Honest
  • Labor
  • Quality
“From a quick oil change to a more complicated service such as cooling system or exhaust system upgrade, D&G team of mechanics will get it done appropriately.”
In Business Since 2023
1924 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY
i
75th Street Auto Center

75th Street Auto Center

(48)
“I don't need to gratuitously diss local Ford Service, but they on the other hand have no customer service skills, constantly upsell, take forever, charge an arm and a leg, and are just awful to deal with.”
316 Bay Ridge Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY
i
Sunrise Collision and Towing

Sunrise Collision and Towing

(42)
  • Paint
  • Brand
  • Hospital
“I have been in a handful of accidents and every time have had nothing short of a horror story dealing with the body shops, rentals, and insurance companies.”
Accepts Debit, Check, Cash, All Major Credit Cards, Insurance
In Business Since 1988
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
John A Carucci Motors Inc

John A Carucci Motors Inc

(42)
  • Job
  • Photo
  • Inspection
“Been using John for years - he and Michael are great along with Oscar the mechanic - but, I guess they have decided it's time to relax - now we have Ricky who we already like - very nice guy good pricing and great work.”
1782 Union Blvd #1, Bay Shore, NY
i
All Island Auto Co

All Island Auto Co

(17)
“Very professional and excellent work.”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
Licensed, BBB Rating: A+
In Business Since 2006
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
David Auto Wreckers

David Auto Wreckers

(33)
“They have the best prices, i went to 3 location and because i was a woman they tried to rip me off but David's auto took care of me and work with me, no complains!!”
1368 E Bay Ave., Bronx, NY
i
Auto Imports

Auto Imports

(11)
Transmissions
“Positive Punctuality, Quality, Professionalism, Value Services Transmission, Air & cabin filter replacement, Exhaust, Steering & suspension repair, Brakes, Oil change”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
ASE Certified
In Business Since 1969
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Kevin Tire Repair Shop

Kevin Tire Repair Shop

(30)
  • Tires
  • Price
“What an experience as a woman had a flat had no other option than to go to the tire shop here a little hesitant, but I was treated with the upmost respect, they made me feel very welcome and safe.”
838 Bay St, Staten Island, NY
i
L & D Services Station Inc

L & D Services Station Inc

(21)
“It's very busy, the best part is they are honest not a lot of places like this left, I should be selfish and tell people to go elsewhere so the wait isn't so long but I can't they are to nice”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1969
723 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
i
Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.

Michael Anthony Auto Service Inc.

(15)
  • Prices
“They run a tight ship owner operated your in good hands”
In Business Since 2012
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Rev's Auto Services

Rev's Auto Services

(20)
  • Money
  • Vehicle
“Awesome place been using them for over 10 years me and my father have never had any issues Paul is very reasonable and understanding towards your problems and will work with you to fix that very standup guy would highly recommend others to come visit...”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
In Business Since 1996
91 Moffitt Blvd # A, Bay Shore, NY
i
Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

Gardfield Auto Repair Inc

(15)
  • Price
  • Mechanics
“They are fairly priced knowledgeable and very accommodating I used a mechanic for over 25 years till he retired so was quite nervous about trying someone new.”
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Tom's Vette Shop Inc

Tom's Vette Shop Inc

(5)
  • Prices
“I have known Tom for many many years , he knows his stuff and his prices are better then catalog prices , very nice person and he will give you great advice .”
In Business Since 1995
Serving Oyster Bay Area
i
Gomez Auto Repair

Gomez Auto Repair

(13)
“Great place”
Accepts All Major Credit Cards
102 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY
i

Auto Repair Services in Oyster Bay, NY Cost Estimates

Minimum cost
$370
Maximum cost
$3079
National Average
$567
Avg Per Hour Rates
$99
$456
$801
Typical price range is based on 274 cost profiles
Click to copy
Successfully copied!
Average Cost $567
Minimum cost $370
Maximum cost $3079
Avg Per Hour Rates $99

Typical range $456 to $801 is based on 274 cost profiles.

Why these companies made our list

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top