View Profile
Ricks Mufflerman Shops
“It is particularly worth mentioning that Rick single-handedly defeated the technician at Honda dealership, which totally mis-diagnosed the problem earlier.”
Best Auto Repair in St. Augustine, FL
24 professionals listed · 22 in St. Augustine · 4 open weekends · 23 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 17, 2026
View Profile
Turbofinish
- Bumper
- Technician
- Job
“I had what I thought was a scratch from a grocery cart that ended up being just a contact mark and they were kind enough to suggest using a specific cleaner and it came right off without any evidence of being there.”
View Profile
A-Ford-Able Automotive & Tire
- Truck
- Mechanic
- Price
“Jim knows how to run a solid shop, and obviously has vetted his employees well as every single person I had the pleasure of meeting was the right amount of friendly, and professional.”
View Profile
Atlantic Automotive and Quick Lube Center
“The next morning and we were from out of town they fixed our car within 2 hours with great customer service we were very satisfied and would recommend the shop to anyone”
View Profile
Velocity Motorwerks LLC
- BMW
- Communication
- Vehicle
“Brought my '99 911 in for maintenance and overdue repairs and couldn't be more pleased with the correspondence throughout, excellent work and the fair price for the repairs!”
View Profile
A+ Garage Complete Auto Repair
- Vehicle
- Job
- Price
“Brandon, Adam and the crew always do superb work at fair prices and would rather keep you future business by sending you elsewhere for repairs that may be beyond them than to take your money and not fix your problem!”
Listed for drivers in and around St. Augustine, FL, these 24 shops handle general repair work. What each one says about parts, warranties, financing and fleet accounts comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: St. Augustine, FL
Of the 24 professionals we list here, 22 are in St. Augustine itself and 2 come from Jacksonville (37 mi). The professionals on this page are rated from 4.3 to 5.0 across 7,010 reviews; all 24 have 50 or more reviews and 23 are rated 4.5 or higher. When customers rate these professionals on specific qualities, they most often praise quality (95%), professionalism (91%) and value (88%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the professionals on this page are "fair", "diagnosis" and "honest". 4 are open on Saturdays. The services the professionals on this page list most often on their websites are alignment (3), tires (3), RV service (2), fleet services (2) and towing (2). 9 list staff certifications (ASE). Domain records put 13 websites of the professionals on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 1997. 2 offer financing; 6 give free estimates; 6 are family- or locally-owned and 6 list coupons or special offers. We count these figures across the professionals on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the professional before you visit.
How long have the listed shops been open?
16 of the 24 shops show ten or more years in business. Longevity is not a guarantee of anything, but a repair shop that keeps the same sign over the same door for that long has generally been settling arguments rather than walking away from them.
View Profile
Melvin's Auto & Truck Repair
- Oil
- Mechanic
- RV
“When I put my 10 year old Silverado in the shop for an Oil Change a tire rotation, they check out everything as part of a preventive program they do.”
View Profile
Saint Augustine Auto Repair
- Vacation
- Work
- Price
“Their pricing is very fair, and they won't do more than you need, they'll explain what's wrong and will offer recommendations for repairs as well as offer quotes for work required.”
View Profile
Ray's Tire & Automotive
“The two people I interacted with, Angel at the service desk, and Mike, one of the technicians, helped me so much through an unfortunate outcome for one of our vehicles.”
View Profile
Sargeant Service Center
“Thank you so much Kevin and the Sargeant Service Center Crew 🔧 I just had my air conditioner fixed and it was so fast, great service and reasonably priced!”
View Profile
Ray's Commercial
“While traveling from up north we had a tire issue on I-95 on our RV, We called & talked to Chris & stopped in so he could look at them & due to the age & condition of our tires recommended replacing all 6 , we had a little time as we were staying in ...”
View Profile
Karr Doctor
- Mechanic
- Money
- Vehicle
“They replaced the passenger door i had the part but i was afraid to do it myself because you have to take the door panel off which includes taking off the power window/lock etc the mechanic did a great job and even cleaned my door panel better then I...”
View Profile
Ray's Collision Services
“I could not see where the ding was nor could I tell anything had been done at all - it looked better than it probably did fresh from the factory (and Ford isn't known for quality paint work).”
View Profile
Tire Outlet
“I was approved for financing with their Snap Program and they gave me a fantastic deal to where the total cost was completely covered by the financing program and at low payments.”
View Profile
1st Choice Automotive
- Vehicle
- Job
- Price
“5 star rating called and asked how much it would be to replace the engine if I brought my own (my cousin was able to get me a great hook up, I don't recommend this for most people)”
View Profile
Oldham's Automotive
- Mechanic
- Truck
- Price
“I get my oil changed regularly and tires rotated and everything is check under the hood and around my car to make sure it is ready for me to drive off their lot.”
View Profile
Asian & European Auto Services
- BMW
- Job
- Honest
“My husband and I have been through it with mechanics for our older Porsche cheyenne and each time we had work done a new seemingly unrelated issue would pop up and then we found Asian and European Auto Services.”
View Profile
A1A Auto Center
- Vehicle
- Diagnose
- Tire
“My daughter lives in Fla and had an issue with car she pulled in and they helped her immediately thank goodness they found her lug nuts all loose on her front tire they fixed her right up and sent her on her way”
View Profile
San Marco Paint and Body
- Insurance
- Job
- Price
“Very polite and they made it their priority to get my car completed any timely matter they were very nice and polite and did a very excellent job on my car”
View Profile
Beleesi's Garage
- Communication
- Diagnosis
- Price
“I have a minute Cooper which apparently need a lot of TLC , Benny was very knowledgeable and gave me advice that others haven't, I will go there always in the future, highly recommend!”
View Profile
Evans Automotive & Tire Center
“The very nice man at the register understood my dilemma and installed the battery in their parking lot ( because they had appt work in the garage) so I could get on my way quickly.”
View Profile
Poko Bro's Automotive Repair LLC
- Vehicle
- Money
- Price
“Also got my oil change there which was only $65 for full synthetic, which I thought was a good price, considering other places charge around $100 for full synthetic.”
View Profile
Daytona Auto Repair and A1 Transmission
- Mechanics
- Owner
- Prices
“We've been taking our Chevy Astro and Honda Pilot to Lee for five years and have found him to be knowledgeable, honest, fair and trustworthy, and he stands behind the work.”
View Profile
King Auto
- Name
- Knowing
- Price
“Had it in my possession a week later and took the car back to Corey, wherein he charged me $180 for labor (it would have been even less if I had communicated I didn't also need the tie rods fixed), and the turnaround time was only 3 hours for such an...”
Auto Repair Services in St. Augustine, FL Cost Estimates
Minimum cost
$300
Maximum cost
$2500
National Average
$460
Avg Per Hour Rates
$80
$370
$650
Typical price range is based on 326 cost profiles
Why these companies made our list
What customers say about professionals in St. Augustine
- “With a 2 year warranty on the repair and a fair price, I wholeheartedly recommend them.” — customer of Ray's Tire & Automotive
- “They worked with my warranty to get me an engine and several other needed repairs and it was quick turn around considering all they had to do.” — customer of Melvin's Auto & Truck Repair
- “Oldham’s is the only place I will be taking my out-of-warranty autos from now on.” — customer of Oldham's Automotive
- “Staff is friendly and knowledgeable, plus digital scheduling, estimates and work updates.” — customer of Velocity Motorwerks LLC
- “Eddie quickly diagnosed the issue, explained the repairs, and provided an estimated timeframe and cost.” — customer of A1A Auto Center
Excerpts from public reviews of the professionals listed on this page.
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
